The Challenge Factory discussion

Dead Men Don't Crochet (Crochet Mystery, #2)
This topic is about Dead Men Don't Crochet
20 views
2016 ♦Archives Buddy Read ♦ > ~Michelle~ & Trea - Crochet Mysteries Series

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Denise, Manufacturing Director (new)

Denise (destiny_chan) | 7414 comments Mod
~Michelle~ & Trea - Crochet Mysteries Series


message 2: by ⚜️XAR (last edited Jul 11, 2016 03:14AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Reading Order
1. Hooked on Murder by Betty Hechtman
2. Dead Men Don't Crochet by Betty Hechtman (Agree to abandon BR after this book!)
3. By Hook or by Crook by Betty Hechtman
4. A Stitch in Crime by Betty Hechtman
5. You Better Knot Die by Betty Hechtman
6. Behind the Seams by Betty Hechtman*
7. If Hooks Could Kill by Betty Hechtman
8. For Better or Worsted: A Crochet Mystery by Betty Hechtman
9. Knot Guilty: A Crochet Mystery by Betty Hechtman
10. Seams Like Murder: A Crocheting Mystery by Betty Hechtman
11. Hooking for Trouble: A Crochet Mystery by Betty Hechtman

*=Trea to Double Up on this book


message 3: by ⚜️XAR (last edited Jun 16, 2016 05:45AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) When would you like to start this, ~Michelle~? I have one BR that is starting today, and another that is unscheduled as of right now. Other than that, I'm pretty flexible.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) I'll be starting this one when I take my son to his speech therapy appointment in a couple of hours.


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments Starting now :)


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) ~Michelle~ wrote: "Starting now :)"

I only read about 50 pages while waiting for my son's therapy appointment to end...but I hate Adele!


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments I know, right?!? I kind of want to slap her. LOL

I finished through Chapter 9 today. I have a doctor's appt. 2 hours away tomorrow so I won't get much reading in. Hopefully we can pick up wherever you get to tomorrow.

I am enjoying it so far!


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) ~Michelle~ wrote: "I know, right?!? I kind of want to slap her. LOL

I finished through Chapter 9 today. I have a doctor's appt. 2 hours away tomorrow so I won't get much reading in. Hopefully we can pick up wherever..."


I wasn't able to get much further than I had after my son's appointment, but I've had a rough night and will probably do some more reading before he gets up for the day.


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments No worries. As always, I have 2 - 3 other books going at the same time so no need to feel super rushed.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) ~Michelle~ wrote: "No worries. As always, I have 2 - 3 other books going at the same time so no need to feel super rushed."

Eh, its more of a OCD thing for me...I try to read a book a day, but I just wound up getting busy. Got a 2 hour wait today, so I should make some good progress today.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Well, my two hour wait made me have excellent progress on this, because I finished it last night before bed. Sadly, though I didn't like it much. The story was rather boring to me, the romance between Molly and her detective was uninspired at best, and Molly felt downright stupid to me at times! I do remember liking this a bit more the first time I read it, so it could just be how I've changed in my reading tastes for not enjoying it this time around.

I picked up my library request for the next book yesterday, so I plan on sticking around for the next book at least!


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments I haven't read any more yet, but probably will finish by tomorrow. I'm sad it didn't go well for you. Maybe the 2nd book will be better!


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) ~Michelle~ wrote: "I haven't read any more yet, but probably will finish by tomorrow. I'm sad it didn't go well for you. Maybe the 2nd book will be better!"

I'm hoping so!


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments Well I finally finished Book 1 and gave it 3*, but it was probably more like 2.5* in all actuality. It seemed to drag on a good bit there in the middle/end. I wasn't expecting the correct suspect, so that was a little bit of saving grace I guess. And you were right that the whole romance was lacking and almost ridiculous - I think more so than in Book 6 that I had already read.

Maybe the writing gets better as the series progresses because I do recall liking Book 6 slightly more than this one.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) ~Michelle~ wrote: "Well I finally finished Book 1 and gave it 3*, but it was probably more like 2.5* in all actuality. It seemed to drag on a good bit there in the middle/end. I wasn't expecting the correct suspect, ..."

I do remember not being that impressed with the first 3 books, but my library system has all of them, so I'll keep going with it and see if it improves.

When would you like to try to read book 2? I've got nothing scheduled yet, but a good bit of buddy reads set up. I already have my library copy, but it is due back on the 14th. It should be renewable though!


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments Trea wrote: "~Michelle~ wrote: "Well I finally finished Book 1 and gave it 3*, but it was probably more like 2.5* in all actuality. It seemed to drag on a good bit there in the middle/end. I wasn't expecting th..."

You tell me what works best for you this month and it should work for me as well.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) How about we start it this weekend then, say Saturday or Sunday? That should give me plenty of time to read it before it has to go back to the library.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) I haven't seen a reply back yet, Michelle, did starting this this weekend work for you?


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) Well, I went ahead and started it, since I hadn't heard back from you. I'm not that far into it, but I'm not really liking it. Molly is coming off as nothing more than a busybody with a bit of a god complex who denies it and the romance now has an ick factor to it. At least in Joanne Fluke's books, Hannah admits she's a busy body, but also has the sense to call in back up if she needs it! Plus, there was a bit more romance to things there. This is coming off as a poor imitation of that.

I'm going to finish this one for sure, and the third, just to be sure of my feelings on it, but I can't guarantee I won't abandon the series after that.


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments Hey! I hadn't seen the notifications come up. I'm doing WOBBLE and lots of things get buried under all the notifications from there. I'll purchase the Kindle version today and start on it. I wish it was sounding much better! Sorry I kept you hanging.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) ~Michelle~ wrote: "Hey! I hadn't seen the notifications come up. I'm doing WOBBLE and lots of things get buried under all the notifications from there. I'll purchase the Kindle version today and start on it. I wish i..."

No worries! I had a couple of others to work on, so I only put in a little work on this one. I started another buddy read and read Purity in Death too, so I wouldn't get too far ahead. I'm only on page 34 and all this has already manifested.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) I wound up finishing this since my other buddy read is only reading 3 chapters a day. I didn't care for it, as it was just more of the same we saw in book 1 as far as how Molly was acting.


Michelle's Empty Nest (mlundy5) | 704 comments Well, I finished Book 2...Meh...

I don't think I can make myself stay on a timeline as a buddy read with the rest of them. I'll probably work them in if I need them for a specific challenge, well maybe...maybe not at this point.

I really had to force myself to read this one and probably would not have finished if it wasn't a BR. :(

I'd love to try another BR in the future with a book that's actually decent enough to have some discussion about. Keep me in mind.


⚜️XAR the Bookwyrm (xar-the-bookwyrm) I'm sorry you didn't like it either! I totally understand about wanting to quit on the BR, as I was planning on forcing my way through it if I had to! I'll let Denise know she can archive the thread when August sign ups come out, and thank you so much for agreeing to buddy read with me!


back to top