Navigating Indieworld Discussing All Things Indie discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Getting To Know You!
>
The GRRRR!!!!!! thread

Well some of my books are on 'to read' lists that run above 9,000. Assuming the people read as many as 5 books a week, they'll have to be the longest lived people in history to get to mine.
So, Anita, I've got to the stage where I don't even look at 'to reads' now. It's no longer something to get excited about!

A recent conversation with my sister totally made me change the way I look at bad reviews. We should thank the bad reviewers as much as the good ones, because, as you say, "we can't please everyone." And we shouldn't try. When a bad reviewer leaves a detailed reason why they didn't like your book, it gives other readers more information--and probably prevents other readers with similar expectations from picking up your book and having a similarly poor reading experience. So, in essence, a few bad reviews help prevent even more people from having a negative experience with your work. And as we all know, the people who leave reviews are but a small sample of the people who actually read our work, and most people who didn't like a book won't bother to review it, either--but you can bet they tell people about it!
My sister also has a much more strict review system than I do. My system? I start off wanting to give everyone 5 stars, and books lose stars for "bad behaviour", lol. (In other words, not meeting my expectations for various criteria.) For her? A book must earn every star it gets. 3 stars is a book she liked and might read again. 4 stars she really liked, and 5 stars is something she loved and thought was freaking amazing, blowing all expectations out of the water. She has a friend who is even more strict--if he wouldn't read it again, it doesn't get more than 2 stars, even if he thought it was okay. (He tends to re-read books he likes often.)
So, that gave me a huge switch in perspective--and I helped her to see that leaving a three-star review is still helpful if you explain why. An important function of reviews is to give other readers appropriate expectations. And your 2-star reviewer did that. Someone who loves your work and genre may read that and think, "eh, that doesn't bother me", and pick up the book anyway. We need to stop taking stuff like that personally. I hope that helps. :-)

That was really well put, Talena, and I agree. As long as the review states what went into the rating, it can help weed out those who would not be happy with the read, which is what I'd want. And, conversely, tell those looking at it if those things would bother them or not. Nicely said. And i know that one person's 3 is another person's 5....it is all very subjective.

I totally understand that! It's tough for it not to be a downer, even when we know that it's still a good thing for our platform.
If you're ever wondering if bad reviews can help sell product, though, just search for Haribo Sugarless Gummy Bears on Amazon. Oh, and grab the Depends. ;-)

Thank you. And yes, it is subjective. That's why the review system works, but must still be taken with a grain of salt--all of us humans are so different. :-)

That happened to me last month. I had 2 and a half weeks to receive my books before a big library event. I thought that would be plenty of time and when I put in my order the estimated time was 3 and a half weeks. I did get my order ahead of schedule and on time for my event, but I will not make that mistake again.

Well some of my books are on 'to read' lists that run above 9,000. Assuming the people read as man..."
Thanks. That's what I thought. Wanted to see what someone else had to say. Wouldn't it be nice if we could reach out to those individuals?


So true. I actually preferred a 2,3 star reviews with constructive criticism than a fawning 5. Fawning 5 reviews make me veryyy sceptical.


Thanks Anna. I've seen the up and down as well, but I have to agree with Ted, it's another feature that doesn't seem to have any value for the author.

No doubt. And as a creator, if someone takes the time to think about my book and offer constructive criticism in areas I'm lacking, I AM grateful! No matter how skilled we may become, there is always room for improvement. It's being teachable that turns us into better and more successful writers. That book may be done and out there, but I can take those lessons and use them in my next project.

This could be a good read since the closure of Pronoun. It is always a good idea to evaluate what is best for you as an author.
It is the tale of two marketing systems.
ttps://davidgaughran.wordpress.com/2017/10/2...

Here are the links to the magazine and my website where the article can also be viewed.
https://www.indieauthorsmonthly.com/r...
https://www.anitadickason.com/circlin...
Healing from surgery is easier if you lose the weight. That's why they like you to be thinner.
Try the keto diet, Alex. my whole family has done very well with it. As a combined group we lost close to three hundred pounds.
Try the keto diet, Alex. my whole family has done very well with it. As a combined group we lost close to three hundred pounds.

Alex send me a blog post about your books and I'll put it up- You do it too Amy- Brit will post them- hopefully, it will net you a sale somewhere in the states.

I'm finding some help in doing newsletter swaps. I'm in Facebook groups with other writers in my genre (fantasy), and we arrange to promote each other's books in our newsletters. One generous person did that for me when I had only a couple of hundred of subscribers, and from her newsletter of 10,000 thirty people bought my book the day her newsletter came out.
Another angle is joint giveaways, again with writers in your genre. You all agree to promote the giveaway on your social media and through your newsletters. Most of them don't care how small your newsletter list is.


https://mybookcave.com/g/48c94c2f/




Write on medium. It’s s built in audience. I haven’t been doing much to promote but I’ve noticed an uptick in sales in paperbacks since I started posting there. You don’t have to maintain it. Write when u want. It’s good if u can do a post once a week. Don’t make it about your book. Make it about something that will make people want to look u up and buy your book. I started out by liking and following as many people as I could. I now have over 500!followers

Alex! Write about the photos and letters you found during your aggravating renovation. I found that quite interesting, as I enjoy reading about historical information. Hugs

Carole, Thank you for getting on Medium and starting this ball rolling. I haven't yet contributed, but do intend to write and submit. I'll keep you posted. Hugs

I've put this post in my diary for March with the sincere hope there will be time to follow up on this.
Good. They have a place on there where u can prepare drafts and then publish. When I think about something I put it up and store it Watch for one on the dedication of nurses coming later today.





This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Amy Robsart: A Life and Its End (other topics)Iridessian Haunts (other topics)
Yes, it tells a tale.