Queen of Shadows
discussion
why does everyone only think about the love interest?!
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Celia
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 19, 2016 12:05PM

reply
|
flag

But the majority of readers read for the romance. Not to be sexist but most of this series demograph is targeted to YA girls. And what do most YA girls like: boys, romance. Look at Twilight, 50 Shades ( which is absolute shit, but a great example), Titanic, Romeo & Juliet (a tragedy but people tote it as one). Romance is a vast and enchanting genre.
SJM says herself in an interview that she plans romance before any other aspects. This is a romantic, action fantasy. Some read it for the romance while others, like me, read for action/intrigue. The romantics are just more vocal about it.
SJM says herself in an interview that she plans romance before any other aspects. This is a romantic, action fantasy. Some read it for the romance while others, like me, read for action/intrigue. The romantics are just more vocal about it.

No. I love talking about Manon and Aedion and even Chaol (though I despise the prick) and Dorian. I really want to know about that weapon and poor Kaltain... But I think there are lots of people like me that love the romance aspect of it and that's the most widely desireable subject for teenage girls (the majority of the series' audience).

I'm fine with the romances, and I definitely get into them since I'm invested in the series as a whole, but I wish there was a little less time spent on them. Especially Rowan and Aelin. I can deal with it, it's just... I was really excited at the end of HoF that we were getting two people who were of the opposite sex and who had an intense, loving relationship that was PLATONIC. I just feel like there's not enough of that in YA these days.
And it's just... Maas' world-building is absolutely fantastic, and it should not be as overshadowed by the romances as it is.
I just had to think very hard about what happened action-plot wise with everyone in Rifthold. I remember the stuff with Manon fine (because Manon is just fantastic and I always looked forward to her chapters the most during QoS), but anything I can remember from Rifthold is clouded by Rowan and Aelin being so in love all of a sudden, and Rowan and Aedion with their constant juvenile bickering. (Yeah, I know they're territorial fey males, but there was still too much of it.)
I keep having to reminding myself that it was really only in QoS that the plot's been this badly overrun with the romance. Hopefully it dies down again in the last two books. (...There's only two more books...... *cries all the tears*)
Just out of curiosity, is the romance overrunning the plot and world-building a problem in A Court of Thorns and Roses as well? I plan on reading it sometime this year, but I'd like to know if this is something I should watch out for there as well.

I'm fine with the romances, and ..."
It's interesting... I didn't really care for Manon's chapters in HOF because it was mostly just boasting about how big and powerful she was and how ruthless she was on the battlefield and with "bedding men" (XD) but then QOS she just made this beautiful change that was amazing to behold like YES Now we finally have a ruler we could get behind! Ruthless but compassionate at the same time!


And, Rebecca, for me ACOTAR was a disappointment. I did like it but not so much. It is totally love centric, you should think about that, I was expecting something more ToG and it wasnt. The world and the characters are splendidly well done and it was some enterteining read but I didn't get invested on it. I'm still thinking if I should continue with the next book or jus nah.
And in HoF I expected Manon's chapters the most, I'll admit.

And, Rebecc..."
It wasn't about who is getting laid it was about Aelin finding herself and Rowan finding himself together. And I feel like the romance was equally balanced with Manon's sideplot, Dorian, the King, Lysandra, Aedion, Chaol, the secret weapon, the wards, and then evenly placed between each sideplot were shared moments between Rowan and Aelin whether it be smexy times or little sweet conversations, dealing with past demons, training, jokes. It's all important and I feel like Maas handled it all beautifully because there were A LOT of things going on in this installment!


Celia you are my soul mate! ^.^


Anahy wrote: "Well, to be honest, this is a YA fantasy novel. Most YA novels don't really focus on the world or the plot, but mainly the characters and their relationships with each other."
Or that the vast majority likes certain aspects of the story than others. It's just preference.
Or that the vast majority likes certain aspects of the story than others. It's just preference.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic