Christopher Paolini (INHERITANCE CYCLE series) discussion
Book 4
>
Book 4 Title
k guys no matter what you want brom is dead and not coming back eragon has dealt with it and moved on already no point in bringing him back
the best thing for eragon right now is for arya to accept that she loves him
Brianne wrote: "my opinion matters. and CP will read this post and say sorry.i doubt it LOL
Brianne wrote: "BROM LIVES!(that's conspiracy theory number two for me)"
We never know what kind of twist an author will put into the story. I do it all the time in my stories.
But it is a good theory.
Mod
more secrets he kept with saphira maybe???
Yeah...we never know....it is possible....
i seriously doubt he'll come back just cause we want him to cp is not gonna do it
Mod
if brom comes back the only thing that will happen is that eragon will be in shock and disbielf and he won't trust him cause he cant be sure if he is a trick of galbys or not the only thing he knows for certain is that everybody told him that you cant bring people back to life and he believes he saw brom die so once again bring brom back will only cause shock disbielf hey not to sound heartless i want him back to but eragon wouldn't be able to handle it
Jacobe wrote: "if brom comes back the only thing that will happen is that eragon will be in shock and disbielf and he won't trust him cause he cant be sure if he is a trick of galbys or not the only thing he know..."DANG IT! But I want Brom back....Poor Eragon...and Selena....It's so sad!
they're tragity lead to the book sad yes neccisary as well yes brom was kool but we all died and he had one of the longest human lives ever and now he is with selena anyway so what does it matter
it was also neccisary for arya to be captured sending saphira to eragon again tragic but neccisary
Yes...I suppose. I doubt that Brom will come back or Selena unless in some kind of...near death experiance for eragon when he see their ghosts...but their time in the book is up. 
i don't care about selena at allbut broms NOT dead:)
Mod
Mod
well, she's nothing to the story but plot twists, and unexciting onesplus she's kind of a slut
Mod
Mod
you have a crush on her don't you...
Mod
plus she's kind of a slut "
How do you know? We don't really know anything about her.
well, she was with morzanshe loved him, she killed people
then she goes with brom and is suddenly all flowers and candy?
i don't think it should be that easy for someone to be forgiven
Mod
Mod
i dunno, maybe it's my love for Brom that makes me hate herbut i think the plot was weak in that, the whole i left eragon a message on the saphira recorder. like i hated it being explained like that
brom could still live. He was preserved crystal by by saphirra right?
Mod
yup, perfect stasis,
he was preserved? can someone tell me where that happened?
Mod
OHHHH, you mean his coffin, yeah... HE'S COMING BACK
Mod
Mod
Mod
BROM WILL LIVE HE WILL LIVEHIS PURPOSE WAS TO BE AWESOME AND HE HAS MORE AWESOME TO DO.
Mod
Brianne wrote: "well, she was with morzanshe loved him, she killed people
then she goes with brom and is suddenly all flowers and candy?
i don't think it should be that easy for someone to be forgiven"
Well, fist off, I think Morzan tricked her into thinking he was a nice guy, and falling in love. And then she was immediately bound up with oaths so she couldn't leave, and so she had to kill some people. But remember that we don't know that the reports of her are accurate. She most likely was mostly a spy and less of an assasin. The stories about her cruelty are probably just rumors, because she was so secretive and powerful. She didn't WANT to help the Empire. Then Brom helped partially free her, and she helped the Varden as much as she could. We just don't know enough about her to decide if she's good or not.
she killed, people a lot of people. i dunno, i just don't pity her enough to feel sorry for herim a bad person
Mod
Brianne wrote: "she killed, people a lot of people. i dunno, i just don't pity her enough to feel sorry for herim a bad person"
lol. I agree that she certainly made some HUGE mistakes, but she regretted them. And remember that the reports of her being such an effective killing weapon, and murdering so many people, might be just a rumor, according to Oromis and Jeod. By the way, Eragon has killed lots of people too. :)
well maybe galby has all these little things, but he has millions of them, and what they do, is give him lots of magical power, and that majkes him way stringer than anybvody, and so no one can basically beat him
*sarcasm*(creeping n here)