Should firestar have left skyclan or brought them to the forest?

[weston]

I saw at the end of the book that firestar left skyclan but should he have
Brought them with him... I'm not sure

[Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~]

He should have listend to Bluestar its not his concern! I dont wanna be mean but he lost a life helping some lost clan!

[Katlyn]

SkyClan was not meant to be driven out, but there was no room for them. The leaders reigning at that time are sorry for what they did, but There was no place fit to bring SkyClan back to, especially after they were so well settled.

[[deleted user]]

Tana~ wrote: "He should have listend to Bluestar its not his concern! I dont wanna be mean but he lost a life helping some lost clan!"

I think that, for the sake of Skyclan cats, he should have done it. Skywatcher was very thankful AND he got a prophecy about his kin.

[eloise]

They should've left Skyclan where they were and then in the next series, when they all traveled to their new homes, fetched them so all the clans could live together!