Cinder (The Lunar Chronicles, #1) Cinder discussion


453 views
Cinder: Fancasting The Characters

Comments Showing 1-50 of 50 (50 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rainbow Moonstone (last edited Feb 17, 2016 08:27PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rainbow Moonstone Who would you like to portray the characters in Cinder? Did you imagine the characters to look like certain people? If so, please share :) If not, how did the characters look to you in your imagination?
These would be my choices...

Hailee Steinfeld as Cinder
(view spoiler)

Or Seulgi from Red Velvet as Cinder

(view spoiler)


Kai from EXO as Prince Kai

(view spoiler)

And for the other characters:

(view spoiler)

I'd love to see your choices :)


Loretta Lawrence Levana -
Diana Agron

Cinder -
Ellen Page

Kai -
Kim Hyung Joon

Pearl -
Minzy

Adri -
Kim Hee-Ae

Peony -
Goo Hara

Erland -
Micheal Caine


Rainbow Moonstone Loretta wrote: "Levana -
Diana Agron

Cinder -
Ellen Page

Kai -
Kim Hyung Joon

Pearl -
Minzy

Adri -
Kim Hee-Ae

Peony -
Goo Hara

Erland -
Micheal Caine"


:) Yaaay thanks for answering!! You picked some really interesting choices I especially like the idea of Kim Hyun Joong as Prince Kai, Michael Caine would be really good and I love Ellen Page, too so she would be a great choice for Cinder :)


Loretta Lawrence Yeah. But I'm not so suree if she's Asian or White. LOL. I know. After reading two books you'd think I'd have that part down, but I'm kinda sure it was mentioned somewhere she was white.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Bree wrote: "Who would you like to portray the characters in Cinder? Did you imagine the characters to look like certain people? If so, please share :) If not, how did the characters look to you in your imagina..."

kai looks a little young


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Loretta wrote: "Levana -
Diana Agron

Cinder -
Ellen Page

Kai -
Kim Hyung Joon

Pearl -
Minzy

Adri -
Kim Hee-Ae

Peony -
Goo Hara

Erland -
Micheal Caine"


holy crap its sara hart


superbookishbabe I think Cinder is of mixed heritage, so it looks half-Asian, half-white, a little bit of everything. All I know is that she has brown hair and brown eyes. BTW, all the fan casting is PERFECT! :D


Sara ^Agree with top comment, I just imagined Cinder to be a little bit, okay, a lot, more plainer, and, um, not that attractive. But, definitely half asian half white.


Rainbow Moonstone Cassie wrote: "I think Cinder is of mixed heritage, so it looks half-Asian, half-white, a little bit of everything. All I know is that she has brown hair and brown eyes. BTW, all the fan casting is PERFECT! :D"

Ohhh I like the term 'fancasting' I'm going to change the title of this thread to that :) and thank you for answering the thread! hehehe :D


message 10: by Rainbow Moonstone (last edited Nov 25, 2013 09:20PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rainbow Moonstone Sara wrote: "^Agree with top comment, I just imagined Cinder to be a little bit, okay, a lot, more plainer, and, um, not that attractive. But, definitely half asian half white."

Yeah thats an interesting thought you guys brought up about CInder being half-white, half-asian. I had trouble imaging her some of the time. At first I saw her as asian, but then half way through the book I was like...wait a minute...is she supposed to be white? lol And then from then image kept shapeshifting in my imagination. But oh well. And that's a good point about her being plainer since she's a mechanic, of course ^^ I'd try to find another plainer Cinder but not many mixed asian celebs come time mind at the moment.

Sam wrote: kai looks a little young "

I found another possible Prince Kai who is actually Chinese this time. I'd pick Kris Wu because he's about the right age for Prince Kai.. and he's the leader of Exo-M so he already has that leader, princely vibe going on to me.

Kris Wu - as Prince Kai?

(view spoiler)


message 11: by Anisha (new)

Anisha Ahmed Personally, I can see Kai himself being a good Prince Kai. I mean, even the description matches and he seems like the good prince type.


Lilac I don't understand. Cinder wouldn't have been white....


SarahO Well, Cinder is Lunar and she spent the first few years on earth in Europe before going to live in New Beijing so I'm not sure what nationality she would look like but the book does say brown hair.
I think Chloe Bennet from Agents of Shield would make a great Cinder!


Sabrien Abdelrahman Maybe


Christina O. Chloe Bennet would make a great Cinder!


message 16: by Jenni J (last edited Feb 28, 2014 09:25AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenni J description
Kim Jaejoong as prince Kai! *Swoons to hell* but maybe he is too old for the role now :(
description
And Emily Fields as Cinder!
Will update when I find more actors/actresses that fits the rest of the cast


message 17: by Lilac (last edited May 21, 2014 06:20AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lilac Lily Cole as Levana, Goo Hara as Pearl, and Gong Li as Adri are spot on.

I don't know who should play Cinder. Marissa Meyer (the author) says she's supposed to look mixed-race, with tan skin and dark hair. I imagined her looking something like this drawing:

description

And I don't think she would be pretty in a Shay Mitchell (Emily Fields) way. I think she'd be...tougher looking.


message 18: by Lilac (last edited May 21, 2014 07:17AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lilac Does anyone else like Sophie Turner as Scarlet?

description

description


message 19: by Rainbow Moonstone (last edited May 24, 2014 05:39PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rainbow Moonstone ✿Lilac✿ wrote: "Does anyone else like Sophie Turner as Scarlet?



"

I love Sophie Turner as Scarlet!!!! I want to see her in more things *_*

Oh and also I was thinking that the reason why Cinder has an ambiguous race might be because (most likely) very losely based on Sailor Moon (Marissa Meyer cited herself as being a former Sailor Moon fanfic writer) that's what I read somewhere. Even though Sailor Moon is Japanese, speaks perfect Japanese she is also blonde haired and blue eyed and nobody questions it...cos its anime *shrugs* LOL. People have pink and freen and blue hair in anime.


Sinta Cassie wrote: "I think Cinder is of mixed heritage, so it looks half-Asian, half-white, a little bit of everything. All I know is that she has brown hair and brown eyes. BTW, all the fan casting is PERFECT! :D"

How about Shay Mitchell. Marissa said she's not bad for Cinder!


message 21: by Kelly Brigid ♡ (last edited Sep 16, 2014 11:06AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelly Brigid ♡ Well, Marissa Meyer said she would cast:

Cinder: Shay Mitchell
description

Scarlet: Emma Stone
description

Queen Levana: Angelina Jolie
description

I'm not all too sure about Shay Mitchell as Cinder, but she's close enough. Emma Stone and Angelina Jolie are PERFECT though! :D


message 22: by If (new)

If List Hi Kelly! Propose these actors for Cinder on The IF List:

http://iflist.com/cinder(thelunarchro...


message 23: by kirstin ✿ (last edited Sep 16, 2014 06:41PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

kirstin ✿ Wow, I've found my fellow Exo-Ls here. LOL.
And yep, Cinder is most definitely not attractive at all and I'd like to keep it that way. There's been too many attractive heroines these days.


Kelly Brigid ♡ Kirstin wrote: "Wow, I've found my fellow Exo-Ls here. LOL.
And yep, Cinder is most definitely not attractive at all and I'd like to keep it that way. There's been too many attractive heroines these days."


But then the male audience wouldn't bother watching the movie! lol. And Cinder is supposed to be pretty in the book.


kirstin ✿ Kelly ~ Well, yeah, I guess. LOL. But just for a change, you know? I just read the book a week ago and Cinder is definitely not pretty. Not saying she's ugly either. But she's not pretty ^^


Rainbow Moonstone Kirstin wrote: "Kelly ~ Well, yeah, I guess. LOL. But just for a change, you know? I just read the book a week ago and Cinder is definitely not pretty. Not saying she's ugly either. But she's not pretty ^^"

It would be nice if Cinder was played by a relatable looking girl instead of model, I agree :) But as the story progressed I started to imagined her to look like Sailor Moon XD

And Yep!! :) EXO fighting! hehe When I realized the main guy's name was Prince Kai I couldn't imagine him to be anyone else hahahaha XD

Thanks you guys! for taking the time to comment on the post ^__^


kirstin ✿ Rainbow ~ Yes! I imagine Cinder as someone plain-looking tbh, but can be pretty when she puts effort into her appearance.

Kai < 333 I mean, the Exo Kai. LOL. I always picture him as Kai too because of the name.


Kelly Brigid ♡ Well, I don't mean like drop-dead gorgeous, but I pictured just pretty, you know? And that's how the book represented her anyways, pretty little mechanic lol


message 29: by Rainbow Moonstone (last edited Jun 19, 2015 10:24AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rainbow Moonstone ✞♣♫~Қεllყ~♫♣✞ wrote: "Well, I don't mean like drop-dead gorgeous, but I pictured just pretty, you know? And that's how the book represented her anyways, pretty little mechanic lol"

That's a good point on that though :)

Ohhh how about that girl from the Clean Bandits music video as Cinder! She is Japanese and I think she is an English speaker.






Nikita Character - Actor/Actress - Best known for if you don't know name.

Cinder - Marie Avgeropoulos - Octavia Blake(The 100)

Kai - Ki Hong Lee - Minho(Maze Runner)

Scarlet - Sophie Turner - Sansa Stark(Game of Thrones)

Wolf - Kit Harington - Jon Snow(Game of Thrones)

Cress - Chloe Gace Moretz - Hitgirl(Kick Ass)

Thorn - Sam Claflin - Finnick(Catching Fire)

Dr. Erland - Michael Caine - Alfred(Dark Knight films)

Levana - Anne Hathaway - Princess Mia(Princess Diaries)

Winter - Amandla Stenberg - Rue(Hunger Games)


message 31: by SD (new) - rated it 4 stars

SD Rainbow Moonstone wrote: "Who would you like to portray the characters in Cinder? Did you imagine the characters to look like certain people? If so, please share :) If not, how did the characters look to you in your imagina..."

Lol nice picture for Dr. Erland


ihearthawaii Cinder:
Chloe Bennet or Phoebe Tonkin

Scarlet:
Holland Roden

Cress:
Annasophia Robb or Dove Cameron

Winter:
Amandla Stenberg

Kai:
Ki Hong Lee

Wolf (I had trouble with him, so be nice ):
Theo James

Thorne:
Brant Daugherty

Jacin:
Jake Abel

Levana:
Angelina Jolie

Peony:
Ellen Wong

Pearl:
Arden Cho

Adri:
Lucy Liu

Ran:
Lucas Till

Konn Torin:
Daniel Dae Kim

(I know I do not have pictures. I do not know how to put them on. If you want to know what they look like. I made a slideshow. Go to https://docs.google.com/presentation/...

to see it.)


ihearthawaii Chloe Bennet is half Asian


ihearthawaii So, she could still work. Half the characters in movies aren't correct. In the first Percy Jackson, they were supposed to be twelve, but the actors were 18.


ihearthawaii No, but Chloe Bennet is half Asian. In Marissa's description, Cinder is mixed ethnicity.


ihearthawaii So not everything is perfect. I think she could fit the role and that is my opinion. If you don't agree, that is okay, but I don't want to hear about it. I am entitled to my opinion, and my opinion is the Phoebe could fit the role. Deal with it.


ihearthawaii By the way, I'm not racist. I am a quarter Korean, and Naive American. Definition or whitewash:

a solution of lime and water or of whiting, size, and water, used for painting walls white.


ihearthawaii Right of Speech, dummy.


ihearthawaii And so can I.


ihearthawaii I know what it means.

Okay you little piece of trash. This is my opinion, and there is no way you can change it over the internet. You are entitled to your opinion, no matter what it is. I have stopped people from saying racist jokes, so you can't call me racist. And everybody's opinion is equal. So if you want to critic me on what I think, go right ahead. But know that everybody else will want you to die in a hole.


JaLynn Smith I honestly think Cinder should look something like this:

I don't really think she's Asian. I mean she was born on Luna, taken to France, then taken to New Bejing. Since no one knows who her father was you can theorize that she was Asian, but I don't think so.

Prince Kai - Kai from EXO or Kim Myungsoo




JaLynn Smith Sabreen wrote: "Does anyone else like Sophie Turner as Scarlet?

"
I Can definitely see Sophie Tuner as Scarlet.


JaLynn Smith ✞Ƙєℓℓу✧Sтєℓℓαя Scяυтιηу✞ wrote: "Well, Marissa Meyer said she would cast:

Cinder: Shay Mitchell


Scarlet: Emma Stone


Queen Levana: Angelina Jolie


I'm not all too sure about Shay Mitchell as Cinder, but she's close enough. Em..."


I think Sophie Turner would make a better Scarlet, but you are spot on with Angelina Jolie as Queen Levana.


Phoenix2 Kai from Exo, haven't thought of him, but yeah!! I also like Chanjo from teen top as Prince Kai


JaLynn Smith shad ─ wrote: ""i dont think shes asian" yeah ok but she passed for 6 years as a new beijing native so............."

She was never mentioned as a native. And she was adopted; people adopt people from other countries all the time. And even if she wasn't Asian she lived there for 6 years so who would really see her as being "out of place" when she's been there for so long? It's just my veiw anyways.


Nikita I would like to revise my dream cast a bit. The list is mostly of the main cast and a few with two choices.

Cinder - Lindsey Morgan
Kai - Ki Hong Lee
Scarlet - Sophie Turner
Wolf - Kit Harington or Bob Morley
Cress - Sabrina Carpenter
Throne - Sam Claflin or Brant Daugherty
Winter - Amandla Stenberg
Jacin - Peyton Meyer
Levana - Madeleine Stowe or Lana Parilla
Dr. Erland - Mark Hamill
Voice of Iko - Lupita Nyong'o
Sybil Mira - Ruth Negga
Konn Torin - Daniel Dae Kim or John Cho


message 48: by Ri (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ri I found some actresses that may work for Cinder...
Celina Jade **
Kara Crane **
Paula Taylor
Chloe Bennett

**The ones I really liked
I basically searched "Multiracial Asian actresses" and clicked the IMDB link.


message 49: by Ri (last edited Feb 17, 2016 05:47PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ri ihearthawaii wrote: "Cinder:
Chloe Bennet or Phoebe Tonkin

Scarlet:
Holland Roden

Cress:
Annasophia Robb or Dove Cameron

Winter:
Amandla Stenberg

Kai:
Ki Hong Lee

Wolf (I had trouble with him, so be nice ):
Theo ..."


What about Tyler Posey or Taylor Lautner for Wolf? Seems like they would have experience...Or Hemlock Grove or Joe Manganiello...though he may be a bit too old.


JaLynn Smith shad ─ wrote: "JaLynn wrote: "shad ─ wrote: ""i dont think shes asian" yeah ok but she passed for 6 years as a new beijing native so............."

She was never mentioned as a native. And she was adopted; people..."


Oh no. It's not that I prefer one race over another or anything like that it's just that whenever I read the book that's just how I imagined it. It never stated anything to lead me to believe that she was Asian. I mean she has no ties to Asia whatsoever other than the fact that that's where here adopted parents live (unless you have a theory that her unknown father was Asian). Everybody has their own images if the characters, thats just mine.


back to top