Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2018 Challenge Prompts - Regular
>
40. Your favorite prompt from the 2015, 2016, or 2017 POPSUGAR Reading Challenges


Oh, I hadn't thought about that. I was really surprised when I saw that there were only 50 prompts this year, and that makes it work out to a full 52, like you mentioned. I may have to do the same. Thanks for sharing your idea!

Could you add links to the lists of the previous years' challenges to the first message? I think that would be appreciated.

https://www.popsugar.com/love/Reading...
https://www.popsugar.com/love/Reading...
https://www.popsugar.com/love/Reading...


I like this idea!
For 2017, my favorite prompt was "A book that's been on your TBR list for way too long." The Kitchen House (Jan 26, 2014)

Great Idea... I might join you in doing that.
Edit: So far with my wild cards.
40 - 2015: A book with a number in the title
The Seven Sisters
51 - 2016: Either Dystopian, Graphic novel or Blue cover (Think I will keep this one open)
52 - 2017: A family member in the title
The Shadow Sister

2015 -- The Book of Three (a book with a number in the title)
2016 -- Spindle's End (a book based on a fairy tale)
2017 -- Stranger in a Strange Land (a book you picked up at a used book sale)

2015: A book set somewhere you've always wanted to visit
The funny thing was that I read a book mostly set in Wales, and I ended up having a last-minute opportunity to go about three months later. (I hated the book, but my personal experience has still affected my choice, because we had a magnificent time there.)
2017: A book recommended by a librarian
Like the best booksellers, many librarians are book experts. Getting a recommendation from a librarian I know, whose own reading taste is similar to mine (and they know this), has always resulted in an enjoyable experience for me.

2015: A book set somewhere you've always wanted to visit
The funny thing was that I r..."
I was thinking the same thing just now, as I was going over the lists again. There are definitely some prompts I was not excited for at all (political memoir!!), but for the most part, my enjoyment of a prompt had more to do with the book I picked than the prompt itself.

That said, I really liked the "long meaning to read" prompt this year...
I'm going for the first book you see in a bookstore as it's almost guaranteed to be a genre I don't usually read!


Good idea! I'll do the same.
I have been doing this challenge since 2015, so I grabbed lists from 2015, 2016, and 2017, and then rated each category from 0 (meaning, "this is a category we have again in 2018, or close enough") to 1 ("I hated this category") up to 5 ("I would want to repeat it"). Then I sorted by rating, and I've got about 15-20 categories to choose from. And it looks like this is just going to be a "wild card" category, because there are things like "mystery" or "from the library" (this would be approximately 100% of the books I read!) or "audiobook" or "on your TBR list a long time" or "recommended by family" and so on ... basically, I think ANY book I want to read will fit into one or more of these categories!
So I'm not going to bother coming up with any ideas here, I'll just fit something in when I end up reading a book that doesn't fulfill another open category.
It's kind of annoying. Why didn't Popsugar just admit the truth and call this category "WILDCARD"????
So I'm not going to bother coming up with any ideas here, I'll just fit something in when I end up reading a book that doesn't fulfill another open category.
It's kind of annoying. Why didn't Popsugar just admit the truth and call this category "WILDCARD"????


(2015) A book your mom loves -or- a book you started but never finished.
(2017) A book about an interesting woman - I've been meaning to read "The Diary of a Young Girl"
(2017 advanced) - a book you picked up at a used book sale - plenty on my to-read list

So for this I'll go with either of these:
The Immortals of Meluha
1984
The God of Small Things
Malgudi Days


2015 - A graphic novel
2016 - A YA bestseller
2017 - A book you bought on a trip
For 2015, I will probably read Road to Riverdale.
For 2016, I still haven't chosen a book but I know it will be an easy one!
For 2017, I have a lot of options as I love buying books whenever I travel. Some of my options are:
Alex and Eliza
Carry On
The DUFF: Designated Ugly Fat Friend
Geekerella

40. 2015 - A book set during Christmas OR A book with antonyms in the title. I love Christmas, and I have a few books on my Kindle and at home ready to read for this one, but I will probably add more between now & then, too. But, I saw a lot of good choices for the antonyms in the title book when I looked at listopia, and quite a few are on my TBR list.
51. 2016 - A book you can finish in a day. Honestly, I really like this one because it gives me a little freedom to give myself a break & help catch up on my list if I need to. Plus, I may not read just a very short book, but may find a longer one I expect to not be able to put down until I finish it.
52. 2017 - A book you got from a used book sale. I just went to my library's used book sale last month & loaded up on books. I bought some of them specifically for the Around the World challenge since I already had that list when I went to the book sale. I have found some others that I bought will readily fit this challenge, as well, but I still have plenty of books that don't have a prompt home, so I will fit one of them here.

a book written by someone under 30 (I could finally read Eragon)
a graphic novel (Outside my normal range, but it would be fun to pick up some of the Joss Whedon TV-sequel graphic novels.)
a book of poetry (I have several on my TBR, but very rarely choose to read poetry.)

I think I'm going to go with:
2015 - A book set somewhere you've always wanted to visit
2016 - A book where the protagonist has the same occupation as you
2017 - A book with a title that is a character's name
I have several options for the 2016 same occupation prompt. I'm a lawyer, and I already have Rogue Lawyer, Soulmates, and Bonfire at home, and all three have lawyer protagonists.
And, for the 2017 prompt, I received The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo from Book of the Month and have been dying to read it, since it's been praised by many members of this group!
Just need to find something to fit the 2015 prompt, but that shouldn't be too hard to do over the course of the year.
UPDATE 8/9 I finished these three challenges, below is what I actually read.
2015 - A book set somewhere you've always wanted to visit: The Heart's Invisible Furies (Ireland) - Such a fantastic book. I'm recommending it to everyone I know!!
2016 - A book where the protagonist has the same occupation as you: Bonfire (lawyer)
2017 - A book with a title that is a character's name: The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo - another fantastic book!
Two of the books I read for these prompts are my fav. reads of the year.

2015 - written by someone under 30 // a book your mum loves
2016 - based on a fairy tale // self improvement


2016 I can read ?

2017 I can listen to an Audiobook? Hidden Bodies

2015: A book set somewhere you've always wanted to visit
The funny thing was that I r..."
As a librarian, I'm glad you liked the prompt so much and I'm glad your librarian is good at Reader's Advisory!



2015 - A book you started but never finished (because I have a ton of unfinished books I'm trying to finish)
2016 - A murder mystery (because I just finished Merry, Merry Ghost and was having a hard time slotting it anywhere)
For 2017, I guess I'll just see what comes in handy. There are so many gimmes that this truly is a wildcard prompt!




I read this as a hormonal teenager and sobbed the whole time!



From the 2016 Challenge I chose the prompt Self-Improvement.

I generally avoid non-fiction but this book caught my eye and this prompt fit it perfectly.
Completed 1/24/18

https://www.popsugar.com/love/Reading...
https://www.popsugar.com/love/Reading...
https://www.popsugar.com/love/Reading......"
Did anybody ever type up the 2015 list? I started doing these challenges in 2016, and typed them up myself so I could print them out legibly and also to have a computer copy to edit with the books I was thinking of to fulfill each prompt.
I've found that those pretty graphics PopSugar puts together do NOT print out fully from my computer- either the printer cuts off half the lines, or it's shrunk to fit the page and too small to read.
Or I could just pick " a banned book" as my prompt from 2015 and not bother looking at all of them. I was briefly considering doing both the 2018 and the 2015 prompts this year,but I don't really want to read a book that scares me, and there WEREN'T any books I was supposed to read in school but didn't- I read everything assigned in all my English classes, plus extra books!
I still might do it, though I'm not sure how to fulfill that prompt about school.







Finished

My Review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Dry (other topics)Mao's Last Dancer (other topics)
Dark Rivers of the Heart (other topics)
My Absolute Darling (other topics)
The Heart's Invisible Furies (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
E.M. Forster (other topics)Joe Hill (other topics)
For anyone who is NEW to the challenge this year, you don't have to have participated in previous challenges. You can always look through the archives in the group to find prompts from previous years.