Mockingjay
discussion
What if…? Game
date
newest »
newest »
I hate peeta she should have ended up with gale
Katniss would be devastated, like she was with Prim. She would still end up with Peeta and have a life with him and Prim and her mother.What if Katniss never held out the berries?
I still don't like peeta
I think she would have killed herself and let Peeta be the winner.What if there was another female victor in district 12?
What if there was another female victor in district 12?"That would have oepened up a whole new scenario, with Haymitch and the female going into the quarter quell, which could have very different possible outcomes for the rebels...
What if Katniss hadn't been able to get back into town in the beginning of 'Catrching Fire'?
(The scene, where she had to jump from the tree)
I think that the peacekeepers would have taken Katniss's mom and sister away to keep Katniss in line or worse kill them.What if Peeta never fell in love with Katniss?
Nikita wrote: "What if Peeta never fell in love with Katniss?"We had that question 5 questions ago...........
what if prim was older?
Anna wrote: "I hate peeta she should have ended up with gale"i liked peeta idk why everyone calls him weak sure he was but when you really think about it he went trough 2 game and was hijacked by the capitol and i know he probly wouldn't have goten trough the games if it weren't for katniss and it even say i think somewhere in the book that she chose peeta beacuse he knew what she was going trough they both saw the same things happen kids dying. also gale left her for district 3 kind of a butt whole move gale
Jzurnee wrote: "what if prim was older?"As long as Katniss was still the elder sibling, I don't think it would have changed anything...
What if Gale had been reaped in the first Games, and not Peeta?
(Can't remember if we've had this question before)
Line wrote: "Jzurnee wrote: "what if prim was older?"As long as Katniss was still the elder sibling, I don't think it would have changed anything...
What if Gale had been reaped in the first Games, and not P..."
They would´ve worked together till almost the end and he would leave her and both would hope for the best. Not before trying to plan an escape that did not result.
What if Katniss´s dad were alive?
If gale had been reaped in the first games I think Katniss would have probably won if they made it to the final two , I think the gale probably would have killed himself to try and save KatnissWhat if it was Peeta and Prim sent to the games
@Sarabi "What if Katniss' father was alive?"If her dad was still alive at the point that the story started. Katniss wouldn't have become hunting partners with Gale, because she started hunting with Gale due to the fact that they didn't have money/food coming in after her father died. Katniss would have a different relationship with her mother because they would have gone through the stage where her mother "shut down" after her father died. I don't know if Katniss would have even acknowledge who Peeta was, if the Reaping would have happened the same way (Prim and Peeta being reaped and Katniss volunteering), because she had a connection with him from the bread scene, as they would not be starving because her father would still be able to provide for his family.
@Hayley "What if Peeta and Prim were sent to the games?"
I don't either of them would have gotten very far. I don't think that Haymitch would have taken any more interest in them than the previous tributes he mentored, meaning they would have received little to no help from their mentor during the games. Katniss was the one who was able to get Haymitch to take an interest in them as tributes, by showing that she was capable of actually coming out of the games a victor, and Peeta was able to help her to get Haymitch to actually support them during the games.
What if, in the 2nd Quarter Quell, the final two tributes were Haymitch and Maysille, one of the female tribute from District 12 that Haymich had had an alliance with?
I think Haymitch would have let Maysille go home to District twelve which in turn it would result in Maysille being the mentor of Katniss and Peeta.What do you think would have happened if Katniss got caught by Thread in the woods coming home the day when she met Bonnie and Twill?
If Katniss had been caught by Thread, I feel that she would have been made an example of by him, similar to how he made an example of Gale. I don't know if it would she would have been actually been whipped in the square in District 12 like Gale, but I think that President Snow would become involved quickly, maybe even showing Katniss's punishment district-wide.What if, Katniss never learned how to hunt?
If Katniss never learned to hunt her odds of surviving the hunger games would be decreased. Like she said in catching fire every districts industry helped the tributes learn something before going into the games and district twelve they couldn't coal mine until eighteen where as in district seven they swing an ax as soon as they can life them Also I don't believe that she would have survived to be 16 esspesally after her after died
Things in the book would be very diffrent
What if Peetas name had been pulled at the 75th hunger games reaping and not haymitch's how would the games be diffrent ?
Nikita wrote: "He would have continued to help with the war and eventually live happliy with Annie and their son.What if Prim hadn't died?"
Katniss might have ended up with Gale.
Then I would have had a fit - Gale is awesome {and hot}What if Katniss's father was still alive - but her mother wasn't (thanks to an illness)?
Katniss would most likely be stronger and wouldn't have befriended Rue and would have won the games without Peter, cause she didn't owe him anything leaving her to be a every day victor nothing specialwhat is clove won the games instead of katniss?
Nothing would change. The Games wouldn't have been stopped. What if Rue allyed with Tresh?
Since Rue and Thresh were already from the same district, things wouldn't totally change. Rue wouldn't have been struck with the dagger (I think) but she would have eventually been killed.What if Katniss ended up not being able to have children? Would Peeta have left her?
then katniss would have been a lot happier. her best friend would have died but her sister would still be alive.what if snow was katniss and prims father?
They would live in the Capitol and thus not participate in the Games. They would be totally different people not being born in District 12. If they were illegitimate and lived in District 12 i don't think Snow would care, just maybe reveal it to Katniss subtly in the rose garden.What if Snow was forced to be a tribute after the revolution?
He would've died due to the sores of poison in his mouth and exposureIf president snow has a granddaughter he had to have had a son or daughter so do you think he was/is married? Do you think he blackmailed her to marry/have a kid with him?
I feel that President Snow had a daughter because he was not trying to teach somebody to take over for him. I feel that one of the first tributes was forced to have a relationship with him and then killed after the daughter was born because he wanted to raise the daughter by himself and teach her the ways of the capital and not put her in jeopardy of the Games. I feel that because the relationship between himself and the tribute worked out that is what happened for his daughter. Then he had his daughter and her lover killed so he could also raise his granddaughter and not have her be in the Games.What if Haymitch did not win the Games, who would Peeta and Katniss's mentor be?
Uh oh! Maybe they wouldn't have had a menror at all because there weren't any other district 12 Victor's. Or the Capital would give them a rubbishy one from goodness knows where. Either way, they'd be dead😱! What if Buttercup didn't exist?
Katniss would be happier because she hated Buttercup. What if Katniss had fallen in love with Gale instead of Peeta?
She might have died because she would be even more devastated that Gale's bomb might have killed Prim
What if Madge hadn't given Katniss the Mockingjay pin?
Then the people would make her a different symbol. She wouldn't be the Mockingjay, she'd be something else.What if the first Hunger Games had been in a desert?
Than Katniss wouldn't have won the Game! EEK! Her knowledge about how to survive in woods was her greatest advantage over the other Tributes! If she lost that, she lost the Game.What if Johanna wasn't Katniss's friend?
katniss might not have made it out alive because she might have killed her and she wouldn't have got beetee and they wouldn't have been able to break out of the arena and that would lower katniss's chances of winning even further and might have stopped the rebellion what if katniss hadn't blown up the careers food?
Haymitch would have pulled a Mags, He would have tried to survive as best he could until he was being a drag on the group and then given himself up to save Katniss, and Finnick. He would have made sure that they were united with Johanna first or would have jumped in front of the morphling, when the monkey was going to rip out somebody's throat. It would been very different because Finnick could not be the perfect human we all know him to be.What if the Capitol cancelled the 75th Games due to Peeta's lovely announcement? Then what if the Capitol found out they were lied to?
i don't think they would do anything public, it would be bad for themselves. i guess they would make them to have a baby or fake the pregnancy, and gave them a fake baby.and also Peeta and Katniss would get married much earlier. and probably they would get punished, by losing their loved ones( cause they really can't do anything to them!).
Cinna would still die, probably they would kill Prim too and in Peeta's part, i guess they would kill her father.
What if Johanna was the mockingjay?
Katniss wouldn't have married Peeta and she would be emotionally traumatized even more than she already was.What if Katniss wasn't in district 12?
That is a hard one, MANY things could had happened but well, first thing, katniss wouldn’t have met peeta, and Effie wouldn’t have probable picked prim’s name for the reaping so katniss wouldn’t have had to volunteer for tribute, and even if she was form another district and would have been picked for the hunger games, she probably would have died or killed peeta and the games would keep going probably never making her the mockingjay (also, her dad wouldn’t have died, or at last not in a mine accident) there are many other possibilities to what would have happened but I think those are the most important ones.What if peeta hadn’t tossed that bread to katniss when they were 11 and just looked at her and give it to the pigs?
Well then I would be way happier! I always sort of hated Gale. Everything would be perfect. But it is not. What if Peeta had never noticed Katniss before the Games?
Personally, I think she would have died. If he had NEVER noticed her, she would not have gotten that bread that saved her family, and her [specific] Hunger Games would never have happened. Which book is your favorite, and, on the other hand, which movie is your favorite? (If they are the same or different explain why)
I love the Catching Fire book.And the movie is Mockingjay part one.
I don't know why. I chose them because they were the ones I reread and re-watched more. But I love all of them equally.
My question:
What would happen if Cato had killed Peeta in the first book? (I'm not saying any specific moment, that's your choice)
I would have been happier! Why Finnick...? 😢What if Prim was brave and a warrior like Katniss rather than innocent and sweet?
The book would have been a million times better. Prim would have been able to help raise Katniss and Peeta's children (it's real). I mean just for a second imagine having an Aunt Prim. Less tension between Peeta and Katniss. They would actually live happily ever after, knowing that they would no longer had to deal with that waste of character - Gale.What if Peeta was chosen to be the Mockingjay instead of Katniss?
If Peeta was chosen to be the Mockingjay,I feel like he would have been a better public speaker - he has a way with words - but he wouldn't have the same spirit as Katniss. I noticed that whenever something major happened, (like in district 8 in Mockingjay, and Katniss witnessed it, and then she made her "burn with us" speech), she always has a fiery response (pun intended). Peeta, I feel like, he wouldn't have said anything like that, but talked about the lives lost because of the bombing. He would have been a more caring (its true), helping people grieve over deaths kind of leader. Now if Peeta and Katniss's roles were completely switched (Peeta as the Mockingjay, Katniss hijacked), that's a different story. The way I replied was that if Katniss was with the rebels, but if she wasn't, I feel like Peeta would have more urgency and spirit in his voice. What if Clove and Cato had been presented as "star crossed lovers", but the rule of two tributes becoming victor if they are from the same district was applied and kept as a rule in the 74th games?
Abigail wrote: "If Peeta was chosen to be the Mockingjay,I feel like he would have been a better public speaker - he has a way with words - but he wouldn't have the same spirit as Katniss. I noticed that whenever ..."I am going to assume that we are completely taking Katniss and Peeta out of consideration. I'm going to answer this as if they weren't there.
If Cato and Clove replaced Katniss and Peeta essentially, I don't think they would have had nearly as much support. It is likely that if they tried the nightlock thing at the end, the result would have been similar, but I don't think it would have sparked a rebellion. Part of why the districts fought was the inspiration of the lowest of the low besting the Capitol. They wouldn't have caused the same reaction.
What if the lie about Katniss being pregnant was actually true? If the baby survived Catching Fire, how do you think that would have affected Mockingjay?
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
What if Coin was actually a good person?