Goodreads Librarians Group discussion
Serieses!
>
Gone with the wind
date
newest »

If they are sold as a set (rather than each volume sold separately), they should have a single listing.
If they are sold as individual volumes, those should not be combined with the box set, or with volumes than contain the full book.
If they are sold as individual volumes, those should not be combined with the box set, or with volumes than contain the full book.

If the answer is yes, can you link the whole set to the original book so it can look like this http://prntscr.com/uny6xz instead of http://prntscr.com/uny767 ? It can be hard for my friends to see my rating and for me to see theirs. It looks like I've read a whole new book (or didn't read it at all because I read vol 1 and if I go to the original english page of the book it's listed as "read" but it's not the case for the page of the set I own, so probably it's not linked) just because I have a different edition. And some of the details are missing from the sets entry. The page number, the year it was published (2017), setting, characters etc etc.
If the answer is no and I can have them listed separately:
I don't know if it matters but in every book I found different ISBNs, the "main" one and the one specific to the book itself (vol 1 isbn, vol 2 isbn, vol 3 isbn).
I also found the other 2 books listed separately on Goodreads but it's kind of hard to work with.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5...
This one is the number two of the set, and it's not "linked" to the right set or to the original Gone with the wind, it's just an edition to another edition (kind of). The first link I posted ( https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4... ) it's linked to the right one. And in the title it doesn't say it's the second volume, so it was hard for me to find.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5...
Same for the 3rd book + the description is in another language.
I know maybe I give you a hard time and I'm so sorry but thank you so much for trying to help me understand this.
I found reviews (not so many but still) on all the "entries" of the books I put in here and it's sad because it should be in one place and maybe a review worth reading is hidden from where it should belong just because it was a misunderstanding. I know it's not your fault at all and I'm not blaming you for what's happening.
Lavs wrote: "So, just because I bought it as a set I should have just one entry for all 3 books?"
The question is not so much how you personally bought it, but how the publisher made it available for sale.
The question is not so much how you personally bought it, but how the publisher made it available for sale.
I have 3 books of "Gone with the wind" I and could only find one of them and it's not marked as "series". It should be one?
This is the first book:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4...
And I found this option with the box set I own instead:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/4...
So here they are combined. Should I add this version instead? But I'd like to have them separately. And the details are incomplete. Also, it's not related (marked as other edition) to Gone with the wind just like the first one.
https://www.litera.ro/catalog/product...
Here is where I bought the set from. If you need help with the info for the other 2 books I would gladly help you.
Thank you and have a nice day!