Omnibus/OHC Graphic Novel Collectors discussion
Comic Reading Discussion
>
Recommended Reading: The Works of Grant Morrison
date
newest »
newest »
Off the top of my head:
JLA: I have a soft spot for these. They got me into DC for a few years. If you look at the stories as a whole, the threats escalate. I admit that at a certain point it loses it's direction, but I look back fondly on those stories.
Batman: I'm taking these as a whole, because individually they are quite as strong as when you read them all together.
Books I liked but don't highly recommend:
While a little unfocused, you can see the beginnings of his career.
I liked this, but I'm not quite as enamored with it as everyone else.
I remember this story all coming together nicely.
Meh:
New X-Men - I never cared for it.
Invisibles - I found it to be too confusing and "out there".
Seven Soldiers of Victory
Aztek the Ultimate Man
Marvel Boy
Haven't read Doom Patrol yet.
JLA: I have a soft spot for these. They got me into DC for a few years. If you look at the stories as a whole, the threats escalate. I admit that at a certain point it loses it's direction, but I look back fondly on those stories.
Batman: I'm taking these as a whole, because individually they are quite as strong as when you read them all together.
Books I liked but don't highly recommend:
While a little unfocused, you can see the beginnings of his career.
I liked this, but I'm not quite as enamored with it as everyone else.
I remember this story all coming together nicely.Meh:
New X-Men - I never cared for it.
Invisibles - I found it to be too confusing and "out there".
Seven Soldiers of Victory
Aztek the Ultimate Man
Marvel Boy
Haven't read Doom Patrol yet.
I did really like his Batman run. I would like it if they did another Absolute collection the first part of his Batman run but I am not sure that's likely. Shame that to collect his run you end up with three different sizes of hardcovers as no one size collected it all.
Additionally I'd vote for All-Star Superman (available in Absolute edition).
Additionally I'd vote for All-Star Superman (available in Absolute edition).
Relstuart wrote: "I did really like his Batman run. I would like it if they did another Absolute collection the first part of his Batman run but I am not sure that's likely. Shame that to collect his run you end up ..."
Yep, Combining Batman and Son, Black Glove and RIP in one Absolute seems like a no-brainer to me. There are enough additional chapters in other books that they could split the two main ones into two Absolutes, then fill in the pages with Resurrection of Ra's al Gul, etc.
Yep, Combining Batman and Son, Black Glove and RIP in one Absolute seems like a no-brainer to me. There are enough additional chapters in other books that they could split the two main ones into two Absolutes, then fill in the pages with Resurrection of Ra's al Gul, etc.
I think Resurrection of Ra's al Gul may go in-between Batman and Son and The Black Glove. Which is really annoying since the DLX has Son and Black but not Resurrection. Resurrection is the one story I have that is only in standard size HC. The end of Batman his run is only in TPB or Absolute.
Books mentioned in this topic
DC One Million Omnibus (other topics)Animal Man Omnibus (other topics)
All-Star Superman (other topics)
Absolute Batman Incorporated (other topics)
JLA: The Deluxe Edition, Vol. 1 (other topics)
More...




The idea is to compile a list of books on each subject/topic from the group members and have a central thread that people can use to decide where to begin.
Preferably, the suggestions should be limited to stories that are available in some type of hardcover: Absolute, Omnibus, Deluxe HC, etc.
Make as many suggestions as you like, but do try to keep it to an "essential/best reads". At some point the mods will count all of the suggestions and make a summarized list.