Goodreads Choice Awards 2025

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Harry Potter, #7) Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows discussion


368 views
Who to Save Elimination Game

Comments Showing 351-400 of 2,055 (2055 new)    post a comment »
1 2 3 4 5 6 8 10 11 12 … 41 42
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 351: by Abby (new)
May 19, 2015 06:03AM

Abby Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 352: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 4 stars
May 19, 2015 06:19AM

Alyssa Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 76
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 353: by Abby (new)
May 19, 2015 06:20AM

Abby Bathilda Bagshot: 4
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 3
Remus Lupin: 76
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 354: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 07:18AM

Lianne Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 76
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 355: by Aero (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 10:09AM

Aero Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 12
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 356: by [deleted user] (new)
May 19, 2015 10:18AM

OMG Hedwig???? Seriously people?!?!?! It's HEDWIG!!!!!

Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 357: by Abby (new)
May 19, 2015 10:22AM

Abby BATHILDA BAGSHOT IS AN ACTUAL HUMAN BEING. THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH HER AND SHE DESERVES TO BE ON THIS LIST LONGER THAN A PET.

Bathilda Bagshot: 4
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 358: by [deleted user] (new)
May 19, 2015 10:25AM

Hedwig tried to save Harry's life. Plus, Bagshot was working for Voldemort.
And pet's are WAY easier to be with than humans. Lock your dog outside for an hour and do the same with your friend. Open up the door after the time limit and see who still loves you.

Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 359: by Abby (last edited May 19, 2015 10:33AM) (new)
May 19, 2015 10:32AM

Abby Hedwig was a very loyal pet to Harry, I'm not trying to deny that. And what exactly do you mean that Bathilda was working for Voldemort? I'm 99% sure she wasn't, in the book or movie. I'm fairly sure the scene you may be thinking of was in the Deathly Hallows and Bathilda was dead; her body was animated by Voldemort using Nagina. There was never any mention of her working for Voldemort.

Bathilda Bagshot: 4
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 360: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 10:36AM

Lianne We don't know Bathilda, but we do know Hedwig. I care for Hedwig way more then for Bathilda!

Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 361: by Abby (new)
May 19, 2015 10:44AM

Abby It depends exactly on what you mean by "knowing" a character. We do know that Bathilda Bagshot was friends or at least close enough to Lily Potter to come to Harry's First Birthday; proof here:
"We had a very quiet birthday tea, just us and old Bathilda, who has always been sweet to us, and who dotes on Harry. […] Bathilda drops in most days, she's a fascinating old thing with the most amazing stories about Dumbledore,"

I, personally, just don't feel comfortable saying that I would rather chose to save an animal than a human being.

Bathilda Bagshot: 4
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 4
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 362: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 12:27PM

Lianne It bassicaly means that Hedwig is way more important in the story then Bathilda Bagshot and therefore it's easyer to care about Hedwig then Bathilda. Honestly, I had to look up who Bathilda was, because I didn't know who she was. Okay, her name is diffent in my languages, but that's besides the point. Hedwig is there in all books!

Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 11
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 363: by Aero (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 01:03PM

Aero Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 78
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 10
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 77


message 364: by Carolín (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 01:23PM

Carolín Bathilda Bagshot: 2
Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 78
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 10
Nymphadora Tonks: 62
Fred Weasley: 78


message 365: by Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 03:14PM

Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past Bathilda Bagshot: 3
Sirius Black: 48
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 29
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 73
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 12
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 77


message 366: by Nikki (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 06:42PM

Nikki Bathilda Bagshot: 2
Sirius Black: 48
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 29
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 73
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 12
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 78


message 367: by Caron (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 07:10PM

Caron Bathilda Bagshot: 1
Sirius Black: 48
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 29
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 73
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 12
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 79


message 368: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 11:44PM

Lianne Bathilda Bagshot: OUT
Sirius Black: 48
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 29
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 73
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 13
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 79


message 369: by Caron (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 19, 2015 11:57PM

Caron Sirius Black: 48
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 30
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 73
Alastor Moody: 18
James Potter: 12
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 79


message 370: by Lianne (last edited May 20, 2015 01:11AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 20, 2015 01:10AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 30
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 73
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 12
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 79


message 371: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 4 stars
May 20, 2015 04:44AM

Alyssa @Christie: Gurl did you change every character's points?

Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 30
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 74
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 11
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 79


message 372: by Caron (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 20, 2015 04:58AM

Caron Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 22
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 74
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 79


message 373: by Abby (new)
May 20, 2015 05:50AM

Abby Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 31
Albus Dumbledore: 21
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 74
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 37
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 80


message 374: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 20, 2015 07:53AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 32
Albus Dumbledore: 21
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 74
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 80


message 375: by Aero (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 20, 2015 09:18AM

Aero Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 32
Albus Dumbledore: 21
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 80


message 376: by Abby (new)
May 20, 2015 09:20AM

Abby Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 32
Albus Dumbledore: 20
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 81


message 377: by [deleted user] (new)
May 20, 2015 10:07AM

Go Hedwig!!!

Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 32
Albus Dumbledore: 20
Hedwig: 8
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 12
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 81


message 378: by Abby (new)
May 20, 2015 10:49AM

Abby Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 32
Albus Dumbledore: 20
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 17
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 81


message 379: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 20, 2015 11:07AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 20
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 16
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 81


message 380: by Abby (new)
May 20, 2015 11:17AM

Abby Sirius Black: 49
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 16
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 36
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 82


message 381: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 21, 2015 01:12AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 75
Alastor Moody: 16
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 35
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 82


message 382: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 4 stars
May 21, 2015 05:01AM

Alyssa Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 7
Remus Lupin: 76
Alastor Moody: 16
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 35
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 82


message 383: by Abby (new)
May 21, 2015 05:52AM

Abby Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 76
Alastor Moody: 16
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 35
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 83


message 384: by Aero (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 21, 2015 10:19AM

Aero Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 16
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 35
Severus Snape: 12
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 83


message 385: by Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 21, 2015 03:55PM

Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 33
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 35
Severus Snape: 12
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 84


message 386: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 03:17AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 34
Severus Snape: 12
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 84


message 387: by Kelly (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 03:18AM

Kelly irius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 8
Lily Potter: 34
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 84


message 388: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 03:27AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 33
Severus Snape: 13
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 84


message 389: by Kelly (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 03:31AM

Kelly Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 32
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 84


message 390: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 07:36AM

Lianne Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 31
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 85


message 391: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 4 stars
May 22, 2015 08:11AM

Alyssa Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 78
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 8
Lily Potter: 31
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 85


message 392: by Abby (new)
May 22, 2015 08:42AM

Abby Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 78
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 31
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 85


message 393: by [deleted user] (new)
May 22, 2015 10:21AM

Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 78
Alastor Moody: 15
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 31
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 60
Fred Weasley: 85


message 394: by Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 12:39PM

Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 14
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 32
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 85


message 395: by Lianne (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 12:58PM

Lianne Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 13
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 32
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 85


message 396: by Abby (new)
May 22, 2015 01:15PM

Abby Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 13
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 32
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 86


message 397: by Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 22, 2015 06:35PM

Cristie of Crops and Craps and Things Long Since Past Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 5
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 12
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 32
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 61
Fred Weasley: 87


message 398: by [deleted user] (new)
May 22, 2015 08:49PM

Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 12
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 32
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 60
Fred Weasley: 87


message 399: by ❀ Sabina (new) - rated it 4 stars
May 23, 2015 04:56AM

❀ Sabina Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 34
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 12
James Potter: 10
Lily Potter: 31
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 60
Fred Weasley: 88


message 400: by Caron (new) - rated it 5 stars
May 23, 2015 04:57AM

Caron Sabina
249 books | 14 friends
Sirius Black: 50
Cedric Diggory: 26
Dobby: 35
Albus Dumbledore: 19
Hedwig: 6
Remus Lupin: 77
Alastor Moody: 12
James Potter: 9
Lily Potter: 31
Severus Snape: 14
Nymphadora Tonks: 60
Fred Weasley: 88


1 2 3 4 5 6 8 10 11 12 … 41 42
back to top

all discussions on this book | post a new topic


Books mentioned in this topic

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (other topics)