50.1 - Perletwo's task: Primary Colors

[Wanda]

Would this work for the green cover option?

[Suzanne]

Wanda wrote: "Would this work for the green cover option?

"

No, sorry - there's some of the right green there, but it's in her hair, not in the background, and the image is too big to see enough of the background anyway.

[Gabriella]

Suzanne - please, check message 150 =)

[Suzanne]

Gabriella wrote: "Suzanne - please, check message 150 =)"

oh shoot, i missed it! Sorry - the thread flipped over to a new page & I didn't see there was one left back on 3.

These should be fine. I remember seeing 12 Years a Slave on the list, thought about it for one of mine, just mark the page it's on when you post.

[Gabriella]

Suzanne wrote: "Gabriella wrote: "Suzanne - please, check message 150 =)"

oh shoot, i missed it! Sorry - the thread flipped over to a new page & I didn't see there was one left back on 3.

These should be fine. ..."

Thanks!

[Wanda]

Would this work for the green cover?

[Suzanne]

Wanda wrote: "Would this work for the green cover?

"

The green is on target, but on embiggening I think there's more black than green there, so no.

[Cindy]

Is this the right shade of green?

[Suzanne]

Cindy wrote: "Is this the right shade of green?

"

A little too yellowy green, sorry.

[Marscha]

Will this work for blue?

And for green?

[Suzanne]

Marscha wrote: "Will this work for blue?

And [bookcover:Hex Marks t..."

Iced is too light a blue.

Of the greens, I'll approve Hex Marks the Spot.

[[deleted user]]

Could I get these books approved ?

First for book 1 --- Texas :

The Midnight Assassin: Panic, Scandal, and the Hunt for America's First Serial Killer

Book 2 - Michigan

Michigan Murders


Book 3


Thank you

[Suzanne]

Julie wrote: "Could I get these books approved ?

First for book 1 --- Texas :

The Midnight Assassin: Panic, Scandal, and the Hunt for America's First Serial Killer

Book 2 - Michigan

[book:M..."

The settings books look OK from what I can tell.

The green cover is too dark a green. It's a little lighter when embiggened from the thumbnail, but still too dark.

[Suzanne]

Julie wrote: "Could I get these books approved ?

First for book 1 --- Texas :

The Midnight Assassin: Panic, Scandal, and the Hunt for America's First Serial Killer

Book 2 - Michigan

[book:M..."

The settings books look OK from what I can tell.

The green cover is too dark a green. It's a little lighter when embiggened from the thumbnail, but still too dark.

[Suzanne]

Julie wrote: "Could I get these books approved ?

First for book 1 --- Texas :

The Midnight Assassin: Panic, Scandal, and the Hunt for America's First Serial Killer

Book 2 - Michigan

[book:M..."

The settings books look OK from what I can tell.

The green cover is too dark a green. It's a little lighter when embiggened from the thumbnail, but still too dark.

[[deleted user]]

Ok , thanks -- 2 out of 3 !

[Melanie]

Thanks for responding on my other questions!

For a blue cover, please verify:

[Suzanne]

Melanie wrote: "Thanks for responding on my other questions!

For a blue cover, please verify:
"

Approved.

[Robin (Saturndoo)]

Would these work for Red and Blue cover?

[Suzanne]

♥Robin ♥ wrote: "Would these work for Red and Blue cover?

"

Both approved!

[Wanda]

Seeking approval for any of the following:

[Suzanne]

Wanda wrote: "Seeking approval for any of the following:







..."

Approving New Orleans Mourning.

[Candy]

Will this work for red?

[Sarah]

Would any of these work for green?



Thanks.

[Suzanne]

♥Robin ♥ wrote: "Would these work for Red and Blue cover?

"

Robin, I've got to rescind that approval - the group mods messaged to remind me we'd rejected Dark Lover before the task was posted, on the grounds that it's a color wash over an image, not a true background. Lover Eternal is in the same style. Sorry 'bout the confusion.

[Suzanne]

Candy wrote: "Will this work for red? "

Approved.

[Suzanne]

Sarah wrote: "Would any of these work for green?

[bookcover:Erasm..."

Approving Deadly Proof and Erasmus Hobart.

[Teresa Jo]

A quick question about the book format... If I wanted to read Rebecca, which is approved for Red - but I wanted to read the Kindle format - would that work? (I am still reading through all of the posts, so if this has been answered already, I will find it eventually) :) Thanks

[Dlmrose, Moderator Emeritus]

Teresa Jo wrote: "A quick question about the book format... If I wanted to read Rebecca, which is approved for Red - but I wanted to read the Kindle format - would that work? (I am still reading through all of the p..."

Mod note

From FAQ
I. General default rules
J. So, can I ALWAYS read any format or edition of a book for any task?
Yes, but if the task requires a specific number of pages or a particular image/color on the cover, the edition you read must satisfy the requirement, and your link must be to the edition that you actually read. The easiest way to make sure you do this is to put the ISBN on the edition that you read in the box when you are adding the link, rather than the title – this will bring up the correct edition. If you put in the title, you’ll get the GR default edition.

[Teresa Jo]

Thanks, that is what I found after I posted - probably shouldn't work on this while I am at work :)

[Robin (Saturndoo)]

Suzanne wrote: "♥Robin ♥ wrote: "Would these work for Red and Blue cover?

"

Robin, I've got to rescind that approval - the group mods messaged to remi..."

OK so either one of those books would work for setting for options 2 New York?

[Suzanne]

Hi Suzanne, would any of these books work for the green cover option?



Thanks!

[Suzanne]

Approving The Laws of Murder and, after much mental debate, Ella Minnow Pea. The rest are too yellow-y green to my eye.

[Suzanne]

Thanks!

[Julia]

Does work for red cover?

And Threads and Flames for Option 2 set in NY?

Thanks

[Suzanne]

Julia wrote: "Does work for red cover?

And Threads and Flames for Option 2 set in NY?

Thanks"

Dog in the Night-Time is just a bit too orange-y. Shame, coz it's such a good book. :(

Haven't read T&F, but based on the GR description it looks OK.

[Julia]

Suzanne wrote: "Julia wrote: "Does work for red cover?

And Threads and Flames for Option 2 set in NY?

Thanks"

Dog in the Night-T..."

Drat.

How about or for red cover?

[Suzanne]

Julia wrote: "Suzanne wrote: "Julia wrote: "Does work for red cover?

And Threads and Flames for Option 2 set in NY?

Thanks"

Do..."

The Murder Stone works nicely. Murder Offstage is definitely a pink to my eyes.

[Christine]

Hi, pls approve settings for these books

Lost in Bliss set in Colorado (CO)

Omens set in Illinois (IL)

thanks!

[Suzanne]

Christine wrote: "Hi, pls approve settings for these books

Lost in Bliss set in Colorado (CO)

Omens set in Illinois (IL)

thanks!"

Haven't read either, but from what I can see on their GR main pages, they should be OK. Just as you're reading keep the "at least 50%" requirement in mind and see how they do.

[Ceelee]

Hi! I am back again with a book to submit for your approval. I stumbled upon this book searching for something completely different and didn't see it on either the approved or rejected list. It looks like it may fit the shade of green you are looking for but I wanted your opinion first.

[Suzanne]

Ceelee wrote: "Hi! I am back again with a book to submit for your approval. I stumbled upon this book searching for something completely different and didn't see it on either the approved or rejected list. It loo..."

Yep, that works nicely.

[Wanda]

Would this be acceptable for green?

[Suzanne]

Wanda wrote: "Would this be acceptable for green?"

No - too yellow-y and too pastel. Think shamrocks.

[Sarah]

Would this be the right blue? Thanks.

[Suzanne]

Sarah wrote: "Would this be the right blue? Thanks.

"

approved!

[Kathy G.]

Will this red work?

[Suzanne]

Kathy G. wrote: "Will this red work?

"

It's at the dark edge of the acceptable spectrum, but I'll approve it.

[Kathy G.]

Thank you!!!

[Marie-Anne]

Will this work for green?