The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
question
"Quotations?"

I noticed that all throughout the book, very little is put in quotations, including dialogue. What did you make of this? What do you think it adds or doesn't add to the story?
Right now, here at the end of my work day, all I can offer up is that it makes our unreliable narrator less reliable. Like he doesn't want to be held accountable for the specifics of what was said.
Right now, here at the end of my work day, all I can offer up is that it makes our unreliable narrator less reliable. Like he doesn't want to be held accountable for the specifics of what was said.
reply
flag
I don't think it's meant to add anything to the story. I think eschewing quotation marks is just the fashion among authors who are trying to be seen as "literary."
I think that's, at best, a lazy and jaded assessment. I haven't seen that refusal to use quotations in any other written work lately, including works by authors considered literary. Moreover, I don't think Junot Diaz has shown himself to be someone who writes for others' conventions. He's dedicated his work to things he cares about: Dominican people and Latino immigrants. These are people who the world at large doesn't give a shit about. I also thought that the style in Oscar Wao was a bit different from his other works, especially in the broken up narrative timeline, the varied narrators, and the quotes. If this is pandering to literary norms, it seems unnecessary to me given the success of his two short story collections.
The Incredible Hogg
A lot of authors who've had a lot of critical success don't use quotation marks in some of their works, Cormac McCarthy, Nadine Gordimer, Jose Saramag
...more
· flag
· flag
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic