20.5 - Bigger is Better - MegSCL's Task: Cover Tropes

[Amanda]

Would work for option 3?

[Trish]

Morning. How about this for option 3?

[Meg]

Amanda wrote: "Would work for option 3?"

Yes that's OK

[Meg]

Trish wrote: "Morning. How about this for option 3?

"

That works

[Trish]

Great. Thank you.

[Mxshining]

Would this be alright for option 3?

[Rina]

Would this work for option 3? Thanks in advance

[Meg]

Mx.shining wrote: "Would this be alright for option 3?

"

Yes, that works

[Meg]

Rina wrote: "Would this work for option 3? Thanks in advance
"

Yes, that works

[Marty]

Is this cover acceptable for Option 3?

[Meg]

Marty wrote: "Is this cover acceptable for Option 3?
"

Yes that is fine

[Lauren]

Does this work for option 1?

Thanks!

[Wanda]

Would this work for options #1-Historical Fiction

[Meg]

Lauren wrote: "Does this work for option 1?

Thanks!"

That works

[Meg]

Wanda wrote: "Would this work for options #1-Historical Fiction

"

Sorry no, her body is turned too far to the side

[Ann A]

How about this for option 3? I wasn't sure, since it is a white AND gray background.

[Meg]

Ann A wrote: "How about this for option 3? I wasn't sure, since it is a white AND gray background.
"

That's fine. The white could count as a single object

[Ann A]

Meg wrote: "Ann A wrote: "How about this for option 3? I wasn't sure, since it is a white AND gray background.
"

That's fine. The white could count as a sing..."

Great! Thanks.

[Sarah Ruth]

How many images do you consider this to be? 1? 4? 8?

Wondering if this counts for option 3, but I am not optimistic... :)

[Meg]

Sarah Ruth wrote: "How many images do you consider this to be? 1? 4? 8?

Wondering if this counts for option 3, but I am not optimistic... :)

"

That's a tough call! But I can see how it could be interpreted as 1 image, so I'll allow it.

[Sara]

Does this one work for option 3?

[Meg]

Sara wrote: "Does this one work for option 3?

"

Yes that works

[Ed]

Will work for Option 3?

[Meg]

Ed wrote: "Will work for Option 3?"

Sorry no. I see background as a picture rather than a plain background.

[Sarah Ruth]

Meg wrote: "Sarah Ruth wrote: "How many images do you consider this to be? 1? 4? 8?

Wondering if this counts for option 3, but I am not optimistic... :)

"

T..."

Thanks!!

[Alex]

Does this work for option 2?

[Meg]

Alex wrote: "Does this work for option 2?
"

Yes that works - and I've heard it is excellent!

[Sandy, Moderator Emeritus]

For option 1, this is a little different - is historical fiction, and the people on the cover have their backs turned. Does it matter that the people are in a little blurb advertising her as the author of ?

[Meg]

Sandy wrote: "For option 1, this is a little different - is historical fiction, and the people on the cover have their backs turned. Does it matter that the people a..."

It technically works - I didn't specify how big or central the people had to be

[Alex]

Meg wrote: "Alex wrote: "Does this work for option 2?
"

Yes that works - and I've heard it is excellent!"

Great!! Thank you...looking forward to reading it! :)

[Cindie]

Does this work: ?

[Meg]

Cindie wrote: "Does this work: ?"

Yes

[Cindie]

Meg wrote: "Cindie wrote: "Does this work: ?"

Yes"

thanks!

[TraceyL]

Does this book work for Option 3?:



Since it's a piece of paper with a doodle on it, I'm just making sure that it counts as one image and not two.

[Meg]

TraceyL wrote: "Does this book work for Option 3?:



Since it's a piece of paper with a doodle on it, I'm just making sure that it counts as on..."

Yes, that looks good

[TraceyL]

Thanks for the quick reply!

[Whitnie]

Would this book work for option #3

[Meg]

Whitnie wrote: "Would this book work for option #3 "

Sorry no, it is yellow/brown rather than off-white

[Bucket]

Is this okay for option 3? Thanks!

[Meg]

Bucket wrote: "Is this okay for option 3? Thanks!

"

yes looks good

[Ed]

For option 3, could I get approval for please?

[Meg]

Ed wrote: "For option 3, could I get approval for please?"

Sorry, the cover is a picture, rather than an object on a plain background. Also, it's fiction so wouldn't work anyway.

[S.L.]

For option 3 does the below work?

[Meg]

S.L. wrote: "For option 3 does the below work?

"

Sorry, I'll have to say no. The portrait and the lines on the background will both count as images

[Claire]

Is there too much going on in this one for option 3?

[Meg]

Option 3 requires non fiction

[Claire]

Meg wrote: "Option 3 requires non fiction"

Thanks for that, should have read it properly!

[Sue]

Does work for option 3?

[Meg]

Sue wrote: "Does work for option 3?"

Yes that will work

[Marie-Anne]

The instruction say: "back to you". What about ? The back is completely to the reader, even though the head is turned.

Thank you.