Goodreads Librarians Group discussion
Questions (not edit requests)
>
duplicate editions
date
newest »


There is nothing wrong with reviewing different editions.

Is the book available as an ebook from any other vendors besides Amazon- BN, Kobo, etc.?
And users are free to review a book as many times as they like, no matter what the edition.

No, the ebook is only on amazon. I enrolled in a 90 day ebook exclusive with amazon. There is a print-on-demand paperback version (same edition) available at Ingram and Amazon.
Oh, I didn't know users could review the same book as many times as they liked. Thanks for your reply.

No, the ebook is only on amazon. I enrolled in a 90 day ebook exclusive with amazon. There is a print-on-demand paperback version (same edition) available at Ingram and Amazon.
Oh, ..."
Okay, I can merge the duplicate ebook edition then. Amazon uses an ASIN rather than an ISBN for Kindle editions, so the ISBN ebook edition would only be listed if it had been published/available elsewhere.
I've queued the merge, it may be a little while before you see the duplicate edition disappear.

Should Netgalley edition be added as a separate edition considering it's a subscription site for forthcoming titles??
The ISBNs used on NetGalley are usually the same ones that will be used on other sites when the ebook goes on sale.
I tried to combine the editions myself from the author dashboard, but there was no way to select both "editions". I received an error message that "I must select at least two works to combine."
I only noticed this because a user posted two reviews (one to each edition) of the same ebook. Can a librarian correct this, or is there something else I need to do - like edit the publication dates so they match? Not sure why the dates are different.
thanks for your help.