Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban

[Julia]

This is where you can discuss your favorite and least favorite parts of book 3

[[deleted user]]

PoA is my favorite book out of all 7!!!

[Mary]

Yes. My favorite too. (view spoiler)[Though I have to confess that after the first two books had an Obviously Guilty Person, I never really suspected Sirius Black of being a bad guy. (hide spoiler)]

[Julia]

Sirius was my favorite character. I also really enjoyed the extreme description of Diagon Alley.

[Anna]

I really like how it's not all about Voldemort

[Mary]

It's the only one where Voldemort does not appear at all.

[Anne]

I know.

[Anne]

The movie is so different!

[Ayla]

Movie was different, but at least they guessed Harry's hair, it was flawless

[Christine]

Am I the only one who thinks Crookshanks is an animagus? How could a cat obtain a Firebolt for Sirius? How could a cat read so that it could retrieve a list of passwords? How could a cat communicate with Sirius at all? And why would it care about him? Crookshanks lies on Sirius's chest when it looks like Harry might try to kill Sirius, and in Goblet of Fire, Crookshanks is so mhappy to see Sirius that he nearly crawls into the common room fire. I think Crookshanks is Regulus Black.

[Julia]

I completely agree. There is no way a cat could know so much behind the scenes stuff. However I have never thought of the idea that it could be Regulus Black but its a great theory!

[Mary]

No, Crookshanks is part kneazle, that's the secret.

[Alyson]

I think this is one of my favourites!