Percy Jackson Fan Club! discussion

139 views
Predictions & Thoughts! > Do you think one of the 7 will die? If so, which one?

Comments Showing 151-200 of 237 (237 new)    post a comment »

message 151: by [deleted user] (new)

i like vikings :3


message 152: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments GO THOR


message 153: by [deleted user] (new)

lol yea


message 154: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Have u seen the Thor movies


message 155: by [deleted user] (new)

yea hes so awesome


message 157: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments IKR he's amazing


message 158: by [deleted user] (new)

ikr


message 159: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Ha ha


message 160: by [deleted user] (new)

lol


message 161: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Back to the topic so....... Don't hurt Da SEEWEEDBRAINS


message 162: by [deleted user] (new)

yesh dont huurt him


message 163: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Never


message 164: by [deleted user] (new)

eva


message 165: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Do u think the line from the prophecy a oath to keep with a final breath is completed


message 166: by [deleted user] (new)

idk


message 167: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments It is completed


message 168: by Danielle (new)

Danielle | 65 comments All of his series are awesome.


message 169: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Oh yea they are


message 170: by [deleted user] (new)

of course RR'S series is awesome


message 171: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Jis books are awesome


message 172: by [deleted user] (new)

yesh


message 173: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments I wish Grover was In the mark of athena


message 174: by [deleted user] (new)

yea gtg baseball game GO METS lol byeee


message 175: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Talk to u later


message 176: by MOVED - CHECK BIO, Head Camper ~ "Bob says hello." (new)

MOVED - CHECK BIO (izzylightfleur) | 15305 comments Mod
Lina wrote: "I dont think he would kill any of the seven. I think he knows we all would get pissed, but if he did, i would want it to be Jason. Im sorry, but I hate that guy. Hes too...PERFECT. he's like mr. pe..."

Please edit the striked out word. If it wouldn't be in a Percy Jackson book, it should not be used here. Thank you.


message 177: by Renee (new)

Renee I think Frank will die.


message 178: by Renee (new)

Renee heroically of course.


message 179: by Sophia (new)

Sophia Encina | 29 comments If Frank dies it would be really sad for hazel. :(


message 180: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Hazel would be heart broken and that's when Leo would comfort her but NOT flirt and she falls for Leo and Leo has to make a choice between hazel and cylpso


message 181: by Sophia (new)

Sophia Encina | 29 comments Which one would he choose though. I am leaning towards calypso since he made a promise to come back to her. But that does not mean in a romantic way. Right?


message 182: by Danielle (new)

Danielle | 65 comments Please don't let Frank die. He and Hazel are too cute.


message 183: by Sophia (new)

Sophia Encina | 29 comments Yeah. They are. But we all know Uncle Rick. That meany.


message 184: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments I don't want frank 2 die but I mean ur right he is a meanie butt that would make a awesome book


message 185: by Sophia (new)

Sophia Encina | 29 comments True. I can't take it waiting anymore. I am need to get my hands on the blood of olympus.


message 186: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Gtg talk to u all later I can't believe it's the last Percy Jackson book *Sob SOB **


message 187: by Sophia (new)

Sophia Encina | 29 comments Why does it have to be the last book?!? *bawls eyeballs out* Ok bye.


message 188: by Elisar, Co-Head Camper and v confused by BoO (new)

Elisar (ehlihr) | 13295 comments Mod
Personally, I would want Percy to die. Not because I don't absolutely love Percy or anything, he's my precious little child, but it would add a lot of finality to the story- he dies, and goes to the isles of the blessed i keep thinking of Merlin when it comes to the isles lol and then he's finally at peace for the rest of eternity. He'll no longer be under the control of the gods and all that- whom he has become rather bitter towards.

The thing is, Rick wouldn't do that. Unlike J.K. Rowling or the Hunger Games lady (suzy collins?), Rick actually cares about what the readers will do when it comes to a death. Chances are- he kills Reyna, knowing a lot of people don't really care much about her whICH IS RIDICULOUS CAUSE SHE IS THE QUEEN OF EVERYTHING and also, Hazel. Hazel is out of her time, and isn't supposed to be alive at all. It would make morbid sense for her to be killed, or, at least, taken back to the Underworld.

A lot of people think Frank will die, and at a time, I might have agreed- Frank had been around for two books with little growth in his character besides being a little braver and maybe more intelligent than we presumed. Now, though, he's much more intelligent, a Roman leader (most likely the next praetor), and thanks to daddy, super buff (which i personally found kind of unnecessary and kind of dumb for reasons here (view spoiler)) so Rick wouldn't kill him off. Frank has bigger things set out for him, that much is obvious.

The truth is, Rick is horrifically unpredictable a lot of the time, but his books are easy to understand. Thinks don't connect to each other in extremely complex ways, but rather, really simple ones. This should make it easier to guess and make predictions, but rather, it makes things harder because we have a wider range of options. Rick would just as easily kill Nico as he would Hazel, or Octavian Annabeth. The only constant is that he takes his reader's feelings into account. Sure, he sent Percy and Annabeth to Tartarus, but no one really thought they were going to die, right?

In the end, it shouldn't matter. He just better make an ending worthy of the nine previous books in the two series.


message 189: by Sophia (new)

Sophia Encina | 29 comments That is true. Really it will be hard to let any of the characters go because we all have grown attached to them all. Even Uncle Rick but he has to break our hearts to make a good book. So he would probably will kill Percy because he has been in all of them. And percy deserves a heroic death.


message 190: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments One WOW RR should really look at some of these predictions for ideas it would make another awesome book two he would never kill Percy maybe annabeth ( if he got a really good security) but I think frank , hazel , nico , or Reyna will die


message 191: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments Izzy {Valdez} Lightfleur ~ ͠♥Dᴏ ʏᴏᴜ ʙᴇʟɪᴇᴠᴇ ɪɴ ᴍᴀɢɪᴄ﹖♥ wrote: "Definitely think that one of the seven will die,
yahhh up top i think that too he might even sacrifice himself cus nemesis said he will watch himself burn in HOH



message 192: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments Lina wrote: "yea DONT HURT DA PRECIOUS SEAWEED BRAIN!!!!!"

loll hess ilove percy so much if he does anything to him i will never touch a rick riordan pj book related cus imma cry


message 193: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments Daughterofposeidon wrote: "Rick has stated that not all of the seven are going to suvive. i kinda hope he is lying but so long as he doesn't kill percy, annabeth or leo..."

yess my girl ur so right


message 194: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments deleted user wrote: "I want

JASON

to die if any one of them dies."


honest up top u deserve a cookie a chic chip one for saying that if they have to choose jason should die


message 195: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments Meghan wrote: "I have ideas...
I think Frank will probably die. I mean, his life is tied to a stick of wood. But I think Hazel will also have to go back to the Underworld to make things right (but go to Elysium w..."


ya I'm cool with that suggestion


message 196: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments Lina wrote: "I dont think he would kill any of the seven. I think he knows we all would get pissed, but if he did, i would want it to be Jason. Im sorry, but I hate that guy. Hes too...PERFECT. he's like mr. pe..."

yaaaa same here like i have sympathy for her she's pretty and deserves a nice life and a good bf jason is not my fav character he's just ugggghhhhhhh make me wanna barf but if theirs a choice hopefully he dies


message 197: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments Sophia wrote: "Do u remember the Titans Curse. What if he does what he did in the Titans Curse? What if only three survive?"

wat three survive i forgot was it percy annabeth and thalia or someone else


message 198: by C (new)

C Oordt | 425 comments Noo don't think that if anyone dies it will be Reyna , nico or coach hedge protecting his baby


message 199: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments C wrote: "Noo don't think that if anyone dies it will be Reyna , nico or coach hedge protecting his baby"

well reyna isn't important neither nico but coach hedge is too funny hopefully he won't die but the r only important because they r takin the athena parthenos with them thts it


message 200: by Percabeth (new)

Percabeth Caleo | 233 comments if any could die in the 7 i want either jason or hazel they r not that important characters well i would feel bad for piper and frank thats it


back to top