Breaking Dawn
discussion
Write Book Five
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Booklover456
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jul 10, 2014 10:09PM
Fan fiction of Twilight... book Five as Bella continues her journey as a vampire.
reply
|
flag
What if she changes Charlie, or attempts to? Jacob dies... Stephenie's biggest fail in the Twilight Saga was no main character died. That should be changed. Maybe Edward or Alice join the Volturi!
I think there should be a fifth book because there are so many unanswered questions.
Abby wrote: "I think there should be a fifth book because there are so many unanswered questions."There are?
Yes, there are. Here's a list of some of them.
Will Charlie find out that Bella's a vampire?
Will Charlie find out that Rensemme is actually their daughter?
What will Rensemme and Jacob first kiss be like?
How will Edward and Bella, especially Bella, react to Rensemme and Jacob dating?
Does Renee, Bella's mom, find out about any of this?
These are just something I wish to know that are know by the end.
Will Charlie find out that Bella's a vampire?
Will Charlie find out that Rensemme is actually their daughter?
What will Rensemme and Jacob first kiss be like?
How will Edward and Bella, especially Bella, react to Rensemme and Jacob dating?
Does Renee, Bella's mom, find out about any of this?
These are just something I wish to know that are know by the end.
Jacque wrote: "Abby wrote: "I think there should be a fifth book because there are so many unanswered questions."There are?"
Also:
Who was Embry's father?
How did a trait that was previously sex-linked to males suddenly show up in a female?
Will the Volturi come back and pick them off one-by-one?
And the biggest one for me:
Will SM explain how a being with no cellular growth was able to father a child with a human?
Booklover456 wrote: "What if she changes Charlie, or attempts to? Jacob dies... Stephenie's biggest fail in the Twilight Saga was no main character died. That should be changed. Maybe Edward or Alice join the Volturi!"Sorry. Just realized what your intent was in starting this discussion.
Well, I actually took a stab at writing the fifth book. Or rather re-writing the fourth book. You can read it at fanfiction.net if you like. It's called Cygnus Rising. #shamelessplug :)
I might just have to read that!
Me, too. I am a fan of Twilight but it could have been so good that it blew me off my feet!
Well, I don't know how good my version is, but I answered a couple questions that were bugging me.Hope you enjoy it! :-)
Along with there being a fifth book I also think she needs to finishing writing Midnight Sun. It ended right before one of my favorite parts, and I so want to know what happens.
In book five Jacob gets with Leah because they are very similar and their relationship would not be disgusting. =D
In book five he can't be with Leah if he imprinted on Rensemme.
I've got a twist. In book five, Renesmee goes to college and meets a boy she truly falls in love with. Then we'd get to see if Jacob becomes "whatever she needs him to be."
Am i the only person who doesn't want a book five? I just feel that the ending was good and i was content with it? I wasn't left desperate to find out what happened next. In my opinion Bella will 'die' and they'll all move away with Jacob and leave the wolf pack behind.
I agree, I loved the ending but its fun to imagine what would happen next and I want to see what other people would imagine when the saga would end.
Booklover456 wrote: "I agree, I loved the ending but its fun to imagine what would happen next and I want to see what other people would imagine when the saga would end."Same! Glad someone agrees!
If I could, I'd collect all the twilight lover's sign on the need for book 5 and submit it to Ms. Stephanie Meyer provided that I get a chance to meet her.
Abby wrote: "In book five he can't be with Leah if he imprinted on Rensemme."Imprinting is not necessarily romantic. He can be her brother for all we know.
Katie wrote: "Am i the only person who doesn't want a book five? I just feel that the ending was good and i was content with it? I wasn't left desperate to find out what happened next. In my opinion Bella will ..."
I guess it depends. People who hated it might want a book five to fix the things they hated. Some people who couldn't get enough of it might still want more. I wouldn't want a book five. I hated the last book so much I wouldn't be satisfied with less than a re-write of book four.
At any rate, I don't think SM will do it. She's said in an interview that this was Bella's story, and she ended it where she felt Bella's story was finished.
Rel8tivity wrote: "Katie wrote: "Am i the only person who doesn't want a book five? I just feel that the ending was good and i was content with it? I wasn't left desperate to find out what happened next. In my opini..."
I agree, i don't think SM will write anymore of twilight. When i first finished reading Breaking Dawn i really wanted there to be another book, however since then i realised the ending was pretty amazing and nothing more needed to be said.
Iris wrote: "Abby wrote: "In book five he can't be with Leah if he imprinted on Rensemme."
Imprinting is not necessarily romantic. He can be her brother for all we know."
I understand that, but at some point he might actually love her romantically.
Imprinting is not necessarily romantic. He can be her brother for all we know."
I understand that, but at some point he might actually love her romantically.
I agree with you Katie, amazing ending. Am I the only one who loves the villains better? They always have more interesting stories to tell... Twilight is the rare saga where I root for the main characters.
Booklover456 wrote: "I agree with you Katie, amazing ending. Am I the only one who loves the villains better? They always have more interesting stories to tell... Twilight is the rare saga where I root for the main cha..."The villains in twilight are brilliant! Each one has an interesting history which must have been very thought out! Have you read the the twilight saga illustrated guide?
I've read the illustrated guide, and love it. I thought it was interesting to learn things that I didn't know before. Even though I don't like Jacob, the guide helped me to better understand is character a little more.
Abby wrote: "I've read the illustrated guide, and love it. I thought it was interesting to learn things that I didn't know before. Even though I don't like Jacob, the guide helped me to better understand is cha..."Same! Reading about the past of each character helps to understand them better! I found Alice's history the best and most insightful. It was like a miniature book in itself.
Katie wrote: "Abby wrote: "I've read the illustrated guide, and love it. I thought it was interesting to learn things that I didn't know before. Even though I don't like Jacob, the guide helped me to better unde..."
Yeah I like her history as well. I thought it was interesting to learn why she created Jacob, and why she wrote New Moon the way she did.
Yeah I like her history as well. I thought it was interesting to learn why she created Jacob, and why she wrote New Moon the way she did.
Yes, i did read the illustrated guide and enjoyed it very much. The villains... Especially James' story captivated me.
Okay I think that stephenie meyer's work is not done. She needs to finish what she started and write a fifth book. She is a great author and so she left us asking questions at the end BUT there were to many questions unanswered. So the ending went from ' man that was great! I wonder what happened next?' to ' OMG WHAT THE HECK?!? SHE DIDN'T EVEN FINISH IT?!? WHAT?!?!' so you can see where that might frustrate some people.
I think a neat idea would be a new series about Renesmee Cullen. Will she attend Forks High or be homeschooled? Will she love Jacob in the romantic way or reject him and try to date another? I think her teen life would be full of adventure unlike her mothers was. She seemed a lot more carefree and spontaneous than Bella, which I liked.
July 16 20014 TO whom may concern:
I would love a continuation of twilight saga or the host book, or and new story altogether. I am more interested in the continuation The host series then twilight series or a new story thought.
Best regards.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
