Harry Potter Fans discussion

119 views
If you could > If you could save one character, who would it be?

Comments Showing 51-72 of 72 (72 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Anna (new)

Anna | 112 comments Lupin or Tonks so that history doesn't repeat itself (i.e. Teddy doesn't grow up without parents like Harry)


message 52: by Mary (new)

Mary Catelli Sirius. Tonks. Remus. Cedric. Hard to choose.


message 53: by Jo (new)

Jo Drye (jodrye) | 2 comments Fred, I don't want to think about George without Fred :(
Remus and Tonks would b another one but I can't imagine one without the other it would be so sad


message 54: by Tajana (new)

Tajana (tajanaa) | 55 comments Johanna wrote: "Fred, I don't want to think about George without Fred :(
Remus and Tonks would b another one but I can't imagine one without the other it would be so sad"

I agree, plus Sirius :)


message 55: by Hannah (new)

Hannah grace | 127 comments one does not simply save only one character


message 57: by Saara (new)

Saara Sen-Basuchoudhary Yeah, it is really hard to decide


message 58: by Megan (new)

Megan All of them!!


message 59: by Hannah (new)

Hannah grace | 127 comments if you save one you save all


message 60: by Bibliogothica (new)

Bibliogothica We can each save someone that died.
That way everyone can live!

I can't just choose one, there are so many characters that I loved that died, and it wouldn't be fair to leave the others behind.


message 61: by kavi ~he-him~ (new)

kavi ~he-him~ (spideykavi) | 148 comments SIRIUS


message 62: by Ayla (new)

Ayla Fred and Cedric becuse they were really young or Lupin because, lers fave ot that man didn't have almost any luck in his life.


message 63: by Arbaaz (new)

Arbaaz Khan (arbaazkhan1999) | 17 comments Why is this even a discussion? Who would we save? I would try to find a way to save them all. Otherwise fred.


message 64: by ℜoxie (new)

ℜoxie -₮he ℛeader (roxiehibbs) 100% sirius black I adored him

But id have liked to have saved them all if it were possible they all touched my heart in some way or another and are all unforgettable!


message 65: by Mad Giles (new)

Mad Giles (Giles A. Madding) (gilesamadding) | 1856 comments It's so hard to pick just one. I'm really torn. I want to say Tonks, so Teddy would at least have his mom, but I'm not sure how well she'd go on without Lupin.

I like the idea of all of us picking a different one, then they may all be saved. :-)

Also want to say Dobby. He was such a sweet soul.


message 66: by Megha (new)

Megha | 96 comments Sadie wrote: "This might sound kind of weird at first but there is a lot of logic behind it. I would chose to save Tom Riddle's mother, Merope Gaunt. If Tom had grown up with a mother to love him he might not ha..."
That's a great idea though if there was no Voldemort then there wouldn't be the "The Boy Who Lived" and Harry Potter is my life or at least a part of it ;)


message 67: by Mary (new)

Mary Catelli there would have been a Harry Potter, mostly likely, but he would have grown up happy with his parents, and even perhaps had brothers and sisters.

Now it is a strange thing, but things that are good to have and days that are good to spend are soon told about, and not much to listen to; while things that are uncomfortable, palpitating, and even gruesome, may make a good tale, and take a deal of telling anyway. J.R.R. Tolkien



message 68: by Zaya (new)

Zaya Harker (hamiltrashdoggo) AGGGGHHHHHHH SO HARD DUIWQSQWUISHWQ IDK EITHER HEDWIG LUPIN FRED SNAPE OR DUMBLEDORE


message 69: by Eragon10316, Hufflepuff Mod (new)

Eragon10316 | 225 comments Mod
Snape


message 70: by Jenine (new)

Jenine (_jenine) | 272 comments All of them, of course
(I'm starting to cry ) :'(


message 71: by Eragon10316, Hufflepuff Mod (new)

Eragon10316 | 225 comments Mod
same!!!


message 72: by diamy (new)

diamy wang (harrypottereatspie) | 142 comments Fred, Snape, Tonks, Lupin


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top