Side Character Ships

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

Carrlene wrote: "Ooh I didn’t think about how he could help her. Also anyone think the whole balcony thing is suspicious? I feel like there’s more to that story sorta like Cyrah and the light leaping accident"

yeah, there are loads of theories going on about that. Like how Brant was secretly Marella's brother, and how he pushed Caprise off the balcony

[Carrlene Ray]

OH MY GOODNESS THAT COULD WORK

[Carrlene Ray]

OH MY GOODNESS DID ANYONE NOTICE THAT BRANT’S LAST NAME WAS REMOVED FROM UNLOCKED!? THAT COULD BE WHY

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

yep!

[[deleted user]]

I don't see how that would work, because technically, Brant was (key word here is WAS) Jolie's fiancee`, so wouldn't that mean that Sophie and Marella would be cousins? I don't think this is how it would work, but eh

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

they wouldn't be cousin's if Jolie and Brant were only engaged

[[deleted user]]

I was never good at the genetics stuff, so I'm probably wrong but anyway, since this is the discussion of side character ships, which one is your guys favorite? I say, Lylie (I know the age gap, but remember, Alden and Della are 100 years apart, and yet they still got married-)

[[deleted user]]

arwyn_d wrote: "i love how ive reread kotlc multiple times and yet you guys' theorys are still blowing my mind, yall are sosmart loll"

Lol same, I've reread all the books, and yet I still don't understand half of the theories you guys say

[Carrlene Ray]

Hold up, so if Brant is Marella’s brother, and Jolie was her fiancé, IF Brant and Jolie were to get married, that would make Marella Sophie’s cousin, right? Or would it make Marella her aunt? Anyways, so say that’s true... and say the Cassius/Caprise twin theory was true, Sophie would be related to Keefe (not by blood tho, and since Brant and Jolie were never technically married, it wouldn’t matter) but Brant could very well be Marella’s brother and Jolie would never have known since Marella was born right after Jolie died

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

I highly doubt that BOTH of the theories would be right

[[deleted user]]

If keefe and sophie are related, I'm suing because he would practically be in love with a relative-

[Carrlene Ray]

Yeah I agree, it’s purely hypothetical and I just think it would be funny to see how Keefe would react if they were “related” if he ever comes back... 🥺

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

and I'm pretty sure Marella would be Sophie's adoptive aunt, not cousin, if Jolie and Brant got married

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

Keefe and Sophie would (hypothetically) be related by adoption, and by a marriage that never even happened XD

[[deleted user]]

Carrlene wrote: "Yeah I agree, it’s purely hypothetical and I just think it would be funny to see how Keefe would react if they were “related” if he ever comes back... 🥺"

Don't say if he ever comes back, he WILL come back, or else the whole fandom is going to rage on Shannon

[[deleted user]]

Aҽɾιαʅ wrote: "Keefe and Sophie would (hypothetically) be related by adoption, and by a marriage that never even happened XD"

This genetic relationship stuff is hurting my brain-

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

if it is like that, that would make TONS of the characters be related to Sophie. it's like Once Upon a Time all over again

[[deleted user]]

Aҽɾιαʅ wrote: "if it is like that, that would make TONS of the characters be related to Sophie. it's like Once Upon a Time all over again"

Bahahaha, yes

[Carrlene Ray]

Yeah, Keefe is definitely coming back, let’s be real. But still. That means a whole lot of pages with a whole lot of no-Keefe. And without Sophitz moments to preoccupy me, I’m not sure I can handle that

[[deleted user]]

Carrlene wrote: "Yeah, Keefe is definitely coming back, let’s be real. But still. That means a whole lot of pages with a whole lot of no-Keefe. And without Sophitz moments to preoccupy me, I’m not sure I can handle..."

Same, I think what I'll do is when the 9th book comes out, I'll skip to the page where Sophie finds Keefe (which is inevitable at this point-) and read those pages, then go back to the no-keefe pages once my heart gets the Keefe it needs

[Carrlene Ray]

Yesssss literally Keefe doesn’t realize how many hearts he has the power to break 😂

[[deleted user]]

He is a heart-breaker, even if he 'claims' that he has never broken any hearts before in Neverseen

[Carrlene Ray]

OH KEEFE HUNNY U BE BREAKING THOUSANDS— THOUSANDS <-b> OF HEARTS

[Carrlene Ray]

Crap i forget how to un-bold the letters. Lemme try something. FITZ I LOVE YOU

[Carrlene Ray]

Ok we’re good

[[deleted user]]

Haha

[bookishcarli]

Clementine wrote: "Lylie is like frazel. I dont see how people cant ship it. Especially considering its the elven world where its not uncommon to have humongous age gaps."

No. The Frazel age gap is only 2 years, (the Lylie one is like 5 years im pretty sure) And plus Frank and Hazel actually canonically like each other, Linh and Wylie never mentioned crushes. Sure, Linh is extra nice to him, but she's extra nice to literally everyone.

[bookishcarli]

arwyn_d wrote: "Clementine wrote: "Lylie is like frazel. I dont see how people cant ship it. Especially considering its the elven world where its not uncommon to have humongous age gaps."

p e r i o d t t t i said..."

Yeah, but they're adults. They didn't start dating until Della was way older than Linh is. And i don't ship Della and Alden. I think their age gap is, though a bit weird, not necessarily that bad since elves can live practially forever. But I don't ship them, I think Della could do SO much better, I think Alden is a jerk

[Carrlene Ray]

I agree. I’m Lylie, but people always get upset by it. And yeah, I get where they’re coming from, but age and stuff like that is so much different in the Elvin world

[bookishcarli]

arwyn_d wrote: "and this is why i can never say i ship lylie"

I never said you couldn't ship Lylie. @clementine said "I dont see how people cant ship it." i was just saying my reasons for not shipping it. I'm fine with you shipping Lylie, I just personally don't like the ship. I think that it promotes pedophelia in books and is an overall bad ship. Sorry if i offended you, though. I was only trying to say my reasons for not liking it.

[[deleted user]]

Lylie is pretty cute, and if it happens I won't be mad, but, that being said, if Tam and Biana get together (which they will no doubt since Shannon lowkey comfirmed that in Unlocked because she said Biana had a thing for the silver bangs-) Dex and Linh could be cute- I mean that part in Nightfall when Tam told Dex 'Are you getting handsy with my sister Dizznee?' made me ship Dex and Linh, so Dex and Linh would be cute

[bookishcarli]

Varsh wrote: "Lylie is pretty cute, and if it happens I won't be mad, but, that being said, if Tam and Biana get together (which they will no doubt since Shannon lowkey comfirmed that in Unlocked because she sai..."

yeah i guess. They might be a good cinnamon roll ship. They'd be more like Frazel imo than Linh and Wylie would. But imo, i like Biana x Dex and Linh x Marella

[[deleted user]]

Linh x Marella would make the meme 'I set fire to the rain!' a reality

[bookishcarli]

Varsh wrote: "Linh x Marella would make the meme 'I set fire to the rain!' a reality"

hahaha yeah. That's why Linhella needs to be canon!

[[deleted user]]

Also, any Ninjago fans here? Because like, I legit think that Linh sorta looks like Nya-

[[deleted user]]

AnnabethChase wrote: "arwyn_d wrote: "and this is why i can never say i ship lylie"

I never said you couldn't ship Lylie. @clementine said "I dont see how people cant ship it." i was just saying my reasons for not ship..."

^^^^^^
lylie is fine WHEN they are BOTH adults

[[deleted user]]

Varsh wrote: "Also, any Ninjago fans here? Because like, I legit think that Linh sorta looks like Nya-"

nah linh is silvermist from tinkerbell

[bookishcarli]

Lemon wrote: "Varsh wrote: "Also, any Ninjago fans here? Because like, I legit think that Linh sorta looks like Nya-"

nah linh is silvermist from tinkerbell"

omg she totally is! Can't belive i didn't think about that before.

[[deleted user]]

AnnabethChase wrote: "Lemon wrote: "Varsh wrote: "Also, any Ninjago fans here? Because like, I legit think that Linh sorta looks like Nya-"

nah linh is silvermist from tinkerbell"

omg she totally is! Can't belive i di..."

Ahhhhh, now that I think about it, IT'S TOTALLY TRUE

[ƒαηgιяℓ_σνєяℓσα∂__(っ◔◡◔)っαυηтιєяσιѕмувαвуѕσвα¢кσƒƒ]

*watch sophie become a counciler so she doesn't have to deal with boy drama*
***single ladies by Beyonce plays in background***

[ƒαηgιяℓ_σνєяℓσα∂__(っ◔◡◔)っαυηтιєяσιѕмувαвуѕσвα¢кσƒƒ]

also Biana

[[deleted user]]

so PHi ANA

[Aҽɾιαʅ]

nah, I think Marella would become a councilor

[[deleted user]]

mmm Marella ?? she'd break like all the laws possible honestly

[ƒαηgιяℓ_σνєяℓσα∂__(っ◔◡◔)っαυηтιєяσιѕмувαвуѕσвα¢кσƒƒ]

ooo lets all post what we think everyone will do in future
Ex-Marella breaks all the laws

[[deleted user]]

FITZ OPENS A BAKERY
BIANA AND KEEFE OPEN A SALON
SOPHIE (still regent ig) OR A MENTOR
DEX TAKES OVER SLURPS AND BURPS (or) BECOMES THE BEST TECHNOPATH IN THE LOST CITIES
STINA WORKS AT THE SANCTUARY(or) TAKES OVER THE EQUESTRIAN STUFF

alternately
THEY ALL MOVE TO THE FORBIDDEN CITIES AND VIBE

[ƒαηgιяℓ_σνєяℓσα∂__(っ◔◡◔)っαυηтιєяσιѕмувαвуѕσвα¢кσƒƒ]

yesss
i cheer for the second one and the alternate one :)

[bookishcarli]

Lemon wrote: "FITZ OPENS A BAKERY
BIANA AND KEEFE OPEN A SALON
SOPHIE (still regent ig) OR A MENTOR
DEX TAKES OVER SLURPS AND BURPS (or) BECOMES THE BEST TECHNOPATH IN THE LOST CITIES
STINA WORKS AT THE SANCTUA..."

THE SALON OMG YEAH

[Carrlene Ray]

AHHH FITZ BAKERY! He’s the sweetest baker I love him

[bookishcarli]

arwyn_d wrote: "Carrlene wrote: "AHHH FITZ BAKERY! He’s the sweetest baker I love him"

im still shook that sophie thought him beaking rufflefluffs was the "greatest gift she's ever gotten" smh
*keefe crys in the..."

EXACTLY!! Keefe's were much more heartfelt, and Dex's saved her life on multiple occasions.