Fragile Eternity
discussion
Keenan Or Seth?
i like them both. but Seth is so right for her
Some people will seriously get pissed at this comment but I think Seth deserves someone better then Aislinn. He hurts so much because of her and Keenan's relationship. He's so patient and loving. He's too good for her. She needs to choose him and firmly tell Keenan that she doesnt want to be with him or stop leading him on. If Keenan and Aislinn were to be together, it would hurt Donia too.
Sid wrote: "Some people will seriously get pissed at this comment but I think Seth deserves someone better then Aislinn. He hurts so much because of her and Keenan's relationship. He's so patient and loving. H..."that makes sense actually. i am mad at her for loving Seth but going for Keenan. i totally agree with u
Seth all the way<333
I keep cheering for Keenan, but I'm not sure why. I think it's their physical need for one another (not talking just sexual, but the draw) Seth would be the most honest choice and that's who she "should" choose. Maybe that's the whole point of fantasy, getting to do what you want, not what you should. I haven't read the last book, so no spoilers, please!!!
Keenan !! Seth is way to good for her! But if it was me I'd just have both ;)
I could agree with that, very tempting :DBut it really pisses me off that she can't seem to make a final decision. Her feeling keep wavering..like really make a final decision already. And also the fact that she has two amazing characters after makes me more furious. Most importantly isn't Seth the one that's always there for her, really if you aren't even gonna let the guy know he's the only one for you quit leading him on!I really don't like her, but the guys are awesome :D
Seth! Seth loved, loves and will always love Aislinn only. Keenan is a jerk who wants both Aislinn and Donia.
I confess I prefer Keenan. Strangely, I found Seth a boring character. At least Keenan has depth compared to Seth. He makes mistakes while Seth is kind of a Gary Stu with piercings. Ash should end up with neither of them. She should rule alone as a Queen and should not need a man to lean to. : )
Anyway, that's my opinion. Feel free to disagree.
It is not strange. Keenan is so gorgeous. But Keenan is a jerk when it comes to love. And Aislinn needs a loyal lover. Not only to cheer her days but to produce children. When Ash is gone, her kid will be the next Summer ruler.
Seth all the way...
i like seth but i i love and choose Keenan. theres something about people who are ment to be together. and if she doesnt want him i'll take Keenan LOL
MariaaLovesCaylene wrote: "hm but seth's name reminds me of sloth, so i think of him as slow and boring, and anyway he has alot of pericings, how could girls like tht?"MariaaLovesCaylene wrote: "hm but seth's name reminds me of sloth, so i think of him as slow and boring, and anyway he has alot of pericings, how could girls like tht?"
It's interesting because I think I like Seth BECAUSE of the peircings. More accurately, I like that Melissa Marr wrote a 'hot guy' as a guy who is actually good looking in his own way, and not just pages and pages of how he looks perfect all the time and everybody stares at him when he walks down the street, and any girl would be lucky to have him, just so we all understand that he's supposed to be really really hot. I like that Seth is man enough to have a belly button ring, too.
Seth! I like Keenan but he irritates me a little! :)
haha I don't think any man is man enough to wear a belly button ring. LOL I like the facial piercings, but not the belly button ring, too feminine.
Seth was gorgeous but Keenan was surely super gorgeous. But as Seth was loyal and truthful friend and lover, Keenan was an ass in love. He loved Donia but wanted Ash more.
Seth right up until keenan switched courts. now keenan!
i love keenan i dont really hate seth i just love keenan more cause he is the summer prince. Summer prince wins hands over a mortal who became a fairy to be with his true love. Maybe donia should find love with someone new other keenan. have read the last book yet but will. mathces i think might be better is ash and keenan, then seth and donia.
Pshhhh, she can have Seth. Keenan is mine :)
Keenan. I'm sorry, I just find Seth so annoying.
I hate Keenan. Ash should be with Seth.Point Finale
Seth! All the fricking way.
Seth, of course.
MariaaLovesCaylene wrote: "KEENAN! >:l I AGREE!!!!
:)"
Nurlely wrote: "Seth is kind and trying his best for Ash. And Seth loves only Ash, while Keenan wants both Ash and Donia...:)"Ash loves Keenan and Seth TOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
ummm most likely Seth for Aislinn because I like Keenan and Donia :)
I personally wanted it to be Keenan, but Seth loved her unconditionally!!
I like Keenan but it is just sad that Keenan loves Donia more...Ash should be with Seth
Personally I haven't read the book yet, I just finished the second one, but I think Seth is soooooooooooooo much better then Keenan. However, Ash can't fully be herself around Seth because he's mortal. It would be better if Seth was a faerie, though then again that would start fights and the like. So I'm indecisive - I like Seth better but I'm not sure if they're the best match - I mean, Seth's given everything he has to Ash but she can't do the same in return. ***Lissa***
Lissa wrote: "Personally I haven't read the book yet, I just finished the second one, but I think Seth is soooooooooooooo much better then Keenan. However, Ash can't fully be herself around Seth because he's mor..."Keep reading. The last two books in the series are my absolute favorite, and you'll love Seth even more.
I think that it doesn't matter who she might choose. Ms Marr is probably going to decide for her and perhaps has already set up in a sequence that may well have Seth inheriting the throne in Fairy. The Summer Queen is also pretty much bound to Keenan for eternity. My fear is that the story is becoming a Fairy soap opera! :)
I thought Keenan was more interesting character. I like Seth but I found him boring in comparison. Actually I think Donia and Seth made a better couple.I felt sorry for Keenan because in the first book every time he tried to do something nice for Ash, she never trusted him just because he was a fairy. Yes he was pushy at times, but keep in mind he just spent forever trying to find her. And now that she was finally found, he didn't want to lose her. Despite it all I think they could have worked out,like Ash said, if she only met him first.
Good points Gini. I too like Keenan for Ash and he has certainly been patient with her needs. I think he deserves a win. :)
Ally wrote: "Lissa wrote: "Personally I haven't read the book yet, I just finished the second one, but I think Seth is soooooooooooooo much better then Keenan. However, Ash can't fully be herself around Seth be..."Thanks, <\i>
* Lissa
Nadine wrote: "I confess I prefer Keenan. Strangely, I found Seth a boring character. At least Keenan has depth compared to Seth. He makes mistakes while Seth is kind of a Gary Stu with piercings. Ash should end..."
That's the best idea yet, no offense or anything, but girls SO don't need guys to live. Heack, my role model was single right up until the day she died.
*Lissa
I like Keenan than Seth and think Keenan and Ash have a real connection.
Keenan doesn't really want her for love. Seth wants it all. I'm Team Seth!
definitely Seth! I love him, and he loves Ash so much. but if you ask me whether I'd rather see Niall or Ash with Seth, I'll ALWAYS say Niall.
Jahlia ((thing 10 Evil 1)) wrote: "KEENAN ISN'T BAD DAMNIT! DON'T YOU REMEMBER WHEN NIALL WHOPPED HIS ASS?*clears throat* sorry, lost it for a second. But keenana, isn't bad. No, IRIAL is bad, niall is bad, keenan is simply a prett..."
How can you say that!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Irial is AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!! Keenan is an idiot.
I loved Seth from the start and still do he's so sweet, in this book though I felt myself saying omg ash n Keenan just get it over with already! Lol
i want keenan to stay wit ash...it wouldnt be good for their own court if keenan stays wit donia...and seth is juzt so idk like hes cute and everything but he should juz try to look for someone else so they wont be all triangle love by keenan seth and aislinn
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
I know right! lol It's been so long since I read it but when I think back, there's so many things that i didn't like although I thought the overall series was okay. Donia was bitter, Keenan was tortured, sad and confused for most of his life, and Aislinn was stubborn. So many screwed up people can screw up relationships! lol I wish I would have been on goodreads.com when I read the series so I could have done a full review of each book. =/