Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
message 2951:
by
Carolien
(new)
May 13, 2018 03:58AM

reply
|
flag



One of my favourites in the series.
I've just started Inspector French and the Cheyne Mystery: An Inspector French Mystery, the second in the series by Freeman Wills Crofts.
A wonderful beginning - I'm instantly hooked.

I've now finished Inspector French and the Cheyne Mystery, second in the series, and I would have to say the plot is utterly bonkers - a really far-fetched adventure thriller. I was rather surprised by this, since the first book in the series was a much more down-to-earth and realistic mystery.
I did still enjoy it, but got a bit irritated with the central character of Max Cheyne, and was pleased when Inspector French finally turned up halfway through the book! Is anyone else reading this series?
I did still enjoy it, but got a bit irritated with the central character of Max Cheyne, and was pleased when Inspector French finally turned up halfway through the book! Is anyone else reading this series?

I've started the first one, I think. Inspector French's Greatest Case?
Jan C wrote: "I've started the first one, I think. Inspector French's Greatest Case? ..."
That's right. I enjoyed that one, and I've also read one out of order where Inspector French only comes in fairly briefly, so it feels more like a standalone, Antidote to Venom. I found that quite a creepy read, as a lot of it is seen from the point of view of a would-be killer planning his crime.
That's right. I enjoyed that one, and I've also read one out of order where Inspector French only comes in fairly briefly, so it feels more like a standalone, Antidote to Venom. I found that quite a creepy read, as a lot of it is seen from the point of view of a would-be killer planning his crime.
I've started reading Murder has a Motive by Francis Duncan.
This is the earliest title in the series about detective Mordecai Tremaine which has been reprinted by Vintage, but I believe there were actually earlier books which haven't been reprinted as yet.
I enjoyed Murder for Christmas and have been meaning to read the other reissued titles. Tremaine is a retired tobacconist with a passion for romantic fiction, so he is quite different from your average detective!

I enjoyed Murder for Christmas and have been meaning to read the other reissued titles. Tremaine is a retired tobacconist with a passion for romantic fiction, so he is quite different from your average detective!

I've started Mystery in the Channel, another Inspector French book.
Sorry, I meant to add, has anyone come across a complete list of the Mordecai Tremaine mysteries by Francis Duncan? All the sites I've looked at only list the five reprints, but one mentioned that there are 20+ mysteries by him altogether, though I don't know if any are non-series.
Confusingly, there is also a completely unrelated series by another author (sci-fi, I think) with a central character called Mordecai Tremaine - what are the chances?
Confusingly, there is also a completely unrelated series by another author (sci-fi, I think) with a central character called Mordecai Tremaine - what are the chances?

Not sure if this will help you Judy
https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/fr...

"Venko's organisation across Eastern Europe makes the Mafia look like the Women's Institute."
"My mother's in the Women's Institute," I said drily. "They're a pretty tough bunch."
I (Charlie) was rewarded with another near-miss of a smile. "I didn't know they had a swat team."
"You be amazed," I said "what she can do with knitting needles".
Carolien wrote: "Not sure if this will help you Judy
https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/fr....."
Thanks, Carolien, that is helpful - it does list all his books although it doesn't say which ones feature Tremayne.
https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/fr....."
Thanks, Carolien, that is helpful - it does list all his books although it doesn't say which ones feature Tremayne.

Just finished The Man in the Picture by Susan Hill A ghost story but still a mystery.
Now starting Artists in Crime for June group read
Only the 5 reprints - I think some of the others are Tremaine books too. Sorry I wasn’t clear before.
https://prettysinister.blogspot.co.uk...
According to this article there are 2 other Tremaine books outside the reprints - "Five of Francis Duncan's mystery novels featuring Mordecai Tremaine have been reprinted by Vintage Books in their Death's Head Moth imprint. The other two are In at the Red and Murder for Christmas".
Sounds an interesting find, but I am not sure how complete that list is.
According to this article there are 2 other Tremaine books outside the reprints - "Five of Francis Duncan's mystery novels featuring Mordecai Tremaine have been reprinted by Vintage Books in their Death's Head Moth imprint. The other two are In at the Red and Murder for Christmas".
Sounds an interesting find, but I am not sure how complete that list is.
https://www.theguardian.com/books/201...
He sounds a fascinating man, Judy. This article suggests there are nine titles! Confused?!
http://moonlight-detective.blogspot.c...
"five of (reportedly) nine titles from the author's series about a retired tobacconist, Mordecai Tremaine – who's also an amateur criminologist and professional murder-magnet".
He sounds a fascinating man, Judy. This article suggests there are nine titles! Confused?!
http://moonlight-detective.blogspot.c...
"five of (reportedly) nine titles from the author's series about a retired tobacconist, Mordecai Tremaine – who's also an amateur criminologist and professional murder-magnet".
Thanks so much for posting the links, Susan! If there are nine titles altogether, I hope Vintage gets round to reprinting the others. The one I'm reading at the moment works well on its own, but does mention that there were earlier cases.
I think the first blogger is just mentioning the other two books in the five reprints, after discussing three of them in his post. Murder for Christmas was the first one to be reprinted, and In at the Red looks like a typo for In at the Death. I will bookmark this post to return to after reading more of the books.
:)
I think the first blogger is just mentioning the other two books in the five reprints, after discussing three of them in his post. Murder for Christmas was the first one to be reprinted, and In at the Red looks like a typo for In at the Death. I will bookmark this post to return to after reading more of the books.
:)
Sorry everyone, Goodreads went mad and posted my last comment about 10 times. I have removed the duplicates! Hoping it does not do the same with this one.


I am reading at Michael Shayne mystery that I got at a library sale.
Whereas "The Dain Curse" was more literary, the Shayne mystery is more of an easy read.


They look interesting. I've downloaded a sample.




I listened to Artists in Crime narrated by Benedict Cumberbatch and was surprised by how good a narrator he is!
I look at that version, Paperbackreader, but it was abridged. I do need to start this one soon, though.

That is a fascinating observation and I've thought about it quite a bit since I originally read your post. It would be really interesting to keep a running tab of the mysteries I read (since it's one of my favorite genres!) with respect to publication date and gender/age of victim.

The Devil's Novice
I'm reading the series in order at the rate of one or two a year. Great series. I remember my grandmother reading these books when I was a kid and later we watched all the Cadfael shows together. I find that I remember almost none of the plots though.

The Devil's Novice
I'm reading the series in order at the rate of one or two a year. Great series. I remember my grandmother reading these books when I was a kid and l..."
I was drawn to these books as a kid, mainly because I loved the cover art that was reminiscent of stained glass windows. I've read a bunch of the books, but not in order, and spread out over many years. I recently got an abridged collection of the audiobooks from audible that were fun to listen to as the narrator is Derek Jacobi, who also starred in the shows. One suspects that a lot of murders from that time period went unsolved (if they were classified as murders at all), so its interesting to see how they can be solved before modern technological advancements (or even fingerprinting) were available.
Annabel makes a good point about modern victims. Often, in GA novels, they are wealthy businessmen; rarely are victims children. I agree that GA authors did not need that kind of tragic, emotional pull. In fact, often, the victim was a blackmailer, or other ne'er do well (to borrow the slang of the time!) and readers were not meant to care too much about their fate, but just puzzle out who did it.

I've often heard it said that GA novels were deliberately cosy, with unpleasant victims no one cared about, because everyone was traumatised about the world wars and needed something gentle. Which may partially explain it, I suppose. But I certainly don't feel that the opposite is true now!

I seem to remember both Poirot and Miss Marple commenting on the wickedness of depriving a young woman of her future life. Granted they're not gory or focused on rape and/or torture as has been the case in more modern books, but I've never found Christie as 'cosy' as she is sometimes claimed to be.

Golden Age - as in most of the mysteries read in this group.
I sometimes have brain freezes about it, too.

I agree. Christie often had victims who were sympathetic. She even had children/teenaged victims. Also, I can think of a Ngaio Marsh victim whose rather cruel death shook me! But it is true that, overall, GA authors wrote books that had 'evil' or 'unsatisfactory' people as the victims.

Golden Age - as in most of the mysteries read in this group.
I sometimes have brain freezes about..."
Thank you!
I'm reading Artists in Crime now too, and enjoying it so far - I had remembered it as one of my favourites in the series. Looking forward to or discussion.
I've read some GA books with sympathetic victims - one or two by Nicholas Blake come to mind. But they don't usually dwell on the details of the death in a gory way.
Yes, there are sometimes sympathetic victims, but a great deal more male victims than seem to appear in current crime books - almost every victim seems to be a young woman or a child these days.
I am reading a new Ruth Galloway, The Dark Angel (no link!). A favorite series. No murder in the first third, but tension and all the lead characters.
I am next in line for the latest Maisie Dobbs so expect to be reading that next weekend, with Artists In Crime and a quick review of A Quiet Life in the Country during the week.
I am next in line for the latest Maisie Dobbs so expect to be reading that next weekend, with Artists In Crime and a quick review of A Quiet Life in the Country during the week.


I've also started A Quiet Life in the Country - 40% of the day through, only one mystery so far. This seems like a very quick read, so as soon as I finish I will report back on whether there are any other stories in my edition!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...