Private Series discussion
JOSH vs UPTON
I agree. I just want Josh to realize Ivy is no good for him.
i totally agree i think josh and reed are perfect but after all reeds done she just doesnt deserve him
I actually liked Thomas for Reed. But that was over from the start...
josh is the best for reed. hes SOOOOOOO sweet and adorable and would do anything for her!
I don't think that Reed deserves Josh anymore. And I think that it would totally be out of character for Josh, the eternal nice guy, to break up with Ivy for Reed. And that wouldn't be fair to Ivy... especially now that Ivy and Reed are getting along. Upton might not be the best guy, but he is okay... I am not sure that I could like Josh if he were to break up with Ivy for Reed...
Mod
ik! and the whole thing w/ dash is, they were drugged! so was josh and she took him back. and ik if josh could he would take her back, but hes too much of a gentleman and wont do it b/c hes npw w/ ivy. not that i like it, but thats how i feel
Mod
Mod
yah ik they were flirting. but its not like she was in love or anything. idk
I love Josh! But I hate that he dumped Reed. That was just so not right.
Mod
Mod
okay i say Josh because who would want to date a player??its just like.........no!
anyways even though Upton seems nice and all i STILL prefer JOSH!!! :D
i still sey josh becasue reed and dash did the same thing as cheyanne and josh and if he cant forgive her after she forgave him then tht is just wrong
Mod
I agree!!!
I don't even like Cheyenne. She annoys the crap out of me.
So Reed and Josh basically did the same exact thing to each other. and both times, it was SABINES FAULT!! I love Josh and REed together. it's so much better than her and Upton. HE's such a player. I personally do NOT like him at all. If he's been with every other one of her friends, then doesn't she have a feeling it won't last long? Ok, sorry back to Josh!! Well you know how he's with Ivy? I know he wouldn't dump Ivy just to go back to Reed. Either, something happens and Ivy ends up dumping Josh. OR Ivy cheats on Josh. That's the only way that they could break up.. Because unless Reed's shot or really close to dying that she's helpless. Or she could go missing... well now my imagination just let loose! so i'll stop! Bottom line, Josh can't really break up with Ivy for no good reason... as much as I hate to say.
That is such a good point and plus both times it was sabines fault and they were so good and reed forgave josh tht one time and so he should forgive her but laurens rite josh cant break up with ivy for nuthing.
Okay, I don't like the whole Ivy and Josh thing. GROSS! I mean, come on. Reed and Josh are so much better together. When I read how Ivy and Josh were going out, I was so grossed out. Ew...
Of course, Josh. Upton is...I don't know and I don't care. Josh is amazing. Upton isn't.
Ok .... I'm most likely going to get heat for this. I don't like Josh. (that's right! I said it! lol)
Don't get me wrong. I used to. BUT as the books went along he started to get on my nerves with his hypocritical tendencies.
He constantly complained about the Billings girls changing Reed and controlling what she did. Even if they did it was her will to let them do so.
I mean for one to talk about how shallow and horrible and controlling they were he was the one that broke up with her over them. Which was basically a "me or your friends/future" ultimatum. Douche move.
Ahhh now we come to the part where Josh truly was lost in my favor for good. ( I really doubt he could come back from this without a miracle).....
If Josh is such a "nice guy" why in the HELL after he and Reed broke up would he end up in her biggest enemy/rival's arms? Practically right away too. Flaunting it in public to humiliate her no less. the boy isn't stupid. He knew what it would do.
It seemed like something along the lines of ... Oh! You hate billings too?! Awesome let's get together we could be soul mates! (exaggeration but still .... come on!)
He had to have known how bad it would hurt Reed. Yet he didn't care and did it anyway. Yea Yea he assumed she cheated with Dash but I didn't see Reed hussying it around when she caught him with Cheyenne! Given there wasn't much time but Reed wouldn't have done it for awhile. there would have at least been a good mourning period.
Ohhh! Let's not forget that he got green as broccoli over reed flirting with Hunter.... while he was sitting next to his new girlfriend. Hmmmm what? He could be happy with someone else but damned if Reed could?
It's all very hypocritical and goes against the whole "nice guy" routine. I feel like he is such a poser. I wish Reed would just get over him already.
UGH! Don't even get me started on Upton, that hoe was trouble from the beginning and Reed is becoming an idiot... has been on the path for awhile now, with guys at least.
well i guess i agree with tht but i still like josh better than upton
Oh pffffft! Upton isn't even an option with me. I disliked him from the start. Watch Reed go back or pine for him. ::rolls eyes::
lol upton is so a playa which kills me
Even when he first popped up it was like .... really Reed? He's only slept with all but one of the girls you know. How does that translate into great boyfriend material? Hmpf!I think Upton really did like her a lot because she was so different from the "elite" he went through before her.... or he could have been running out of new choices. lol
Lauren wrote: "Probably the latter. :)"Lol I hope not. That'd just be self-centered and shallow.
seriously as much as i want it 2 b the first i think its the second..........
Couture.Dior.Megan wrote: "Tiffany wrote: "OMG. "what?"
That's what I was thinking too. lol
omgomgomgomg tht was sooooooo gooooooood and i kinda wish it had happened tht way though
Couture.Dior.Megan wrote: "How can you not want Reed to get back w/ Josh. She took him back after Cheyenne and him kissed even though,Cheyenne made him. Now Josh should take her back after Sabine made her kiss Noelle's boyfr..."that is such a good point. And I like Josh so much more.
I'm actually hoping Reed will get a new serious love interest. Maybe Sawyer ... though he may end up being a psycho. ::sigh:: Reed really does know how to pick em! lol
I know, all her guys have problems, she needs someone like Trey but he has his things to, I just wish she would have given Marc a chance, he was like the only one that didn't have something to hide or was crazy to the 10th power
oh gawd i no all her guys hav issues its sooooooooooooooo cra-z
josh needs to come back. someone told me their friend read that Josh was definently going to be in suspicion.probably a one chapter kinda thing.
like paradise lost. WHAT A RIP OFF! i lost my first PL b/c i had no care for it! i had to buy another one!
well, anyways, this suspicion one is supposed to be good. But whenever Kate says that, it turns out weird and not what we like. so let's hope it's not her liking but ours!
b/c she should care about her readers.
I think they are going back to Easton in this books so Josh will be in it and I believe Sawyer's dad is going to be the new headmaster so Sawyer and his brother will be in it as well. I'm hoping Sawyer will be her new love interest. (even though he could very well be the one who pushed her off of the boat). I don't know I just like him and it wouldn't be the first time Reed liked a whacko. lol
I'm over the Josh thing. Ever since he dated Ivy. It was a seriously asshole thing to do to Reed. He's not as nice as he makes out.
no! if you go on oh i forgot what site it was... but if you serach suspicion by kate brian, something will come upbut the sentence on summary is reed returns to easton from her vacation and suprising things happen or something like that.
Josh is going to be in the book after this one.
that's when she goes back to easton.
she this is going to be a small book.
unless Josh comes to st barts and tells reed he can't like w/o her!!!!
I really want to read Suspicion. Can't wait until it comes out.
Forbidden fruit...Reed, Noelle, and former Billings Girls Kiran and Taylor have been living it up on St. Barths over winter break. The tropical sun has melted away all the tensions of last semester, and for the first time in months, Reed is happy. She's got her best friends by her side, she has a palatial suite with an ocean view, and she's landed Upton, the most sought-after guy on the island.
Reed is falling in love.
But dating Upton makes Reed St. Barths' highest-profile guest — and not in a good way. Upton has a dark past, and he's broken a lot of hearts. One of his exes still wants him. And she'll do whatever it takes to get Reed out of the picture.
This is the synopsis of Suspicion. Greeeeaaaaaaat more Upton BS! Hmmmm maybe the theroy my friend and I came up with isn't so far out there.
what do you think....