Fragile Eternity
discussion
Keenan Or Seth?
message 1:
by
Jessica
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
May 18, 2009 12:33PM
Do you think Aislinn should be with Keenan or Seth?
reply
|
flag
Ash should be with Seth. Keenan loves Donia more.
I'm still reading the book. So, I've been hoping for her to finally realize she could stand on her own. But it would be nice if she could stay with Seth.
I like Seth a lot, less of Keenan. But I do not really care who they will end up with. I love Irial and Niall most...:)
Seth. I loved the way it was solved though. My favourite character is Niall and the queens brother, the one that starts with D
I love Devlin too, but the polygamy stuff irritated me so much.
hm but seth's name reminds me of sloth, so i think of him as slow and boring, and anyway he has alot of pericings, how could girls like tht?
It is interesting how you interpreted 'Seth' and it is totally out of topic.FYI: It is Hebrew. To the biblical, Seth is the third child of Adam and Eve.
I love that seth has piercings :-) i never thought of seth as slothful!! i think that is way obsurd
he was soo patient.. waiting for ash to realise jsut how much he loved her.. and then he accepted everything.. keenan only wanted her because it would further his kingdom
CayleneLovesRia wrote: "who cares, if its out of topic. sloths are disgusting so is seth with all his piercings."It's okay if you prefer Keenan to Seth or vice versa, but backing up your argument with valid evidence is what we readers are supposed to do.
Hating Seth and trying to find his 'weakness' in any way outside the book itself is kind of silly. It is like a kid who hates a toy without any reason.
I LOVE SETH!!! He truely loves Ash unlike Keenan who see's her as a way out.
Seth :). Waaay hotter and not so much of a pretty boy...
And Aislinn loves Seth not Keenan. Keenan is her obligation while Seth is her forever love.
Both...hey it's 2011 why not!
Seth. Period. The End.
I found Seth to be a bit of a boring character. :( I actually liked the fact that he had piercings, it made him a little more edgy, which I think he needed.But the thing that I liked about Keenan, was the obvious attraction and pull that was felt between him and Aislinn. I didn't feel the pull to Seth so I didn't hope for them to be together as much. I really just wanted her to give in to Keenan.
I also didn't get the Donia thing. She didn't seem very special. I really would wanted the Summer King and Queen to be together.
It will be awful if Ash gives herself to Keenan since Keenan can not let go of Donia. I also think there is nothing special about Donia, but Melissa Marr certainly thinks she is special...:)
I like Keenan better than Seth but I dont know who she should be with
She will be with the person she always love. It will be Seth because she never actually loves Keenan more than her obligation.
See with me Seth annoys me I like Keenan better. But then again I always like the assholes or bad boys
I know Im just saying I like characters LIKE that. Keenen IS a pretty boy but he has an asshole attitude sometimes and I like that. Does that make sense?
Being pretty does not make Keenan a good lover. He is suck at love. He needs 4 books before making his decision in book 5. He loves Donia but does not want to let her queen go, feels jealous with Ash and Seth's relationship. Such an awful lover!
Keenan, definitely! But that's only me and my hopes ;p Big chance Aislinnn will end up with Seth. The scenario of the Summer King and Queen being together forever's too boring IMO. But then again, maybe they won't :)
What makes you think the answer is Keenan? Keenan does not even love Aislinn. He wants Ash for Ash is supposed to be his mate, his Summer queen. But he always love Donia. To have Keenan matched to Ash while he loves someone else is absurd.
Donia is a stupid girl. She can not ignore Keenan although he sets his eyes also for Aislinn and he put Ash before Donia. But Donia loves him always. But I think that what love is. Stupid as it is, Donia keep her strong grip on Keenan's love always.
Have u read the last 1 yet?
Not properly. I scan-read it and not very happy about the story so I put it back on my to-read list instead of reading it in a proper way.
@ Nurlely just coz u like seth, doesnt mean eeveryone else has to. Everyone has their own opinions, just saying (:
damn straight fruit cake.!
Nurlely wrote: "What makes you think the answer is Keenan? Keenan does not even love Aislinn. He wants Ash for Ash is supposed to be his mate, his Summer queen. But he always love Donia. To have Keenan matched t..."
who cares. its just a book lol :P
books aren't meant to be arguing about its about reading and enjoying the book, so practically i dont know why this discussion was even made, because books are for reading and and exploring your imagination, and makes a memory in your head about any or a special book you have read.
CayleneLovesRia wrote: "books aren't meant to be arguing about its about reading and enjoying the book, so practically i dont know why this discussion was even made, because books are for reading and and exploring your im..."omg yes thts soo truee!! :)
CayleneLovesRia wrote: "books aren't meant to be arguing about its about reading and enjoying the book, so practically i dont know why this discussion was even made, because books are for reading and and exploring your im..."shankyou for agreeing with me :)
Of course she should have chose Keenan as far as I'm concerned. He would have done anything for her. I read all the books but I will always stick to (view spoiler)
I Love Seth and thinks he is meant for Aislinn :)
Kimi ★★★ wrote: "Of course she should have chose Keenan as far as I'm concerned. He would have done anything for her. I read all the books but I will always stick to [spoilers removed]"yerr i no!!! i reckon this book wasn't tht good after all, it was O.K.
MariaaLovesCaylene wrote: "who cares. its just a book lol :P "Actually this is a discussion forum. If you comment about something, it is appropriate for you to write your reason. Or you are probably beneath understanding.
MariaaLovesCaylene wrote: "Kimi ★★★ wrote: "Of course she should have chose Keenan as far as I'm concerned. He would have done anything for her. I read all the books but I will always stick to [spoilers removed]"yerr i no!..."
Yes I thought the series was okay. I'm not saying that Keenan was right but he was trying to not screw things up for people and be a great king to make things right. So I understand the way he was. He was sacrificing himself and what he might want for others. There were so many points of views which made it a little confusing at times.
I can't really remember too much from this series because I read it around the beginning of this year. I've read too many books since then... lol
It's cool that you read them though. That's the main thing. Reading is rewarding. That's all that matters. The series was alright. I liked some of the characters and the storyline. I liked the darkness of it as well. I thought that book 2 was way too depressing though. I love dark faeries. =)
(view spoiler)
Seth is kind and trying his best for Ash. And Seth loves only Ash, while Keenan wants both Ash and Donia...:)
She should've gone with Keenan I was quite disappointed with the last book and the ending (just my opinion!) Wasn't how I would do it but then I have never written anything worth Jack so what do I know :-)
Exactly! So it's Seth all the way for me too. We are the Seth Team!!! :D
I know I already commented on this thread, but I've been thinking about it for a while and I want to say more. It's not that I don't like Seth, but she created so much of an attraction between Keenan and Aislinn, that I was SO disappointed when they didn't give into each other at least once! grrr I realize that the story was written for Aislinn and Seth to end up together, but they didn't have that same chemistry and firey attraction that I loved between Aislinn and Keenan.Nurlely wrote: "It will be awful if Ash gives herself to Keenan since Keenan can not let go of Donia. I also think there is nothing special about Donia, but Melissa Marr certainly thinks she is special...:)"
I guess I didn't really feel the attraction between Keenan and Donia either. It seemed like Donia was stuck on Keenan, but Keenan could have easily let go of her if Aislinn would have given him a chance. It almost seemed like she decided to keep Keenan and Donia together in the later books. I didn't think she was setting it up for the two of them to have a lasting relationship in the first book. I don't know, maybe it was just me. I read the first books a while ago, but when Keenan started worrying about Donia, I was like "where did that come from?" I thought he was over her in the first book.
Ok I feel like I'm rambling now. I'll stop. :)
Kristy wrote: "I know I already commented on this thread, but I've been thinking about it for a while and I want to say more. It's not that I don't like Seth, but she created so much of an attraction between Kee..."You're not rambling. I feel the exact same way. I feel like there weren't any signs that it wasn't going to happen with the people who were in love. Keenan and Ash could have really been happy together. The attraction was there and so was the friendship. They were drawn to each other. And then at the end it was like Marr changed her mind at the last minute. It threw off the whole story.
I didn't see it with Keenan and Donia either. She gave up a long time ago. She shoulda been sleeping with that guard. So disappointing. =/
Oh yeah I completely forgot about the guard. I was totally into that relationship. I kept waiting for more to happen between the two of them. Ugh, the more I think about this series to more frustrated I become.
Kristy wrote: "....I read the first books a while ago, but when Keenan started worrying about Donia, I was like "where did that come from?" I thought he was over her in the first book. "Keenan did not seem to have that big love for Donia when he understood that Ash was his destiny. I was also confused about his concern towards Donia. Did it happen because Ash did not care lot about him? MM wrote it like it was always there.
Seth did not capture my heart at the beginning. For me he was a mere human among the gorgeous male fey. I started to like him when MM made Keenan a moody one, one torn between 2 girls, despite the chemistry between him and Ash. I lost my interest on Keenan then. Wanting Ash and Donia both really made him a jerk.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
