We’re keeping this as simple as possible. There are only two rules really: NO RECIPROCAL REVIEWS HONESTY IN REVIEWS The rest is designed to make those 2 principles work as smoothly as possible. The initial aim is for authors to support each other with reviews, but avoid, as far as possible, suspicion of cronyism. Hence the ban on reciprocity.
Debating is stimulating and opens the mind to new ideas but we will not allow insults or personal attacks, either in reviews or on group threads.
Finally, it’s not a rule but a hope that we can all have some fun together :)
We’re keeping this as simple as possible. There are only two rules really:
NO RECIPROCAL REVIEWS
HONESTY IN REVIEWS
The rest is designed to make those 2 principles work as smoothly as possible. The initial aim is for authors to support each other with reviews, but avoid, as far as possible, suspicion of cronyism. Hence the ban on reciprocity.
Debating is stimulating and opens the mind to new ideas but we will not allow insults or personal attacks, either in reviews or on group threads.
Finally, it’s not a rule but a hope that we can all have some fun together :)