Fantasy Book Club discussion

157 views
General Chit-Chat > Does anyone besides me have a min page req to bother with a book?

Comments Showing 51-60 of 60 (60 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Mili (last edited May 09, 2015 04:34AM) (new)

Mili (miliness) First I thought I need to pick out larger books, but recently I also read some, although easy reads, interesting plots in smaller form. So it honestly doesn't matter to me anymore. It stays a gamble if its a 'fun' book~


message 52: by Michele (new)

Michele If a tv show was only one episode long - then I don't think I'd bother to watch it. The fact is a tv show goes on and on.

I don't think you can compare reading to a tv show or a movie or a play - timewise - because if you took a movie and wrote it down, including all the descriptions and emotions and yadda yadda, it's going to be longer than a short story and it's going to take longer than two hours to read.

I don't think there's anything wrong with short stories, and I doubt they're unsatisfying to lots of people. I just prefer something longer. When I read I want to get lost in a world, and you just can't do that with a story 2000 words long.


message 53: by Sonia (new)

Sonia Lal | 19 comments hmm. no. I think books can be well done at any length


message 54: by Tyler (new)

Tyler Watkins (tilurwatki) I think the length of a novel is irrelevant to how good a story is. Some authors can pack a lot into a short novel, while others may take a little more time to get the point across. Not a bad thing! Also depends on if you like to take your time worth a novel or be done with it in only a day or two.


message 55: by Maarit (last edited May 11, 2015 06:55AM) (new)

Maarit I don't mind how long the book is as long as it's interesting enough for me to start it and finish it. Though if the book is long enough (let's say 700+ pages) I tend to freeze with it and read something shorter to get back in the mood for reading the long book (that's why I have four or more books in my currently reading section).

I also don't mind short stories as they can be good in their own way and I read them too, from time to time. Though I admit that single short story is not usually enough and that's why I read short story collections mostly.


message 56: by Stewart (new)

Stewart Boyatt I am on the opposite end of the spectrum right now. I am sick and tired of unending series of giant tomes. I sort of feel like it is more artful and impressive to write a satisfying stand alone novel in 250 pages. Am I left wanting more? you betcha, but longing is not a bad place to be.


message 57: by Lára (new)

Lára  | 479 comments I seriously don´t have a page req at all. I adore shorth stories, so it might be because :D


message 58: by James (new)

James Joyce (james_patrick_joyce) | 12 comments Stewart wrote: "Am I left wanting more? you betcha, but longing is not a bad place to be."

Exactly.


message 59: by Famine (new)

Famine (wolfcreed) Anything less than 300, I feel cheated.


message 60: by L.G. (new)

L.G. Estrella | 138 comments I will read almost anything of almost any length. Sometimes, I'm in the mood for something longer, something I can read and think about for days, even weeks. Other times, I'm in the mood for something quick and easy, something I can get through quickly.

I enjoy video games too, and sometimes you want Tetris, and sometimes you want an involved, long RPG.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top