Peter v Josh

[Paige]

Peter for sure. not only is he the best thing ever BUT also because if josh really liked laura jean he wouldn't have gotten with Margot.

It's THAT SIMPLE!

[Emma]

John

[Odalis]

josh es alguien inportante en la vida de l.j es alguien que la conoce pero Peter no conoce de la misma manera a l.j pero sin duda Peter porque el se esfuerza por conocer a la nuva l.j en cambio Josh no asimila que l.j cambio un poco y por no darle una opurtunidad la aleja

[Lela]

I don't like Peter at all, I think their relationship was forced, which it obviously it was. Also Peter continuously defends Gen even though she's a toxic person, and often chooses her over Laura Jean, which kinda shows that he's not really over her. Josh and Laura Jean have much more chemistry but I don't really like them together either. I think she should have either remained single or get together with one of the other nicer dudes.

[Odalis]

No creo que la relacion entre Peter fuera forzada pero si un sobre poco apresurada , pero Peter siempre puso a la Gen sobre todo hasta encima de las cosas que le inportaban y se gustificaba diciendo que que ella era su amiga y que la estaba pasao mal .

[Daniel]

I like both, but I also think that both are really stupid...

I'll vote for Peter K. he's sweet, and he has not slept with Margot (LOL)

[Zoe]

Peter K, there is literally nothing between Josh and Laura Jean and he dated Margot so even if he likes Laura Jean it's a big nope(he should know that and shouldn't have done it in the first place).

But to be completely honest... I reaaaallllyyy can not tell AT ALL whether or not he actually likes LJ. At all. Really. Especially at the end of the book where he just casually accepts her letter, playing it off with 'a joke'.
There are some times when what he does makes me be like awwwwwww but I can't tell if he sincerely likes her!

This is the one and only time I prefer the movie(it's on Netflix) over the book because it's really obvious that Peter likes her). Honestly kinda prefer her character there more as well.

[Laney]

sorry y'all but i have to go with peter. there's something about him that makes him the perfect fit for laura jean. he makes her go out of her comfort zone, but not too much. Josh is like a brother to her. she might not have thought about him like that in the past, but he dated her sister and he's just the boy next door. i love peter and josh, but kavinsky has stole my heart in this book.

[Irene]

PETER,I don´t have any doubt about it.I mean,Josh should had done something when he had a crush on Lara J. But he didn´t do nothing and he prefered to had a date with her sister.
Okey,Peter sometimes is silly,but he is so cute and he takes care about Lara Jean a lot and that is really cute :D

[Kat]

I think the real answer is John Ambrose McClaren

[willow]

i loved josh in the books but i hated who they cast for the 2nd movie :(

[emily]

I agree, I don't like how Josh was portrayed in the movie, but I really liked him in the book. Although..... Must admit, I'm a Peter K fan all the way

[Sasha]

I'm Team Peter forever!
But I really like Josh in the book, but not so much in the movie.

[Kate]

Peter! Josh seems confused, after just leaving a long term relationship. Josh may make her feel like she could do anything, but Peter is the one who makes her know she could.

[Abby Elizabeth]

PETER!!!!!
(mainly because I kinda had a crush on him too)

[Emily]

Peter K all of the way because as you keep reading you find out that he actually sees Lara Jean and chooses her over any other girl while Josh overlooked her and only thinks of her as the innocent girl next door.

[Ishita]

PETER all the way!!!!!!!!

[Lu'Lu']

I am team Peter, because Peter really has feelings for Lara, meanwhile Josh just broke up with Margot, who's Lara's sister and I think Josh doesn't really have feelings for Lara. Let Josh be Lara's old crush and Peter win her heart.