Mental Health Bookclub discussion
Archive
>
43. A Three-Word Title
date
newest »


I was surprised to find that the original book is quite different! I definitely prefer the film (not just because of the nostalgia), the book just seemed to take itself too seriously. It was a love letter to Yorkshire, which was lovely, but when Mary had decided to start speaking the Yorkshire dialect, it just came across as pretentious rather than authentic.
Clearly it's a magical story at its heart, otherwise it couldn't have inspired a one of my favourite childhood films, but the original book fell flat for me :(
Books mentioned in this topic
The Secret Garden (other topics)Life of Pi (other topics)
Milk and honey (other topics)
Pride and Prejudice (other topics)
The Secret Garden (other topics)
More...
Life of Pi
milk and honey
Pride and Prejudice
The Secret Garden
The Icarus Girl
A Christmas Carol
The Color Purple
The Handmaid's Tale
Discussion prompts
- What did you/will you read for this task?
- What did you think of it?