The Rory Gilmore Reading Challenge discussion
Gilmore Girls Show
>
Dean, Jess or Logan
date
newest »

message 51:
by
Nathalie
(new)
Mar 20, 2021 10:38AM

reply
|
flag


Exactly, she doesn’t deserve any of them. Shes a victim just like her mother. The show is good but they meed counseling.

I really wanted to love Jess. Again this is a different time in rorys life. At chilton she is challenging herself with school work and Jess is on the same playing field or an even higher one then her when it comes to intelligence. My one problem with Jess is that he uses this idea of ‘I’m mean to everyone BUT you’ to show that he really cares about Rory. No, that’s not ok. He delivers some hilarious lines in comebacks but there are a few times of he’s just being mean and it’s not ok. In all honesty I think Jess and Rory would’ve been perfect for eachother when they meet when Rorys at Yale and Jess is in Philadelphia. They’re much more mature and have a really deep respect for eachother.
Logan. Oh boy. I wanted to love Logan so much. I thought he was going to be a combination of Dean and Jess and also bring the Yale spirit. And at first I thought he was that. The rebellion of Jess, the loyalty of Dean.
I really liked it at first because Rory finally seemed comfortable in a relationship. The pressure of high society felt a little shoe horned in, but after rewatching the series, it definitely seems inevitable from Richard and Emily’s perspective. I thought they truly cared about eachother. Until they didn’t. The breakup - cheating miscommunication was just upsetting. Their tension is a bright red flag of you’re done.
You know what, never mind, after three guys Rory just needs to learn how to break up with people.




I AGREE Tristan is awesome !!


In the final seasons, I changed my mind saying Logan is the one for Rory (still team Jess for me tho lol)
But, when I watched a year in the life I changed my mind again
Jess is her soulmate:)


I think all of them suck. Her view of men is awful! She needs a real man. And then she goes to another cheater.


was he perfect? absolutely not. but he cared about rory and did his best to be there for her. yeah he pretty much abandoned her when she graduated high school and i admit that was really sh***y of him to do but he owns up to his mistakes which is more than you can say about dean or even logan (although logan is a close second imo). and when he found out that rory dropped out of yale he had a whole talk about it with her and did everything he could to convince her to go back because he knows her and knows where she thrives which is school.
everyone is entitled to their opinions but imo jess is the absolute best💙💙