2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion
This topic is about
Murder on Gramercy Park
Murder On Gramercy Park
>
Question C
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jonetta
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mar 05, 2018 04:44AM
Mod
reply
|
flag
I decided straight off that he was yucky and he was the murderer. I turned out to be right but about the wrong murder:)
Mod
Amos made my skin crawl so I was suspicious of him from the start. He certainly wormed his way in quickly.
I didn't like this guy at all. His offering to pay Frank to find the killer just left me thinking he was trying to make himself look innocent.
Robin wrote: "I didn't like this guy at all. His offering to pay Frank to find the killer just left me thinking he was trying to make himself look innocent."Exactly Robin!
He was very unpleasant from the start. At first I thought he was too suspicious to be the culprit, but then when Calvin died he became my number one suspect.
He definitely was written to be unlikable. I thought he was a bit too smarmy but knew he wasn't Blackwell's killer even though he was pushing so hard for it to be Calvin. Which was suspicious as was his devotion to Mrs. Blackwell.
Mod
I thought him rather obvious so was discounting him.
Mod
The author did a great job of confusing us with this character.
Jonetta wrote: "The author did a great job of confusing us with this character. ..."I'm glad Thompson ended up making him a murderer. He deserves to go to jail just because I didn't like him LOL.
