Readers Inc. - Monthly Book Club! discussion
(March Selection) The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea by Yukio Mishima
date
newest »


I ordered the UK vintage one because it was cheaper. :) But I love the US cover. Gorgeous! Glad people are excited about it. Seems like it will give us lots to talk about.

As for Mishima I always wanted to read some (I even have "The Temple of the Golden Pavilion"), but never did, so it's great opportunity for me. My edition will be "just ebook" (yeah, I read mostly on e-readers).
This is an author I am quite unfamiliar with and I look forward to delving into the novel.

Brixton wrote: "This is such a wonderful and disturbing read! Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!"
Thanks for posting. Since you've read it, I hope you will join us with our discussion.
Thanks for posting. Since you've read it, I hope you will join us with our discussion.

Mishima will offer you something very, very different from Murakami's work. Murakami was incredibly influenced by English literature and has actively attempted to draw himself as far away from the traditional Japanese literary tradition as possible. Mishima on the other hand was very nationalistic and steeped himself in traditional Japanese culture. Mishima and Murakami's are worlds apart (but I love them both dearly!) :)

Thanks for posting. Since you've read it, I hope you will join us with our discussion."
Absolutely! I look forward to hearing everyone's thoughts!

I've been fascinated by Japan and Japanese fiction for a long time now and I've liked pretty much everything I've read from Japan. Probably my favorite Japanese authors would be Natsuo Kirino (Out, Grotesque, Real World) and Ryu Murakami (Coin Locker Babies, Audtion, In the Miso Soup). I've dipped my toes in Haruki Murakami's works - I've only read Colorless Tsukuru Tazaki and Norwegian Wood and enjoyed them both-, a bit of Keigo Higashino, Hitomi Kanehara, Kobo Abe...but there are SO many Japanese authors that I want to get to!
Really looking forward to next month's reading and discussions!
In the Miso Soup was insane. I'm not a real big fan of Murakami. I think he writes female characters pretty poorly and I usually find his work to be sort of plodding. He's well-loved so that's great. I think I've read four or five of his novels and I still haven't been blown away.
I'm glad you like the choice! Hopefully it will give us all lots to discuss. Good or bad!
I'm glad you like the choice! Hopefully it will give us all lots to discuss. Good or bad!

Yeah...I enjoyed the two I read, but I wasn't blown away by either, nor did I experience that big 'emotional connection' a lot of people mention when they talk about Haruki Murakami, especially Norwegian Wood. I've started reading Underground, which is one of his non-fictions about the Tokyo sarin gas attack, and it's been pretty good.



Confessions of a Mask
This is the only other Mishima I've read. It was a positive experience. I guess we'll all find out soon if The Sailor is or not.
Ha!
This is the only other Mishima I've read. It was a positive experience. I guess we'll all find out soon if The Sailor is or not.
Ha!

This will be a re-read for me, my first read was maybe 5 or 6 years ago and I liked it very much. Also read Confessions of a Mask and Patriotism (in which he wrote about seppuku years before he committed that kind of ritual suicide).
I'll stick to my old French translation.
I don't know much about Japanese literature except for the two Murakamis (Ryu and Haruki, who were mentioned above) and Kenzaburo Oe (by whom I would recommend Seventeen, and an awesome collection of short stories entitled Teach Us to Outgrow Our Madness)

Me, too! It takes awhile to come from England.
yup. I'm excited because I really have no idea what to expect. I know nothing about the story but the basic plot.
Books mentioned in this topic
Confessions of a Mask (other topics)The Sound of Waves (other topics)
The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea (other topics)
The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea
Summary:
Yukio Mishima’s The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With the Sea explores the vicious nature of youth that is sometimes mistaken for innocence.
Thirteen-year-old Noboru is a member of a gang of highly philosophical teenage boys who reject the tenets of the adult world — to them, adult life is illusory, hypocritical, and sentimental. When Noboru’s widowed mother is romanced by Ryuji, a sailor, Noboru is thrilled. He idolizes this rugged man of the sea as a hero. But his admiration soon turns to hatred, as Ryuji forsakes life onboard the ship for marriage, rejecting everything Noboru holds sacred. Upset and appalled, he and his friends respond to this apparent betrayal with a terrible ferocity.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
March’s selection is the Japanese classic The Sailor Who Fell from Grace with the Sea by Yukio Mishima. I’ve only read one other book by Mishima (Confessions of a Mask) which I loved.
Are you excited about this? Have you read any Mishima or Japanese fiction? Which edition will you be getting/reading?
More categories will be set up as the book reading begins. Thanks!