Reading the Detectives discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
483 views
Archived threads > What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread

Comments Showing 401-450 of 4,457 (4457 new)    post a comment »

message 401: by Sandy (new)

Sandy | 4335 comments Mod
I'm definitely on the characters first, mystery second team and probably the best example is how much I love the Amelia Peabody series - the mysteries are outrageous but the family is wonderful.


message 402: by Leslie (new)

Leslie | 600 comments Sandy wrote: "I'm definitely on the characters first, mystery second team and probably the best example is how much I love the Amelia Peabody series - the mysteries are outrageous but the family is wonderful."

Perhaps one reason that is such a successful series is that I love it too even though I am mystery first, characters second team! Though the best mysteries have both character & mystery of course...


message 403: by Lady Clementina (new)

Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore | 1237 comments Sandy wrote: "I'm definitely on the characters first, mystery second team and probably the best example is how much I love the Amelia Peabody series - the mysteries are outrageous but the family is wonderful."

I've only read one of those so far but it was great fun. They felt sort of like exaggerated versions of the characters from the Mummy films.


message 404: by Everyman (new)

Everyman | 540 comments Damaskcat wrote: With police procedural crime novels I dislike having to read a lot about the detectives' private lives but because the Ruth Galloway series isn't a police procedural I actually enjoy the private life bits and think they're an integral part of the books. "

What about the Hamish Macbeth mysteries? They're in a way police procedural, but they're also very much about his private life and how it develops (and undevelops) over the series.


message 405: by Sandy (new)

Sandy | 4335 comments Mod
I enjoy Hamish, but consider him more as an anti-police procedural (or maybe police anti-procedural) as he is so often on the outs with his boss. Or prehaps they usually are? I don't read many. I enjoy his personal life, the side characters and the community, but he doesn't develop.


message 406: by Betsy (new)

Betsy | 170 comments I agree. The Hamish of the first book and the latest book are mainly the same. Just the fact that he can't 'decide' between his women after some 20 books says a great deal about him plus I think he likes being the big man in his very small world. Granted his bosses are jerks, but that seems to be common in mysteries nowdays.


message 407: by Jan C (new)

Jan C (woeisme) | 1858 comments I've never been a fan of Hamish. They seem too much like "cozy" to me, although they may not technically fall under the definition of "cozy".


message 408: by Miss M (new)

Miss M | 101 comments I do think the MacBeth books are cozies, even with a policeman. Think I've finally given up on them though, took the last one back to the library unread. Just too formulaic for me and as Betsy says, really nothing ever changes.

I like how the personal lives and family of the detectives in Deborah Crombie's series have developed over tme.


message 409: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
The good thing about this debate is that there are SO many series, that you do not have to read any that don't interest you. The choice is so immense. I just think it depends on what you personally like. I don't mind Gregor Demarkian's cast of neighbours in the Jane Haddam books, but other series annoy me. If you don't warm to a series you can just drop it and try something else and thank goodness for all the great choice we have - truly we are spoilt as readers.


message 410: by HJ (last edited May 26, 2016 12:44AM) (new)

HJ | 207 comments Everyman wrote: "What about the Hamish Macbeth mysteries? They're in a way police procedural, but they're also very much about his private life and how it develops (and undevelops) over the series. ..."

For me the problem is that I love the TV series (I own the DVDs) but was disappointed by the books. He's almost anarchical in the TV series, and the characters of the villagers are wonderful too.


message 411: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments Susan wrote: "Normally, I tend to like the same books as you and Damaskcat, Ann, but I just really did not enjoy the first Ruth Galloway book. Never mind, it happens sometimes..."

It would be odd if we liked all the same books :-)


message 412: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments Everyman wrote: "Damaskcat wrote: With police procedural crime novels I dislike having to read a lot about the detectives' private lives but because the Ruth Galloway series isn't a police procedural I actually enj..."

Love Hamish Macbeth :-) He is so much a part of the mysteries he investigates because he usually knows the people involved that his private life is his work life I think.

I also like Cynthia Harrod Eages' Bill Slider mysteries but there is quite a lot about his private life in those too. I think it depends what the private life consists of as to whether I like reading about it. I got totally fed up of alcoholic detectives at one point when they were 'fashionable' that I went off series which had a lot about recurring personal problems in them.

I think one of the reasons why I like the Ruth Galloway series is because the main characters' personal problems do change and they do find creative solutions to them - even if those solutions don't work all the time. It's not the same problem all the time without any change or development.


message 413: by Everyman (new)

Everyman | 540 comments Miss M wrote: "I do think the MacBeth books are cozies, even with a policeman. Think I've finally given up on them though, took the last one back to the library unread. Just too formulaic for me and as Betsy says..."

Well, one thing that changed that I miss is his hill climbing. Maybe he's getting too old for it, but that was a fun feature of some of the early books which has been totally missing from the more recent books.


message 414: by Sandy (new)

Sandy | 4335 comments Mod
I forgot about his hill running, thanks for the reminder. I think Hamish lives in one of those timeless fantasy villages. Some of the stories go on for awhile as the author mentions that months have passed and seasons have changed (which I really appreciate as a small touch of reality vs. everything wrapped up in a week), so after 30 books he would be getting along in years in the real world.


message 415: by Ellen (new)

Ellen | 147 comments I am reading Hamlet, Revenge!byMichael Innes. It is the second in the Appleby series.


message 416: by Leslie (new)

Leslie | 600 comments I had some trouble with the first part of that but by the end I loved it! I think this is the one that made me decide to read more of the Appleby series.


message 417: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
I really must go back to Appleby - I enjoyed the first one in the series. I'm a sucker for books set in Oxford - my nephew is a student there and I love visiting him:)


message 418: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Bok (regency_reader) | 1036 comments Love the Appleby books! Also the novels that Michael Innes wrote under his real name, J. I. M. Stewart.


message 419: by Carolien (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments I've just started Murder in Steeple Martin and so far am enjoying it. I'm finding the descriptions on how and who harvested hops in Kent before automation especially interesting. It's one of those little side alleys in history that has completely disappeared. (Of course, what I should be doing is studying for my law exams that are coming up over the next two weeks!)


message 420: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
My mother used to go hop picking as a child, Carolien. I believe much of the East End decamped to Kent in the summer.


message 421: by Carolien (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments Susan wrote: "My mother used to go hop picking as a child, Carolien. I believe much of the East End decamped to Kent in the summer."

That's exactly what the book describes!


message 422: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments Susan wrote: "I really must go back to Appleby - I enjoyed the first one in the series. I'm a sucker for books set in Oxford - my nephew is a student there and I love visiting him:)"

The Appleby series is one I keep meaning to go back to as well.

Another author whose books are set in Oxford is Veronica Stallwood


message 423: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments Carolien wrote: "I've just started Murder in Steeple Martin and so far am enjoying it. I'm finding the descriptions on how and who harvested hops in Kent before automation especially interesting. It..."

By coincidence I'm listening to the audio book edition of the second book in that series - Murder at the Laurels


message 424: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments Carolien wrote: "Susan wrote: "My mother used to go hop picking as a child, Carolien. I believe much of the East End decamped to Kent in the summer."

That's exactly what the book describes!"


I think there's one of the Maisie Dobbs series which involves hop picking as well.


message 425: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
It was a cheap holiday for those in the East End. Whole communities used to go and camp in the same places each year. My mother had very pleasant memories of going.


message 426: by Everyman (new)

Everyman | 540 comments Have started The Cinema Murder (free from gutenberg) as my bedside book. It's a little weird so far, but enjoyable.

BTW, if you read e-books at bedtime, as I often do, read them on an ereader (Kindle or Nook) rather than on a tablet or smartphone. The white screen of a true ereader doesn't interfere with your ability to get to sleep, but the blue light screen of a tablet or smart phone does.


message 427: by Lady Clementina (new)

Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore | 1237 comments Everyman wrote: "Have started The Cinema Murder (free from gutenberg) as my bedside book. It's a little weird so far, but enjoyable.

BTW, if you read e-books at bedtime, as I often do, read them on an ereader (Kin..."


I prefer reading actual books at bedtime for the reasons you mentioned as well as comfort so I read e-books whenever I can during the day (all day these days since I am taking a break) but switch to a book at bedtime. At the moment that book is Duncton Wood.


message 428: by Judy (new)

Judy (wwwgoodreadscomprofilejudyg) | 11404 comments Mod
I'm just reading The Daughters of Gentlemen the second in the Frances Doughty series by Linda Stratmann at the moment, and enjoying it a lot - I love reading books set in the Victorian period, and she has a dry sense of humour which adds to my enjoyment. Thanks again to Damaskcat for the recommendation.


message 429: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
I just started Confessions which is really interesting/different so far.


message 430: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments Judy wrote: "I'm just reading The Daughters of Gentlemen the second in the Frances Doughty series by Linda Stratmann at the moment, and enjoying it a lot - I love reading books s..."

You're welcome, Judy and I'm glad you're enjoying them :-)


message 431: by Deborah (new)

Deborah (deborahkliegl) | 104 comments I'm reading an old Perry Mason. Picked it up a few weeks ago, then got busy. :(


message 432: by Carolien (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments Everyman wrote: "Have started The Cinema Murder (free from gutenberg) as my bedside book. It's a little weird so far, but enjoyable."

I enjoy Oppenheim, he wrote some of the very early spy thrillers as well.


message 433: by Everyman (new)

Everyman | 540 comments Deborah wrote: "I'm reading an old Perry Mason. Picked it up a few weeks ago, then got busy. :("

Oh, by golly, I had totally forgotten about Perry Mason. Although ESG certainly wasn't one of the "follow the rules" authors. But Raymond Burr was unforgettable.

I found out that the Perry Mason series is the best selling adult book series in history, according to Wikipedia. (Its third on the overall list; the top two are Harry Potter and Goosebumps.)


message 434: by Betsy (new)

Betsy | 170 comments I've read quite a few of the PERRY MASON books, and have seen all of the episodes.


message 435: by Jan C (new)

Jan C (woeisme) | 1858 comments I'm working my way through Perry Mason. Of course I saw all the shows. But I had read a book by Susan Kandel, I Dreamed I Married Perry Mason where the lead character, Cece Caruso, was working on a biography of Gardner. I'm on her fourth book now, Christietown. And Gardner's second. I have read a few others that were out of order though.


message 437: by Lady Clementina (new)

Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore | 1237 comments Everyman wrote: "Deborah wrote: "I'm reading an old Perry Mason. Picked it up a few weeks ago, then got busy. :("

Oh, by golly, I had totally forgotten about Perry Mason. Although ESG certainly wasn't one of the "..."


I enjoy Perry Mason books as well. Also the books by ESG with Gramps Wiggins.


message 438: by Damaskcat (new)

Damaskcat | 186 comments I'm currently reading my way through the Falconer Files by Andrea Frazer I can recommend them if you want something light to read. Plenty of humour and well plotted with interesting and likeable characters.


message 439: by Deborah (new)

Deborah (deborahkliegl) | 104 comments Everyman wrote: "Deborah wrote: "I'm reading an old Perry Mason. Picked it up a few weeks ago, then got busy. :("

Oh, by golly, I had totally forgotten about Perry Mason. Although ESG certainly wasn't one of the "..."


I found some used, and hadn't read one in years. It was on my shelf in out Tenn lake house. That house has been filled primarily with mysteries.


message 440: by Deborah (new)

Deborah (deborahkliegl) | 104 comments Jan C wrote: "I'm working my way through Perry Mason. Of course I saw all the shows. But I had read a book by Susan Kandel, I Dreamed I Married Perry Mason where the lead character..."

I read several Kandell books and enjoyed them


message 441: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca Libersat (bibliobeque) | 16 comments My grandparents had a wall of paperback mysteries in their home office, mostly Agatha Christie and Erle Stanley Gardner...I hadn't thought about that in years!

I've just started on Journey to Munich by Jacqueline Winspear. Next up is When Falcons Fall by C. S. Harris.


message 442: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
Just started Murder at the Loch Murder at the Loch by Eric Brown
This is the third in a series set in the 1950's and I enjoyed the previous two. The main character is a thriller writer and so it has a nice, bookish feel.


message 443: by Carolien (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments I've finished Murder in Steeple Martin. Nice cozy mystery with an intricate plot.


message 444: by HJ (new)

HJ | 207 comments Carolien wrote: "I've finished Murder in Steeple Martin. Nice cozy mystery with an intricate plot."

I've got that in my TBR pile. Must get round to it, especially since you recommend it!


message 445: by Deborah (new)

Deborah (deborahkliegl) | 104 comments Carolien wrote: "I've finished Murder in Steeple Martin. Nice cozy mystery with an intricate plot."

Good to know. It's on my list already, but now I will look for it


message 446: by Jan C (new)

Jan C (woeisme) | 1858 comments Carolien wrote: "I've finished Murder in Steeple Martin. Nice cozy mystery with an intricate plot."

I have it partially read on my Kindle. It gets lost in the crowd.


message 447: by Susan (new)

Susan | 13586 comments Mod
For something different, I just finished Confessions Confessions by Kanae Minato
a literary mystery set in Japan. It is not a 'whodunnit' but looks at he repercussions of a crime. Very good indeed.


message 448: by Carolien (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments Jan C wrote: "Carolien wrote: "I've finished Murder in Steeple Martin. Nice cozy mystery with an intricate plot."

I have it partially read on my Kindle. It gets lost in the crowd."


I know how that happens!


message 449: by Carolien (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments Susan wrote: "For something different, I just finished Confessions Confessions by Kanae Minato
a literary mystery set in Japan. It is not a 'whodunnit' but looks at he repercussions of a cri..."


Looks interesting. I have Claws of the Cat on my TBR list which is set in Japan.


message 450: by Carolien (last edited Jun 03, 2016 09:27AM) (new)

Carolien (carolien_s) | 597 comments I've just finished Killer Instinct (obviously reading crime fiction is much more amusing than my Criminal Procedure text book at this stage!).

One of the best female protagonists that I have encountered in a while and a solid plot. I like the writing style. It's fairly gruesome, but not as dark as some other books I have read recently and not morbid at all. I'll be checking out the rest of the series (which now involves a convoluted effort to get my husband to buy the Kindle editions via Amazon.co.uk for me as gifts since they're not available on Amazon.com.)


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.