Les Misérables
question
If I LOVED this will I like Hunchback of Notre Dame?


I absolutely adore Les Miserables - the characters, the plot, the way that history is weaved with history, the writing style, everything! In fact if your interested you can read my overly gushing review of it here: http://the-bookshelf-reviews.blogspot.... Anyway, I am really intrigued to read some more of Hugo's works but I have heard mixed reviews of Hunchback from people who loved Les Mis but as you will know, if you read the review, classics scare me and very often I don't finish them so ... does anyone have any idea whether I should give it a go or leave it, I kind of don't won't to tarnish my idea of Victor Hugo .....
reply
flag
I also loved Les Miserables, it's easily one of my favourite books. I'm about three quaters of the way through The Hunchback of Notre Dame and don't have the same respect for it as Les Mis. The start is painfully slow and Hugo does a lot of those side stories about how Paris looks or the life of gypsies etc. I'm listening to it on a audiobook of Librivox.org, which makes some of those hard to read classics a bit easier to get through. Now I'm towards the end of the book I'm really getting into it but the beginning was a huge struggle.
@One the slow start was something I was really quite afraid of with Hunchback, the thing that puts me off most about classics (or at least the ones I've read) besides the language used were the slow starts, overly quick introduction of characters and the overly complicated language. What I need to increase my confidence with the Classics are ones that grab me right from the very first page. This is something I wasn't expecting when I opened Les Miserables as due to the sheer size of it I was expecting it to slowly amble to the action and intrigue but I was most definitely pleasantly surprised I was wrong about. The first paragraph had me completely hooked then and there.
I read the first few pages of Hunchback and found them actually a bit of a struggle and the writing style seemed more convoluted than in Les Mis?
I read the first few pages of Hunchback and found them actually a bit of a struggle and the writing style seemed more convoluted than in Les Mis?
Rachael Dewhurst
Mmmmm, to be honest the more reviews and comparisons I read the less I think I'm going to enjoy it which is a real shame. Oh well, maybe sometime in t
...more
· flag
· flag
I found these so books completely different in style that, other than the frequent historical asides, I wouldn't have thought them the same author.
I enjoy Quasimodo's epoch more than Valjean's myself.
I enjoy Quasimodo's epoch more than Valjean's myself.
@Kirk The great difference in style is something I've been 'warned' about a lot and is definitely one of my main concerns. I loved the writing and storytelling style of Les Miserables, it was one that drew me in and wouldn't let go.
As for ValJean VS Quasi I can't comment fairly having not read Hunchback but I completely fell in love with ValJeans story and character and I feel really quite scared that that's never going to be topped.
As for ValJean VS Quasi I can't comment fairly having not read Hunchback but I completely fell in love with ValJeans story and character and I feel really quite scared that that's never going to be topped.
They are just as different as you can't compare them... I'm not alright with skipping entire chapters, they all have their reason to be, so I can tell you to read and enjoy every word.
I love them both pretty much, but slightly prefer Les miserables... Valjean is kind of a hero to me ^__^
I love them both pretty much, but slightly prefer Les miserables... Valjean is kind of a hero to me ^__^
Rachael Dewhurst
I know what you mean about skipping chapters, I felt exactly the same way before reading Les Mis. However, now that I have read it, when I read it for
...more
· flag
· flag
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Les Misérables (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The Hunchback of Notre-Dame (other topics)Les Misérables (other topics)