The Challenge Factory discussion

The First Four Years  (Little House, #9)
This topic is about The First Four Years
45 views
2016 ♦Archives Buddy Read ♦ > Trea, Erica, & Cindy - Little House Series

Comments Showing 51-100 of 146 (146 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I actually like this one but I see your point. I wonder how Laura is able to write about her husband's childhood experiences so many years later - she must be making up at least some of the dialogue and such.
It also struck me how wealthy Almanzo's parents were. Compared to Laura's experience in the big woods and on the prairie so far, just the description of the barns on Almanzo's farm seem almost palatial!
I just started this last night. Not very far yet...


message 52: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments Trea wrote: "Cindy, would starting On the Banks of Plum Creek on the 12th give you enough time before you leave to read it?"

That should be fine. I'm starting Farmer Boy tomorrow and should have it finished no later than by the weekend.


message 53: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) I've finished this one...not as good as the previous two, in my opinion, but there were a good bit of interesting things happening!


message 54: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (last edited Aug 04, 2016 05:20PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I just enjoy seeing how her husband grew up a little. I agree it's a bit off track and I'd rather read about Laura - but this is fun in its own way. I have a ways to go on it but I'll get there.


message 55: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments I haven't started yet. Things have been hectic here trying to get everything done for my trip but I'll get it read this weekend. I'm looking forward to reading about his family.


message 56: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I'm nearly done, but have to attend the funeral of my childhood best friend's father today - so up and out the door early. It will be a long day.
I do enjoy the descriptions of how everything is made and how absolutely NOTHING is wasted. I'm amazed by how Almanzo's father just knows what the weather will be in the coming day, and how he plans what the work will be for that next day based on his prediction of what's coming. Oh, and the descriptions of food leave my mouth watering. The amount of food Almanzo packs away is astounding. He must have worked very hard, as I'm sure he was not fat and he had to burn off an awful lot of calories every day!


message 57: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Finished this one tonight. I absolutely love the ending, where Almanzo decides he wants to be a farmer rather than going in to town to be apprenticed to Mr. Paddock. Made me smile.


message 58: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "Finished this one tonight. I absolutely love the ending, where Almanzo decides he wants to be a farmer rather than going in to town to be apprenticed to Mr. Paddock. Made me smile."

Yeah, I liked that too!


message 59: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I'm starting On the Banks of Plum Creek today. I may wind up reading the two extra books after all... I just joined the crazy "What's It Called?" challenge, and could us an "O" and a "W" book... hee hee!


message 60: by Cindy (last edited Aug 12, 2016 12:35PM) (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments Erica wrote: "I'm starting On the Banks of Plum Creek today. I may wind up reading the two extra books after all... I just joined the crazy "What's It Called?" challenge, and could us an "O" and a "W" book... he..."

I'm doing that challenge too so I also need as many O's and W's as possible! lol


message 61: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I'm glad Laura's back in Minnesota now. I looked up Plum Creek, and see that she didn't live far from where my father grew up in Worthington, MN. I love Laura's spunk - she's daring and gets in trouble often enough for it. My kind of heroine.


message 62: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
And... done. I couldn't put this one down! What really got me is that now I was looking at all of the disasters (locusts, blizzards, fire) through the eyes of Laura's parents. They had to be quite young - probably in their early 30's at most - and they faced SO MANY things that could have destroyed them. But they were amazingly strong and resilient.
I don't mean to get ahead on this buddy read, but I couldn't stop myself once I started this one. I don't plan to start the next one until September though.


message 63: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "And... done. I couldn't put this one down! What really got me is that now I was looking at all of the disasters (locusts, blizzards, fire) through the eyes of Laura's parents. They had to be quite ..."

Yeah, I'm only at the start of chapter 20, so about halfway through it.

The leeches part was interesting! Mary is such a girly girl!


message 64: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Yes, I love the contrast between the two sisters. And I love to hate bratty miss Nellie Oleson!


message 65: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Updated for the new book...any thoughts on when to start this one?

I have a BR scheduled for the 1st and one scheduled for the 4th, so I'm thinking to start the new one on the 6th or 7th.


message 66: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
That sounds good to me. Up to my earlobes in other reading at the moment and these don't take too long.


message 67: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) I started this one back on the 6th, thinking that's what we had agreed on, but it looks like I am the first one done! It was a decent read, and I liked the little surprise at the end!


message 68: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I was going to start a day or so ago but wound up starting Black Rabbit Hall instead. I'll probably start tomorrow. These go quickly.


message 69: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (last edited Sep 11, 2016 07:44AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I just started this morning. I forgot about Mary going blind. So sad. And their train ride west - so strange to think of that as a dangerous form of travel. This will go quickly now that I've started.


message 70: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Oh wow. The part where Laura and Lena ride out to pick up the wash from the homesteader woman whose 13-year-old daughter was MARRIED the day before. Just imagine!


message 71: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
And I just finished reading about Pa's handling of the moon of angry men who wanted their pay up through their current work. Scary.


message 72: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Oops - men, not moon. Darn phone.


message 73: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Double oops. MOB of men. There.


message 74: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "Double oops. MOB of men. There."

It gave me a chuckle to read it the way you originally had it, something I sorely needed this morning!


message 75: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "Oh wow. The part where Laura and Lena ride out to pick up the wash from the homesteader woman whose 13-year-old daughter was MARRIED the day before. Just imagine!"

I didn't like Lena too much...too wild for my impression of the times, especially how some of the wash was re-dirtied because of the antics she allowed the horses to do.


message 76: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Yes, it makes you wonder what ever came of her. Also sorry that Laura now feels compelled to become a school teacher since Mary no longer can.


message 77: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "Yes, it makes you wonder what ever came of her. Also sorry that Laura now feels compelled to become a school teacher since Mary no longer can."

Yeah, I didn't care for how she was forced into that career...


message 78: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (last edited Sep 15, 2016 12:59PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Pa found the homestead site but he hasn't filed his claim yet. I don't remember if he makes it... sure hoping he does! I continue to be impressed with how grateful they all are with the very simplest of Christmas gifts.


message 79: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "Pa found the homestead site but he hasn't filed his claim yet. I don't remember if he makes it... sure hoping he does! I continue to be impressed with how grateful they all are with the very simple..."

There's a surprise in it!

I would be happy with some of those gifts they got, honestly!


message 80: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Mr. Edwards saves the day! And, Almanzo is on the scene now. I like how this one is ending. Will finish up shortly.


message 81: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Done! I loved this one. I love that Laura is still such a tomboy. When do you want to start The Long Winter? I'm thinking maybe next weekend, the 26th at the latest. I want Laura and Almanzo to meet!


message 82: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "Done! I loved this one. I love that Laura is still such a tomboy. When do you want to start The Long Winter? I'm thinking maybe next weekend, the 26th at the latest. I want Laura and Almanzo to meet!"

The 23rd/24th works for me, and I can't wait for them to meet either!


message 83: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments Okay, ladies, I'm back. I'm so sorry I've been gone so long!


message 84: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
YAY!!! Welcome back! Let us know when you're caught up... We're on The Long Winter, but are happy to wait for you!


message 85: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Cindy wrote: "Okay, ladies, I'm back. I'm so sorry I've been gone so long!"

Welcome back!


message 86: by Cindy (last edited Oct 17, 2016 10:26AM) (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments Can I just say that while reading Prairie, I was actually really upset that they didn't let the dog ride in the wagon when they crossed the creek and then it looked like the dog had drowned? Like to the point that I almost didn't want to finish the book. I was so happy when it turned out that he survived. That's probably silly but I really love my dog. lol


message 87: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Cindy wrote: "Can I just say that while reading Prairie, I was actually really upset that they didn't let the dog ride in the wagon when they crossed the creek and then it looked like the dog had drowned? Like t..."

LOL, I remember getting that angry about it too!


message 88: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Yes, that seemed rather cruel. I guess Jack was viewed more as a work animal than a pet in the modern sense. But still...


message 89: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments I'll be done with Farmer Boy tonight, btw. Sorry to have slowed everything down! I'll start Plum Creek tomorrow.


message 90: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
No worries. I had a bad week that kept me from reading much at all. Happy to wait, even until November if that helps.


message 91: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments Almost finished with Farmer Boy and I feel like I like Almanzo's father better than I like Charles. But of course it is probably because Laura is writing from Almanzo's memories of his father and he clearly idolized his dad. But still, sometimes I kind of feel like Charles is just blundering around the country with his family in a wagon.


message 92: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments I'm almost done with Plum Creek and it's interesting to see the differences between the way Laura and Almanzo were raised.

I have to say though, I am pretty annoyed at Ma right now for making Laura give her doll away to neighbor's little girl and always telling her to be unselfish. They literally. Had. Nothing. It wasn't really possible to be selfish when they had nothing. And why wouldn't it have crossed Ma's mind that Laura might want to keep the first and only doll she had ever received for Christmas?


message 93: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Yeah, that upset me too. It was such a different time back then. Hard to understand now.


message 94: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments I finished Plum Creek. For a while there it really did seem like Pa's Comedy of Errors. But he worked so hard for his family it was just heartbreaking when things went wrong. Even if I did want to wring his neck for some of the ridiculous things he did.

I'll start Silver Lake tonight probably before bed. I'll be ready to start The Long Winter by the end of this week but let me know what works for ya'll. That is where you guys are at right? lol


message 95: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Cindy wrote: "I'll start Silver Lake tonight probably before bed. I'll be ready to start The Long Winter by the end of this week but let me know what works for ya'll. That is where you guys are at right? lol"

Yup, we're at Long Winter, and end of the week works fine for me! Just give a shout when you're starting it!

Re: the doll- I was very glad when she got it back! I felt it showed Ma just how little respect the other girl had had for the gift, when compared to how Laura took care of the doll!


message 96: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I'm ready to start The Long Winter when you guys are.

I'm glad Laura's Ma fixed her doll when she got it back...


message 97: by Cindy (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) | 129 comments I hadn't thought about it before, but maybe part of Laura's talent with words came from her job of "seeing for Mary" once she became blind.


message 98: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
Good point. I was so devastated to "re-learn" of Mary's blindness. I had forgotten about that. Life on the prairie was hard enough without being deprived of your sight! And I agree - Laura probably became quite skilled at describing things in her efforts to help her sister.


message 99: by Erica, Quality Control Supervisor (new) - rated it 3 stars

Erica | 4667 comments Mod
I started The Long Winter last night. So happy - Laura finally met Almanzo - or maybe I should just say "encountered". I won't say how because I'm not sure if either of you have gotten to that point yet. I will also say that I am more than a little concerned for the Wilders living in this claim shanty as they approach a horrific winter season. I don't recall being so concerned about it when I read these as a kid. But I could feel the fear that Pa must have had when he came in empty-handed from hunting and sat down to a supper of only beans in October. How would they survive an entire winter??


message 100: by ⚜️XAR (new)

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Erica wrote: "I started The Long Winter last night. So happy - Laura finally met Almanzo - or maybe I should just say "encountered". I won't say how because I'm not sure if either of you have gotten to that poin..."

I haven't started it yet, but I will in a little bit!


back to top