Omnibus/OHC Graphic Novel Collectors discussion
Comic Reading Discussion
>
What have you added to your collection recently?
message 1551:
by
Donovan
(new)
Oct 19, 2016 07:38AM

reply
|
flag


Hey Lee. I expected it to take a while but 4 and a half weeks is surely too long!?

I'm not sure. It really does take a long time, much longer than other US based suppliers I have ordered from in the past. Maybe send them an email just in case, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were en route somewhere and will be with you soon.



sure :D
Finished reading The Fade Out the other night. Good art and the story kept you wondering who did what and why. It's not a happy story (murder stories usually aren't). I could see this getting made into a movie with some tweaks. Def not for kids.
Honestly, I know Brubaker isn't excited about doing more super hero stories but I haven't liked any of his creator owned non-super hero work more than his super hero work.
Honestly, I know Brubaker isn't excited about doing more super hero stories but I haven't liked any of his creator owned non-super hero work more than his super hero work.
Relstuart wrote: "Finished reading The Fade Out the other night. Good art and the story kept you wondering who did what and why. It's not a happy story (murder stories usually aren't). I could see this getting made ..."
I was going to start reading it last night, but I'm forcing myself to plow through the rest of the Squadron Supreme Omnibus first.
Yeah, the stuff I've read has been good but not great. I'm also starting to feel that they are sort of the same crime story, wrapped in a different setting.
Criminal is still my favorite though of his indy stuff.
I was going to start reading it last night, but I'm forcing myself to plow through the rest of the Squadron Supreme Omnibus first.
Yeah, the stuff I've read has been good but not great. I'm also starting to feel that they are sort of the same crime story, wrapped in a different setting.
Criminal is still my favorite though of his indy stuff.
For anyone interested, I put together a poll to see how it works. If anyone has ideas for a fun poll, let me know.
https://www.goodreads.com/poll/list/1...
https://www.goodreads.com/poll/list/1...

I haven't read Velvet yet but I am really looking forward to it. I also have not read Criminal but I have read The Fade Out, Scene of the Crime, Sleeper, Fatale, and Incognito (super-heroish). Of all this non big two stuff, I like Incognito the best.
As a big Cap fan, I love Brubaker's Cap. The quality does dip in parts of his run but overall I'm very happy with it. He did finish strong with the Winter Soldier run. I also really enjoyed his Iron Fist, Daredevil, and The Books of Doom mini-series. His X-Men stuff was decent but pretty brief. Both his DD and his Cap have significantly influenced what we have seen with these characters on the big/small screen.
As a big Cap fan, I love Brubaker's Cap. The quality does dip in parts of his run but overall I'm very happy with it. He did finish strong with the Winter Soldier run. I also really enjoyed his Iron Fist, Daredevil, and The Books of Doom mini-series. His X-Men stuff was decent but pretty brief. Both his DD and his Cap have significantly influenced what we have seen with these characters on the big/small screen.

About the superhero stuff that he has done, I have only read Captain America and Daredevil. Captain America was great till the Captain America Lives omnibus. After that it became too convoluted for me and I jumped ship. The 1st Omnibus volume of Daredevil was superb and the second one was good but not great. Iron Fist is on my to read list for some time now.
I love how Brubaker brings the noir setting and tension even in a superhero book. Just love it.
I'm in line with Relstuart when it comes to Cap and Brubaker's run. DD and Iron Fist were ok to me, and Books of Doom was better.
Haven't read Fatale or Incognito and I'm looking forward to Fade Out (on my nightstand) and Velvet.
He is really a master at making "real" characters and pulling you into their lives. Even with Scene of the Crime you can see his talent.
Haven't read Fatale or Incognito and I'm looking forward to Fade Out (on my nightstand) and Velvet.
He is really a master at making "real" characters and pulling you into their lives. Even with Scene of the Crime you can see his talent.


Ronny, you owe it to yourself to try Brubaker. For a start, pick anything mentioned in the previous comments. I think we even have a recommendation link for Brubaker. Don't we BZ??
Saugata wrote: "I forgot his Catwoman run. Thanks for bringing it up. I liked it, I have read it some time ago have to read it again.
Ronny, you owe it to yourself to try Brubaker. For a start, pick anything menti..."
I forgot about his Catwoman run as well. There's also Gotham Central.
For superheroes there's also The Marvels Project.
We don't have a thread just for Brubaker but we do have the Crime and Mystery thread, where half of the top books are by him.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Maybe I need to go ahead and create a thread just for him...
Ronny, you owe it to yourself to try Brubaker. For a start, pick anything menti..."
I forgot about his Catwoman run as well. There's also Gotham Central.
For superheroes there's also The Marvels Project.
We don't have a thread just for Brubaker but we do have the Crime and Mystery thread, where half of the top books are by him.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Maybe I need to go ahead and create a thread just for him...

And Ive Got his fade out deluxe on my to buy list. Criminal and fatale i have heard of. The rest i dont know much about.

looking forward to be the happy owner of All 3. Omni's -I've been waiting that for a long time now.


Green Lantern Omnibus 1 by Geoff Johns
Uncanny X-Men Omnibus 2
Fade-Out Deluxe
Looking forward to getting into the GL Omnibus you've all spoken so highly about."
How is the print and binding on the Green Lantern omnibus? I really want that but have heard mixed reviews. I have the smalelr hardcovers but those stories and art are so great.

Nice. I'm in the middle of reading the Doc Strange Omnibus. Great stuff.

The binding seems to be holding up well so far, although it has made a few horrible cracking sounds that made me cringe when I heard them. I don't see any separation though. Due to the size and weight I've been treating it very gingerly.


Do you guys follow this process before reading a new omnibus? I would recommend it!
https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/...

I think I saw that years ago but I certainly don't do that. I kind of feel it should be designed and built in a way to handle normal usage for the uninitiated. But that could just be naivety on my part not knowing much about making books.



The x-men book have the tightest binding i have experienced so far.. damn it's tight.
No Clive Barker so far for me. I've heard good things about the Superman American Alien. I put it in my wish list on IST.
I just got the final volume of Locke and Key and the Empire of the Dead OHC. I was initially not at all interested in picking up the Empire of the Dead book but I saw Maleev did much of the art and decided to give it a look. It was pretty decent.
I just got the final volume of Locke and Key and the Empire of the Dead OHC. I was initially not at all interested in picking up the Empire of the Dead book but I saw Maleev did much of the art and decided to give it a look. It was pretty decent.

Ronny wrote: "Uncanny x-men omnibus 3 just arrived couple days ago, Im starting to own a pretty decent x-men collection i Think.. still missing a lot of really hard to get OOP material between This 3rd omnibus a..."
Updated pic of your collection?
Updated pic of your collection?



Today I come to you for your help in a matter I have zero knowledge, but care deeply, about.
My niece is going to be 6 next week, she is just learning to read and not so keen (I think impatient describes her better) on stories. So, I want to do what any story junkie uncle would do and gift her a (or a couple) wordless children's comic book for present. This is my secret ninja move to get her addicted to the magical world of stories in general and comics in particular.
After doing a lot of research I have zeroed in on The Only Child. Do you have any suggestions regarding this? I understand that this is a peculiar request, but I am depending on you. No pressure ;)
Books mentioned in this topic
Superman: The Coming of the Supermen (other topics)Batman: The War Years 1939-1945: Presenting over 20 classic full length Batman tales from the DC comics vault! (Volume 1) (other topics)
Superman/Shazam!: First Thunder (other topics)
Batman and Psychology: A Dark and Stormy Knight (other topics)
Nightwing: Mobbed Up (other topics)
More...