Here’s the thing: As a professional mystery writer, I can’t buy and/or read EVERY book out there, but I read a lot. And when I look for new books to read for my own enjoyment, I look to the works of my author friends, first. I also enjoy posting my reviews all over the place, if I like the work. However, if I don’t, I will not post an unfavorable review. And if I have a constructive comment to share with the author, I send it privately. While I will always give my honest opinion if asked, I won’t post negative comments, period. I know how hard it is to write anything at all, much less have the work shredded by careless comments that fail to shed light on how the author might improve. I view these common courtesies as my obligation as part of a community of professional writers. I think most of us professionals are the same.
Best,
MAS