Reading the Detectives discussion
      note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
    
  
  
      Archived threads
      >
    What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
    
  
  
        message 1051:
      by
      
          Lynne
      
        
          (new)
        
    
    
      Jan 20, 2017 11:22AM
    
     Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!
      Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!
    
          reply
          |
      
      flag
    
   Lynne wrote: "Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!"
      Lynne wrote: "Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!"That is one of the greatest classics of all mystery books IMHO. Did you guess who dunnit? I'm surely not going to spoil it for others by even hinting!!
        
      I just started Slow Horses 
   about a group of misfit special agents who have been side lined to administrative tasks. It's the first in a series and I think I'm going to like it.
 about a group of misfit special agents who have been side lined to administrative tasks. It's the first in a series and I think I'm going to like it.
    
  
  
   about a group of misfit special agents who have been side lined to administrative tasks. It's the first in a series and I think I'm going to like it.
 about a group of misfit special agents who have been side lined to administrative tasks. It's the first in a series and I think I'm going to like it.
     Just found this group, happy for that!! I am between mysteries right now, but I just completed The Murder on the Links by Agatha Christie - it is her 3rd book and her 2nd featuring Poirot.
      Just found this group, happy for that!! I am between mysteries right now, but I just completed The Murder on the Links by Agatha Christie - it is her 3rd book and her 2nd featuring Poirot.
     Susan wrote: "I just started Slow Horses
      Susan wrote: "I just started Slow Horses  about a group of misfit special agents who have been side lined to administrative tasks. It's the first in a series and I..."
 about a group of misfit special agents who have been side lined to administrative tasks. It's the first in a series and I..."This has been on my TBR for ages. I really must get around to it, because it looks very interesting.
 Jill wrote: "Lynne wrote: "Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!"
      Jill wrote: "Lynne wrote: "Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!"That is one of the greatest classics of all mystery books IMHO. Did you guess who dunnit? I'm surely not going to spoil it for other..."
I won't write a spoiler either---but I will say I began to suspect about 2/3 the way through. Yes, it is a classic!!
        
      Blaine wrote: "Just found this group, happy for that!! I am between mysteries right now, but I just completed The Murder on the Links by Agatha Christie - it is her 3rd book and her 2nd featuring Poirot."
Welcome, Blaine! We have lots of Agatha Christie fans here so you have come to the right place. :)
  
  
  Welcome, Blaine! We have lots of Agatha Christie fans here so you have come to the right place. :)
 We loved The Murder of Roger Ackroyd as well! In fact we just did one of our most recent podcast episodes about it! Check it out if you'd like; we go into a more detailed analysis of exactly how Christie pulls off that AMAZING twist!
      We loved The Murder of Roger Ackroyd as well! In fact we just did one of our most recent podcast episodes about it! Check it out if you'd like; we go into a more detailed analysis of exactly how Christie pulls off that AMAZING twist! https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/a...
Lynne wrote: "Just finished Murder of Roger Ackroyd. Great!!!!"
 Welcome Blaine! We did a podcast episode about Murder on the Links that you might enjoy.... One thing we learned while researching for the episode: it was inspired by Gaston Leroux's The Yellow Room, which is one reason the book has a bit more of a heavy tone than Christie usually does.... We also enjoyed the rivalry between Poirot and the French Inspector, Giraud. Another interesting tidbit: when the novel was first serialized, it was called "The Girl With the Anxious Eyes." I feel like that may be a better title? Especially since there is very little golf in this book! (The Suchet adaptation definitely solves that problem; lots more golf there....)
      Welcome Blaine! We did a podcast episode about Murder on the Links that you might enjoy.... One thing we learned while researching for the episode: it was inspired by Gaston Leroux's The Yellow Room, which is one reason the book has a bit more of a heavy tone than Christie usually does.... We also enjoyed the rivalry between Poirot and the French Inspector, Giraud. Another interesting tidbit: when the novel was first serialized, it was called "The Girl With the Anxious Eyes." I feel like that may be a better title? Especially since there is very little golf in this book! (The Suchet adaptation definitely solves that problem; lots more golf there....)Episode is #11 on our list:
https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/a...
Blaine wrote: "Just found this group, happy for that!! I am between mysteries right now, but I just completed The Murder on the Links by Agatha Christie - it is her 3rd book and her 2nd featuring Poirot."
 We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one was right up there with her best. Anyone else a Tana French fan?
      We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one was right up there with her best. Anyone else a Tana French fan?
     All About Agatha wrote: "Welcome Blaine! We did a podcast episode about Murder on the Links that you might enjoy.... One thing we learned while researching for the episode: it was inspired by Gaston Leroux's The Yellow Roo..."
      All About Agatha wrote: "Welcome Blaine! We did a podcast episode about Murder on the Links that you might enjoy.... One thing we learned while researching for the episode: it was inspired by Gaston Leroux's The Yellow Roo..."Just found the podcast---A+. Thank you!
 All About Agatha wrote: "We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one was right up there with he..."
      All About Agatha wrote: "We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one was right up there with he..."I have a couple books of hers on the shelf---my mother-in-law passes them along to me and I kinda forgot about them. Now I shall have to move them up the queue!
        
      I'm just reading a British Library Crime Classics book on Kindle, Sergeant Cluff Stands Firm by Gil North. This is the first in the series about a Yorkshire detective and seems a bit darker and more realistic than most BLCC reprints - it is also more recent, published in 1960.
I've also got a mystery on the go in a physical book, Talking to the Dead by Harry Bingham, which is another first in a series, about Welsh police detective Fiona Griffiths. Compelling but *very* dark so far - I might need some lighter relief after these two books.
  
  
  I've also got a mystery on the go in a physical book, Talking to the Dead by Harry Bingham, which is another first in a series, about Welsh police detective Fiona Griffiths. Compelling but *very* dark so far - I might need some lighter relief after these two books.
        
      I enjoy books set in the Sixties, Judy, so will look at the Gil North one.
Andrew, I am really enjoying "Slow Horses," so far and it is a series I have also meant to read for ages.
  
  
  Andrew, I am really enjoying "Slow Horses," so far and it is a series I have also meant to read for ages.
 Judy wrote: "I'm just reading a British Library Crime Classics book on Kindle, Sergeant Cluff Stands Firm by Gil North. This is the first in the series about a Yorkshire detecti..."
      Judy wrote: "I'm just reading a British Library Crime Classics book on Kindle, Sergeant Cluff Stands Firm by Gil North. This is the first in the series about a Yorkshire detecti..."They both look good.
 All About Agatha wrote: "We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one was right up there with he..."
      All About Agatha wrote: "We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one was right up there with he..."Re; Tana French. I have read all her books except The Trespasser and have liked them very much. However, I have to agree with you that The Secret Place was pretty weak and not on the same level with her other works. Disappointing but hopefully The Trespasser will be better. Did you like it?
        
      Susan wrote: "I enjoy books set in the Sixties, Judy, so will look at the Gil North one.
Susan, I realised it is really set in the late 1950s, as it was published on January 1, 1960. I read through to the end very quickly (it's a short book) but wasn't really a fan overall as it is a bit on one note - everything is dark, dingy, gloomy, miserable etc. The writing style is very readable though. Anyway I've written a review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
  
  
  Susan, I realised it is really set in the late 1950s, as it was published on January 1, 1960. I read through to the end very quickly (it's a short book) but wasn't really a fan overall as it is a bit on one note - everything is dark, dingy, gloomy, miserable etc. The writing style is very readable though. Anyway I've written a review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
        
      Good review, Judy. Having read it, I see your point! Maybe I will get to it, but perhaps it has dropped down my TBR list a few notches...
    
  
  
   Almost finished with Bar Mitzvah Murder by Lee Harris. I have read all the previous in the series and only have two left to finish them all. Not the best, not the worst, but a quick fill in between "meatier" fare!
      Almost finished with Bar Mitzvah Murder by Lee Harris. I have read all the previous in the series and only have two left to finish them all. Not the best, not the worst, but a quick fill in between "meatier" fare!
     Yes, we loved it! The thing about The Secret Place that didn't work as well for us was the third-person perspective for those parts written about Holly and her friends at school.... Every other book French has written has been from the first-person POV (as were the Stephen parts of Secret Place) and that seems to work much better for her. Also, the magical realism stuff didn't fully play.... The Trespasser is firmly back on the ground, no supernatural(ish) stuff.
      Yes, we loved it! The thing about The Secret Place that didn't work as well for us was the third-person perspective for those parts written about Holly and her friends at school.... Every other book French has written has been from the first-person POV (as were the Stephen parts of Secret Place) and that seems to work much better for her. Also, the magical realism stuff didn't fully play.... The Trespasser is firmly back on the ground, no supernatural(ish) stuff.Incidentally, we had the same issue re: third-person vs first-person with two Christie novels, The Man in the Brown Suit (written from two different first-person perspectives) versus The Secret of Chimneys (written from a roving third-person perspective). The former worked EXTREMELY well, whereas the latter did NOT. (Much more about this on episodes 7 and 9 of our podcast: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/a....)
Jill wrote: "All About Agatha wrote: "We (Kemper & Catherine) both recently read The Trespasser, by Tana French.... We both adore her. Her last book, The Secret Place, was a little disappointing, but this one w..."
 Judy wrote: "I'm just reading a British Library Crime Classics book on Kindle, Sergeant Cluff Stands Firm by Gil North. This is the first in the series about a Yorkshire detecti..."
      Judy wrote: "I'm just reading a British Library Crime Classics book on Kindle, Sergeant Cluff Stands Firm by Gil North. This is the first in the series about a Yorkshire detecti..."I've been dipping into the second Cluff book, not very impressed so far...seems to give new meaning to the notion of 'taciturn.' Reminds me a little bit of the Mosley series, but Insp. Mosley is much more entertaining.
Murder, Mr. Mosley
        
      Thanks Miss M, I might try another Cluff but sounds as if I shouldn't hold my breath
I'll check out Mosley.
  
  
  I'll check out Mosley.
        
      I just finished The Shifting Tide, #14 in Anne Perry's Monk series: a Victorian London setting by a modern author. It's a series I really like but have ignored lately due to other reading commitments. I'm tempted to pick up the next one immediately. This one introduces Monk to the Thames and I know he joins the river police eventually.
    
  
  
   Sandy wrote: "I just finished The Shifting Tide, #14 in Anne Perry's Monk series: a Victorian London setting by a modern author. It's a series I really like but have ignored lately due to other read..."
      Sandy wrote: "I just finished The Shifting Tide, #14 in Anne Perry's Monk series: a Victorian London setting by a modern author. It's a series I really like but have ignored lately due to other read..."Have you read the previous William Monk books? Which one is your favorite?
        
      I have read the prior novels. I cannot identify a favorite (maybe Shifting Tide, but probably because I just read it). My least favorite was the one where they went to the US during the Civil War.
    
  
  
   Susan wrote: "I enjoy books set in the Sixties, Judy, so will look at the Gil North one.
      Susan wrote: "I enjoy books set in the Sixties, Judy, so will look at the Gil North one.Susan, you may also enjoy the Amanda Cross series of books set in the United States 1960s. A feminist professor is the main character.
        
      Thanks for the recommendation, Daniele, I will certainly take a look - I enjoy academic mysteries.
    
  
  
   Sandy wrote: "I have read the prior novels. I cannot identify a favorite (maybe Shifting Tide, but probably because I just read it). My least favorite was the one where they went to the US during the Civil War."
      Sandy wrote: "I have read the prior novels. I cannot identify a favorite (maybe Shifting Tide, but probably because I just read it). My least favorite was the one where they went to the US during the Civil War."I think the one set during the Civil War was "Slaves of Obsession". Another series I love is the Thomas & Charlotte Pitt and my favorite one is the first book "The Cater Street Hangman"
 I have read a few of the Thomas and Charlotte Pitt series and thought they were interesting, especially how the police worked in that era of no fingerprinting, DNA, etc.
      I have read a few of the Thomas and Charlotte Pitt series and thought they were interesting, especially how the police worked in that era of no fingerprinting, DNA, etc.
     Jill wrote: "I have read a few of the Thomas and Charlotte Pitt series and thought they were interesting, especially how the police worked in that era of no fingerprinting, DNA, etc."
      Jill wrote: "I have read a few of the Thomas and Charlotte Pitt series and thought they were interesting, especially how the police worked in that era of no fingerprinting, DNA, etc."I'm imagining it's hard to write mysteries set during contemporary times considering that DNA would be easy to spot out who the murderer is. It doesn't take as much leg or brain work as the detectives of old like Sherlock Holmes or Poirot.
 That's true, unless you encounter the perfect criminal, one with the steps can only be follow and sometimes predicted by Miss Jane Marple or Mr Nero Wolf.
      That's true, unless you encounter the perfect criminal, one with the steps can only be follow and sometimes predicted by Miss Jane Marple or Mr Nero Wolf.
    
        
      I have read the first two Pitt books, but decided concentrate on only one of Perry's series (Monk) so I could keep them seperate. I have so many years of good reading ahead of me!
    
  
  
  
        
      Reading What You Don't Know 
   which is an impressive debut and started
 which is an impressive debut and started 
   Dead Lions the second Slough House mystery. If anyone is a Le Carre fan, Mick Herron really gives spy mysteries a modern twist, but with lots of nods to the classic spy novel.
 Dead Lions the second Slough House mystery. If anyone is a Le Carre fan, Mick Herron really gives spy mysteries a modern twist, but with lots of nods to the classic spy novel.
    
  
  
   which is an impressive debut and started
 which is an impressive debut and started 
   Dead Lions the second Slough House mystery. If anyone is a Le Carre fan, Mick Herron really gives spy mysteries a modern twist, but with lots of nods to the classic spy novel.
 Dead Lions the second Slough House mystery. If anyone is a Le Carre fan, Mick Herron really gives spy mysteries a modern twist, but with lots of nods to the classic spy novel.
     I'm about to start reading The Sittaford Mystery
      I'm about to start reading The Sittaford Mystery
   and while I read that I'm going to read the well-known short story by Roald Dahl Lamb to the Slaughter
 and while I read that I'm going to read the well-known short story by Roald Dahl Lamb to the Slaughter
   and then proceed to reading the Poirot short story collection Poirot Investigates
 and then proceed to reading the Poirot short story collection Poirot Investigates
   reading a few of the stories then proceed to another novel (after The Sittaford Mystery) then read another few stories from the Poirot collection.
 reading a few of the stories then proceed to another novel (after The Sittaford Mystery) then read another few stories from the Poirot collection.
     Susan wrote: "Thanks for the recommendation, Daniele, I will certainly take a look - I enjoy academic mysteries."
      Susan wrote: "Thanks for the recommendation, Daniele, I will certainly take a look - I enjoy academic mysteries."As do I. I never attended a college, although I had always wanted to. This gets me close anyway:}
 I went to oxfam and looked for the penguin logo in the crime section and came away with Gentlemen and ladies by Susan Hill. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3... which is a book so obscure I had to add the edition myself, but amazon have second hand copies.
      I went to oxfam and looked for the penguin logo in the crime section and came away with Gentlemen and ladies by Susan Hill. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3... which is a book so obscure I had to add the edition myself, but amazon have second hand copies. Looks to be a one of those little village wth lots of old ladies mysteries, was published in 1968 when she was 20 but she wrote it when she was still at school.
 Susan wrote: "Just finished debut novel What You Don't Know
      Susan wrote: "Just finished debut novel What You Don't Know  based loosely upon John Wayne Gacy."
 based loosely upon John Wayne Gacy."I recently read this one too. It was a bit too grim for me, but I thought it was well written
      I am about to start reading meet me in Malmo by Torquil Macleod an Anita Sundstrom novel only on chapter four first time reading this author. Really enjoying this book although i am just starting.
    
  
  
   Susan wrote: "Just finished debut novel What You Don't Know
      Susan wrote: "Just finished debut novel What You Don't Know  based loosely upon John Wayne Gacy."
 based loosely upon John Wayne Gacy."As a (former) Chicagoan I tend to stay away from stories about either Gacy or Richard Speck. I had a friend who had a friend was almost picked up by Gacy and I was in town when they were digging up the basement. I was visiting from Albany at the time. I was still in high school when Speck had his rampage (killing 23 Philippine nurses). There was a big fear running through the area between the time that the murders were known aand they found him at the Mark Twain Hotel (essentially a flop house at the time).
 Just started
      Just started 
   Murder in the Ball Park by Robert Goldsborough. Archie and Saul are attending a ballgame between the Brooklyn Dodgers and the New York Giants when a state senator is shot and killed not far from where they are sitting.
 Murder in the Ball Park by Robert Goldsborough. Archie and Saul are attending a ballgame between the Brooklyn Dodgers and the New York Giants when a state senator is shot and killed not far from where they are sitting.
     Gary wrote: "Just started
      Gary wrote: "Just started  Murder in the Ball Park by Robert Goldsborough. Archie and Saul are attending a ballgame between the Brookly..."
 Murder in the Ball Park by Robert Goldsborough. Archie and Saul are attending a ballgame between the Brookly..."How do you like the Goldsborough books as opposed to the Rex Stout originals?
 I have read most of the Goldsborough's, this is one of the two I haven't read. So far Archie and Saul have attended a ballgame, a state senator has been murdered and his widow, who is a neighbor of one Lily Rowan, has attempted to hire Wolfe. All that in the first 25 pages. I have enjoyed them in some cases more than some of Stout's. RG knows his Wolfe inside and out as you'd expect from a long time member of The Wolfe Pack. The newer books take place during the period Stout was writing. The first batch Goldsborough wrote take place after Stout's final novel.
      I have read most of the Goldsborough's, this is one of the two I haven't read. So far Archie and Saul have attended a ballgame, a state senator has been murdered and his widow, who is a neighbor of one Lily Rowan, has attempted to hire Wolfe. All that in the first 25 pages. I have enjoyed them in some cases more than some of Stout's. RG knows his Wolfe inside and out as you'd expect from a long time member of The Wolfe Pack. The newer books take place during the period Stout was writing. The first batch Goldsborough wrote take place after Stout's final novel.
     I always worry that when someone else takes on the writing of a classic series it won't live up to my expectations. I have read all of the original Nero Wolfe corpus (some a couple of times) but I may have to break down and try one of Goldsborough's. Which one would you suggest as a starter?.....I like the period of the 40s and 50s.
      I always worry that when someone else takes on the writing of a classic series it won't live up to my expectations. I have read all of the original Nero Wolfe corpus (some a couple of times) but I may have to break down and try one of Goldsborough's. Which one would you suggest as a starter?.....I like the period of the 40s and 50s.
     I have only read 2 of the books set in the 30s - 50s Archie in the Crosshairs and Archie Meets Nero Wolfe: A Prequel to Rex Stout's Nero Wolfe Mysteries. In the latter Archie is the focus but it answers the question how Archie got the job. In the former pot shots are taken at Archie as he walks home from a poker game at Saul's place. I liked them both.
      I have only read 2 of the books set in the 30s - 50s Archie in the Crosshairs and Archie Meets Nero Wolfe: A Prequel to Rex Stout's Nero Wolfe Mysteries. In the latter Archie is the focus but it answers the question how Archie got the job. In the former pot shots are taken at Archie as he walks home from a poker game at Saul's place. I liked them both.
    
        
      I just finished Dead Lions Dead Lions the second in the Slough House series. Really good and I think I may have discovered a spy series that is as compelling as Le Carre, albeit in a different way...
    
  
  
  
      This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
  
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...







