Harry Potter discussion
James Potter
>
James and Lily, or Lily and Severus?
date
newest »
newest »
message 151:
by
Julia
(new)
Feb 16, 2024 11:24AM
I've started another discussion in this group now on the topic of Patronus form.
reply
|
flag
Julia wrote: "I've started another discussion in this group now on the topic of Patronus form."Cool! =) sorry if I seemed a bit intense during this argument LOL, I just tend to get too into things.
Julia wrote: "I've started another discussion in this group now on the topic of Patronus form."Cool! =) sorry if I seemed a bit intense during this argument LOL, I just tend to get too into things.
No worries, I get very passionate as well. Thanks for joining the other chat. :)
That’s hard but I have to close lily and Severus
I am guessing you don’t like Snape 😂
James and Lily; Lily didn’t love Severus.
Lily deserved better than either of them. Like would you rather date a bully or a death eater. Like Snape is worse, but neither of them were good for her.
I gotta say James and Lily, ONLY BECAUSE of the whole “you can kill all muggles, I’ll HELP you, just don’t touch Lily, you can even kill her KID” I just can’t stand by that, Lily deserves better.
James and lily, We cannot forget that if these two had not gotten married, Harry Potter would not have existed.
I think the only reason Lily married James anyway was because of the prophesy. She knew the child would be powerful. I’m totally team Snape here!
I think the prophecy only came out after Harry and Neville were born...?
Yes, and, it was V himself who decided it was Harry and not Neville. No idea why. The only people who heard the prophecy were Dumbledore, and Snape, and Snape told V. Otherwise, Dumbledore might’ve told Lily and James once they were in danger, but again, Harry was already born.
Dumbledore thought the reason Voldemort chose Harry was because they were both half-bloods (Voldemort's father was a muggle and Lily was a muggle-born witch).Dumbledore told Lily and James they were in danger. They assigned Pettigrew as their Secret Keeper to protect them from Voldemort, but Pettigrew betrayed them.
Huh, I didn’t realize that being a “pure blood” was what saved Neville. Interesting…
Jily for life
james and lily it made the plot also the pensieve with James and severus in the fifth book was my favorite plot line
I understand Severus very much, although I don't explain him - I honestly don't like him. I love James, but I'm aware that he also made a lot of mistakes. However, I think that he was the one that suited Lily better (yes, I also love Jegulus).
I don’t like Snape, he's a terrible character, yes he’s a double agent, yes he feels bad but you can’t just say sorry and make everything okay, plus he bully’s children and is overall a bad character, and James matured and died for lily, he would still be alive if it weren’t for Snape, Snape never matured he still held a grudge. So definitely Lily and James.
