LOTR Minor Hero Elimination game!! Yay!

[Chloe]

Add ONE POINT to the Hero you like most, and subtract ONE POINT from your least favorite Hero. When a Hero hits zero, they're eliminated from the game. All Heroes are starting with 10 points. and im just going to repeat this cuz some ppl dont follow the rules, add and take just ONE point, ONE point, from any two heroes that haven't been eliminated. Here they are:

Éomer: 10
Éowyn: 10
Faramir: 10
Samwise Gamgee: 10
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 10

Okay, i will start, and i want to tell you, you probably noticed, I did remove MAJOR characters like Aragorn and Frodo, but for good reason, i know how many fangirls think Aragorn is ADORABLE, but I like the little guys :) Teodred is someone who dies early on, but i just decided to add him, though i have a feeling he will be eliminated first...Another thing i want to address is DONT get upset saying one of them is not a minor hero, also, dont you dare get upset that Éowyn is a woman, she DOES count as a heroin and she is one of my favs, and if you dont like her...Well i just dont know what to do with you. -_-

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 10
Faramir: 10
Samwise Gamgee: 10
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 9

[[deleted user]]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 10
Samwise Gamgee: 10
Prince Imrahil: 9
Théodred: 9

[Willl]

Sam 11
Prince imrahil 9
Although I really like faramir to!

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11 
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 10 
Samwise Gamgee: 11
Prince Imrahil: 9
Théodred: 8

[Chloe]

Éomer: 10
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 10
Samwise Gamgee: 12
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 7

Umm... why dont u ppl like Imrahil? Just wondering... :)

[Kelly Brigid ♡]

Éomer: 10
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 11
Samwise Gamgee: 12
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 6

Why is Sam still up here? He's a main character.

[Chloe]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 11
Samwise Gamgee: 11
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 6

idk, i just felt Sam wasn't really a HUGE main character, but not as foreign as some...

[Deeptanshu]

Éomer: 12
Éowyn: 12
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 12
Prince Imrahil: 9
Théodred: 5

[Chloe]

Umm.. You add only one point to ONE hero... You adde points to like...everyone XD

[Chloe]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 11
Samwise Gamgee: 12
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 5
okay, sorry, i tried to fix it... so now mine

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 11
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 5
really sorry sam :'(

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 12
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 4

[Spa]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 12
Faramir: 11
Samwise Gamgee: 12
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 4

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 12
Faramir: 11
Samwise Gamgee: 13
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 3

[Saro]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 12
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 13
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 2

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 12
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 14
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 1

[Vidya]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 14
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 2

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 15
Prince Imrahil: 10
Théodred: 1

[Chloe]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 14
Prince Imrahil: 11
Théodred: 1

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 11
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 15
Prince Imrahil: 11

[Chloe]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 12
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 14
Prince Imrahil: 11
bye bye Theodred!

[Kelly Brigid ♡]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 13
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 14
Prince Imrahil: 10

[Kelly]

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 13
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 15
Prince Imrahil: 9

[Caitlin]

Samwise Gamgee is not only a main character, but he is my FAVORITE character!!!! :)

Éomer: 11
Éowyn: 13
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 16
Prince Imrahil: 8

[Benja]

How come Samwise is a "minor hero"?

[Chloe]

Well, sorry, but I felt he was not as big as Frodo's, yeah ur right, but I needs another character :/

[Kelly]

Éomer: 12
Éowyn: 14
Faramir: 12
Samwise Gamgee: 16
Prince Imrahil: 6

[Caitlin]

Reasons why Samwise Gamgee is a main character, not a minor hero: :)

1) Sam has just as big of a role (or even more) than Pippin or Merry, but I noticed you did not put them up here.

2) Sam is introduced in the very first chapter. The last sentence in the trilogy ends with him. "And Rose drew him in, and set him in his chair, and put little Elanor upon his lap. He drew a deep breath. 'Well, I'm back,' he said."

3) Without Sam, Frodo would have NEVER been able to destroy the ring. He would have died, or given up, or fell under the ring's spell. Frodo would never have made it so far.

4) Because of the reason above, some would argue that Sam is really the ultimate hero of the story. Think about it. If he had not gotten Frodo so far, the ring wouldn't have been destroyed. All the help from the Fellowship would have been wasted.

I know I sound like a LOTR fanatic...maybe I am. You should really find a new character. Does anyone have any ideas? :)

[Chloe]

Okay i'll find another person..

Éomer: 12
Éowyn: 14
Faramir: 12
Beregond: 10
Prince Imrahil: 6

Beregond is Captain of the Guard.
Caitlin, i am a Tolkienite, but i couldn't think of anyone else, so sorry :/
Thx for reminding me,
I needed to change him anyway ;)

Éomer: 12
Éowyn: 14
Faramir: 12
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 7

sorry, i love them all so plz dont think i dont like one of them :)

[AmandaP]

Éomer: 13
Éowyn: 14
Faramir: 11
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 7

[Chloe]

Éomer: 13
Éowyn: 13
Faramir: 11
Beregond: 10
Prince Imrahil: 7

[Tess]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 12
Faramir: 12
Beregond: 10
Prince Imrahil: 7

[Kelly Brigid ♡]

Why don't we have Treebeard? xD He's more know than Beregond.

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 12
Faramir: 13 (He is actually my favorite character in the whole book <3)
Beregond: 10
Prince Imrahil: 6

[mels]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 12
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 7

((Sam's actually the protagonist of LOTR, so he's not exactly minor.))

[Kelly Brigid ♡]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 13
Beregond: 8
Prince Imrahil: 7

[Lily]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 13
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 8

[Susana]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 13
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 7

[Kelly Brigid ♡]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 14
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 6

[Benja]

Eomer: 12
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 14
Beregond: 10
Prince Imrahil: 6

[Kelly Brigid ♡]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 14
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 5

[Chloe]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 14
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 6

Hey ppl, i changed from Sam after everyone got upset about it okay? You ppl may not mean it this way, but the way ur saying that kind of hurts my feelings, okay? I said that i couldn't think of another, finally i got sick of the "Sam is NOT a minor hero!" I dont mean to be rude/mean but i just wanted to let you guys know how those comments made me feel. And Treebeard is a good idea, but id prefer not to change again :)

[Caitlin]

I'm sorry if you feel bad. I really didn't mean it that way. I just like discussion, especially about my favorite books.

[Chloe]

It really is okay :) I like discussion too, and I am very sorry if I made you feel bad, I was just a little tired of ppl complaining about Sam, but that was after you posted, so it's okay =) (I needed to change him anyway )

[Ruby]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 14
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 5

[Tess]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 15
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 5

[James]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 16
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 4

[Mehmet]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 15
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 5

[Alexandra]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 13
Faramir: 16
Beregond: 9
Prince Imrahil: 4

[Geoffrey]

Eomer:13
Eowyn:14
Faramir:16
Beregond:9
Prince Imrahil:3

[Jesse]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 16
Beregond: 8
Prince Imrahil: 4

[Chloe]

Eomer: 13
Eowyn: 14
Faramir: 16
Beregond: 7
Prince Imrahil: 5