The Sword and Laser discussion
This topic is about
A Wrinkle in Time
2018 Reads
>
AWIT: This Is How We Bounce the Ball. First We Bounce It. Then We Bounce It Again.
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Sean
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Feb 04, 2018 11:40PM
For everyone who first read this book as children, a question: Is the bouncing the ball scene the one thing you remember about this book more than anything else?
reply
|
flag
It stuck with me forever, and Kamazotz has been my metaphor for frightening conformity since I first read it decades ago.Is it the one thing I remember? Hard to say. The sensations of being with Aunt Beast and the mental feedback loop of the Man With The Red Eyes are pretty strong memories.
I'm afraid all I remember is dragon fewmets, and I'm not even sure whether that's in this book or one of the laters one.
Keith wrote: "I'm afraid all I remember is dragon fewmets, and I'm not even sure whether that's in this book or one of the laters one."
Not in this one.
Not in this one.
I dont remember the bouning balls very well. I mainly remember trying to wrap my head around how time could be a dimension. That and how Charles Wallace was maybe becoming evil and being scared by it.Jeez I read this book 26 years ago.
Sean wrote: "For everyone who first read this book as children, a question: Is the bouncing the ball scene the one thing you remember about this book more than anything else?"Actually I didn't remember that at all. I remember the explanation of the "wrinkle" using the analogy of the ant on fabric, and also for some reason I remember the turkey dinner.
The only thing I remembered from my childhood read was the first scene with IT. The throbbing, pulsing, disembodied brain definitely stuck with me.
When I think of this book I remember the house and the introduction of the characters. For some reason the wind stood out to me. I definitely remember the ball scene but it doesn't stick with me as much as the scene setting did.
The ball scene strikes me as a lift from John Wyndham's The Midwich Cuckoos. In fact many of the tropes seem to be lifted from 50's SF. Jaunting from The Stars My Destination etc. To my adult eyes, which found the book shallow, this lifts ideas and layers cheap christianity over the top.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Midwich Cuckoos (other topics)The Stars My Destination (other topics)






