2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion
This topic is about
Murder on Marble Row
Murder on Marble Row
>
Question H
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jonetta
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jun 03, 2018 09:48PM
Mod
reply
|
flag
I was very impressed that the Isenberg boy taught Frank's son how to sign their names right off the bat.
I loved how this scene was written and what it accomplished. It was more about doing than telling and all in the hands of the children. They showed Frank what Brian could learn in the space of minutes and when he signed, “father,” it brought tears to my eyes.
Oh, me too, Jonetta. That scene just killed me. It seemed like Frank's heart was about to burst from his chest. It also showed how hungry for stimulus and knowledge Brian is. I also loved how FRank got to see that for the deaf couple's children, a hearing impairment is totally within their realm of "normal" and nothing to get worked up about.
I don’t think Frank was this emotional when he first learned that Brian was deaf and not mentally challenged. He was so overwhelmed with feelings!
I agree, Veronica about him seeing the normalcy of deafness. The hearing children didn’t seem adversely impacted, just a normal day.
I agree, Veronica about him seeing the normalcy of deafness. The hearing children didn’t seem adversely impacted, just a normal day.
That was a fantastic scene. I loved how the little boy taught Brian to sign a few words in a matter of minutes.
Loved that scene. It was so good seeing Brian interact with another child who didn't think there was anything wrong or strange with him. Frank got to see that a normal life for his son is possible, and that's more than he dared to hope until that moment. No wonder he was so overwhelmed.
On another note, will Frank have to go to deaf school too? Someone has to teach him sign language for him to communicate with Brian.



