All About Books discussion
This topic is about
The Hobbit, or There and Back Again
Readalongs
>
The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien (Alannah & Jenny)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jenny
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Sep 01, 2013 07:42AM
Starting date sometime around the 3rd of September.
reply
|
flag
Alannah, I've just finished "As I Lay Dying" so I will start on The Hobbit tomorrow. I am as excited as a kid, which really makes me chuckle at myself ;)
I hope you don't mind but I'm definitely going to be following your readalong and may chip in with some comments as this is one of my favourite books. I'm jealous you get to read it for the 1st time and can't wait to hear your thoughts
Me too! Will do some more reading with a cup of tea now. Thanks to LOTR (the film) I have a real vivid image of all the characters, I wish I could unknow the movie though just for a second, to figure out how I would picture this world and it's (so far very charming) inhabitants.
Jenny wrote: "Me too! Will do some more reading with a cup of tea now. Thanks to LOTR (the film) I have a real vivid image of all the characters, I wish I could unknow the movie though just for a second, to figu..."
I have only seen The Hobbit movie but spent most of it staring at Bilbo's feet.
I have only seen The Hobbit movie but spent most of it staring at Bilbo's feet.
(by the way: ALL the characters was slightly exagerated, but you get an idea of what a Hobbit and others look like, plus Gandalf (honestly Iam even hearing his voice)
With each chapter I read I get drawn in more. Just read chapter 5 which I loved. I got a bit worried about my intelligence there though. (...hold on, is this a spoiler? I guess not since you've seen the movie....) When Gollum and Bilbo exchange riddles I really struggled with 95% of them eventhough the book keeps telling us how smart we are and that we probably knew the solution immediately ;)
I'm about 60% in now, I'm still enjoying it. I get what you mean about the riddles, I have never really understood riddles myself. I only got got the first one about the mountains.
I knew a few of the riddles, but I always assumed that they were classic schoolboy riddles of Tolkien's day.
Glad you enjoyed it, Alannah. I think it's a lovely book. I read it in childhood but thought the same as you about Lord of the Rings. I encourage you to read that soon as well!
Same here Alannah, for some reason I had always thought Tolkien's books weren't really for me. No idea where that thought came from ;) Loved the little detail in (some of) the characters. Bilbo's obsession with food for example.
Heather wrote: "Glad you enjoyed it, Alannah. I think it's a lovely book. I read it in childhood but thought the same as you about Lord of the Rings. I encourage you to read that soon as well!"
Yeah, I will definitely try those soon, my friend suggested I wait though until my next holidays until I have no work on because she felt they were the type of books you can't really leave and pick up again.
Yeah, I will definitely try those soon, my friend suggested I wait though until my next holidays until I have no work on because she felt they were the type of books you can't really leave and pick up again.
Jenny wrote: "Same here Alannah, for some reason I had always thought Tolkien's books weren't really for me. No idea where that thought came from ;) Loved the little detail in (some of) the characters. Bilbo's o..."
I had always thought that as well but lately I have been trying to read many different books. I loved the attention to detail in the characters, even though they are hobbits and elves, I loved that those thing like Bilbo's obsession with food made them seem more human.
I had always thought that as well but lately I have been trying to read many different books. I loved the attention to detail in the characters, even though they are hobbits and elves, I loved that those thing like Bilbo's obsession with food made them seem more human.


