Good Talk: A Memoir in Conversations Good Talk question


24 views
Is this appropriate for a HS library?
Mary Mary Nov 11, 2019 05:54AM
I'm cool with this book in the library, but do you think parents will take gas? How questionable can it be, onsidering that Celeste Ng and Jacqueline Woodson praised it? Parents can be weird, though (you don't know the same child I do) and even Follett limits (censors) the books made available to school libraries. Thanks



I can't see any reason why this book would be inappropriate for a HS library.


There is sex and nudity in it. There is also cuss words too.


In my humble opinion, this should not just be in high school libraries, but MANDATORY reading in all high schools. It won't be, but a girl can dream! (Mom of two, ages 21 and 12). Actually, I just encouraged my tween to read it. This is a smart, important book, timely, full of heart and hope. Honestly, there's likely more objectionable material in any given episode of Riverdale, so...

F 25x33
Mary I rarely think anything that I question should not be in a hs library because I think most YA is dreck and not particularly rewarding, but I like to h ...more
Dec 30, 2019 02:21PM · flag
18621751
Madelene Antrim :)
As someone who had to sneak books home like Ragtime and The Handmaids Tale as a young teen, I feel your pain.

Jan 04, 2020 10:03PM · flag

I don't remember anything hugely controversial about it. I think HS can handle these topics.


back to top