All Our Yesterdays All Our Yesterdays question


551 views
Can someone explain why Finn is alive in the end????!!! (Spoiler warning)


Time fixed itself. Because present James died he never invented the time machine so future James couldn't have gone back in time and killed Finn. There is no time machine and no future James- no one to kill Finn. But present day James killed himself(no time travel involved in that death) so he stayed dead. Does that make sense?


Katherine (last edited Nov 04, 2013 11:03AM ) Nov 04, 2013 11:01AM   0 votes
Lol yeah I had to sit and think that through myself at the end. First I was like WTF and then I remembered that now there was no future James. Although you should probably put the spoiler protector on this thread.


Finn is alive because James never invented the time machine so the doctor never went back in time to kill him. Remember how they kept mentioning that time is sentient and fixes itself? And that even if you killed your own grandpa and therefore were never born, a shadow version of yourself still exists to kill your grandpa? Well, because James killed his future self, time fixed the circular paradox this created by making him commit suicide. So Nate was never killed, the time machine was never invented and Finn didn't die.

It was actually a pretty smart way to get around the time travel paradox problem.


I still don't understand the ending of the book though.

U 25x33
Domenic If Em killed James, it would cause Em to not be able to use Cassandra (Not invented) to go and kill James. So when James killed himself with no time t ...more
Jan 08, 2016 06:39PM · flag
54246497
Funmilayo Thank you so much Julia for your breakdown. I agree with Sheetal, yours was the best explanation so far. I just finished reading it and started crawli ...more
Mar 24, 2016 06:49PM · flag

I know how it ends, and I've been halfway through for months now. Do you think I should continue reading?


Doesn't this mean then that if future Em had succeeded in killing young James then Cassandra would have never been invented so she could not have gone back to kill him? That would make their entire mission pointless.


back to top