Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just start?



How was it?"
She apparently has just started it so let me give my opinion: it has no business on a list of books one must read before one dies. I read it when it was published mostly because I had a problem with folks trying to get it banned (I object to even bad books getting banned) but in the end, I found it to be an interesting experiment but in the end pretty shallow and the story itself is so revolting that I was left with no reason to read it. Maybe it's because I deal with sociopaths in my work but I just don't see enough in them to make we want to read a novel about them.

How was it?"
She apparently has just started it so let me give my opinion: it has no business on a list of books one must read befo..."
Oh, now I have to read it--just to see how weird it is! Thanks for the warning though. :-)

How was it?"
She apparently has just started it so let me give my opinion: it has no business on a list of b..."
Ok, I just read a synopsis for it, and on second thought, maybe I won't read it!


I felt the same way - picked it up and finished it in a weekend because it is a simple read but yet very captivating. So moving in its perspective and makes you realize sometimes adults don't realize the impact they have on their children.

Hey Stacie, I will be very much interested in hearing what you think of it. I am currently reading Borges and it is said that Umberto Eco is the only author who at all comes close to Borges' style.

I like most of Padgett's short stories/prose writing, but some of it just mystifies me. Like why Padgett uses sentences like: "Spavined clavicular, and cowhocked, with an air not of malice but simply of a leaden determination..." to describe a mid-western farmer. I get it, the guy's been through a lot, but there's less pretentious ways of getting his point across.
He seems to like these sort of sentences, so I'm becoming very familiar with Dictionary.com

I am liking it. It isn't a quick read by any means. It is very dense and I find myself going back and re-reading some of the passages. The monastic debates are interesting, but sometimes confusing.
I am not a HUGE fan of semiotics, and there is a lot of that in here. However, my theories class is all coming back to me, and I am finding the debates on the meanings of words very interesting...what does it mean to be a heretic versus being holy.
His descriptions of the towers and the library are great and it makes me want to search out a monastary to see if the libraries are really like that.
I haven't read Borges, so I can't compare. :)

Really enjoyed this one. It took a bit to get into, but it was really good. Hope you like it.

I am liking it. It isn't a quick read by any means. It is very dense and I find myself going back and re-reading some of the passages. The monastic debates are interesting, but sometimes..."
Thanks a lot, Stacie. This sounds like something worth checking out, as long as one has enough time on hands.


I am liking it. It isn't a quick read by any means. It is very dense and I find myself going back and re-reading some of the passages. The monastic debates are interesting, but sometimes..."
what book are you talking about and who is the author?

Katie, I had the same issue. It took some time for me to get into, but once I did, I was hooked and the last 300 pages went by quite quicker than the first 200. Once it was over, I was kind of sad to see it end.
Now on to some brain candy off the list...reading book 2 of the Sookie Stackhouse series. :)

its not going well so far, quite dry dare I say boring

Katie, I had the same issue. It took some time for me to get into, but once I did, I was hooked and the last 300 pages went by quit..."
I watch Sookie on True Blood, do you?

Mentioned this novel to a friend of my husband - he and his wife lived in Denmark in the next street that the story is set in! They have both read the novel and thought it ended weakly. I'm 1/2 through it.


Sadly, no. We don't have HBO. However, I have heard great things about it and plan to put it on my Netflix list.

Good to know. I just got this and plan on reading it some time this year. Thanks for the heads up.

FYI - The first season is already on Netflix if your waiting.

its not going well so far, quite dry dare I say boring"
Ana hang in there. It gets better.....and it's short. It's a worthwhile read but if you're like me all the cricket stuff gets tiresome.
Cynthia

Sadly, no. We don't have HBO. However, I have heard great things about it and plan to put it on my Netflix list."
The first season can be bought in any retail store.



I tried to read this once on my own and too found that I had a hard time getting into it. My advice would be to get the annotated notes (which is very helpful), but also read it with a group; whether you can take a class or just find people to read it with and discuss it. Once I did that, I fell in love with that book...just a thought. :)

I tried to read this once on my own and too found that I had a hard ..."
I bought Ulysses together with a book of annotations for it, Ulysses Annotated.
I'm not sure when I'll finally pick Ulysses up but when I do I'll look for a discussion within this group or possibly create one. There does not seem to be one at this time.

Their Number 1 book is Trollope's The Way We Live Now, which isn't even on the 1001 list. Nor is their next novel, their no. 5 book (the majority of their books are not novels), Faulkner's The Bear. Nor is their third novel, number 12 on their list, Flannery O'connor's A Good Man is hard to Find.
I haven't gone through the two lists and compared them title by title, but it's interesting, at least to me, that there is no crossover with the top novels on the Newsweek list.


its not going well so far, quite dry dare I say boring"
Ana hang in there. It gets better.....and i..."
Thanks Cynthia I am but we are making slow progress - I have a no books left behind policy so i will finish it

I started War and Peace yesterday. I've been reading Lolita for couple of weeks. That's going slow for me.


I started War and Peace yesterday. I've been reading [book:Lolita|7604..."
My goodness you are an ambitious one! From Lolita to W&P! They should add in some fun/humorous reads in this list to act as a diversion from the tombs of Ulysses and W&P! I got W&P on my Kindle because I thought it would make me read it, but now I just have two versions of the same book on my to-read list :)

Please let me know if you continue to like the way she writes. I am interested in her books. Richard

Oh, I agree completely! Happy books are hard to find. Last month, I finished
Giovanni's Room, Lord of the Flies and The War of the Worlds out of the list. Definitely not happy books. But I have to say War and Peace is a happy book right now but I'm only at page 100 so I probably haven't gotten to the war part yet :-)
To further prove your point, I started
In Cold Blood yesterday.


I hope you enjoy it, Lyn. This is one of my favorite books by her.

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
City of Bones (other topics)Bouvard and Pécuchet (other topics)
Lolita (other topics)
O Homem Sem Qualidades (other topics)
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Barack Obama (other topics)Mario Vargas Llosa (other topics)
Iain Banks (other topics)
Chinua Achebe (other topics)
V.S. Naipaul (other topics)
More...
How was it?