Steampunk Lit discussion
What's everyone reading that's good (or not)?
date
newest »







It's like a steampunk Sherlock Holmes story, but with an adventurer and an eccentric poet as Holmes and Watson.




I read this a year or two after it first came out; I'm currently rereading it for a local steampunk reading group. I'm interested in seeing how people who are coming to it for the first time specifically as steampunk are going to see it; I definitely saw those elements but I didn't read it specifically *as* steampunk the first time. If that makes any sense. (In other words, will they have expectations that I didn't and will they be met or not?)


I've been reading steampunk for most of my life, and am enjoying the Renaissance of the subgenre now that it has been defined as such.
I'm a bit of a purest though. Cherie Priest's books are some of the best new steampunk out there. I even got to meet her when she came through Denver last fall.
Steampunk started off w/ Verne and Wells and is straight up sci-fi. Most new steampunk is fantasy and I don't like it. After saying that, the exception is China Mieville's "Perdido Street Station", "The Scar", and "The Iron Council." Not many people call them steampunk but they are (The Scar less so than the other two). But they are also fantasy. They are the exception to the rule for me.
Stephen Hunt's stuff is very well written and great stories, but they are straight up high fantasy. Sticking in steam powered metal men as a race does not make it steampunk, in my opinion. He has faeries, spells etc. in his novels and that is fantasy. His steam men even have a religion and the story involves fighting old gods Cthulu-style. Which is more fantasy/horror and not sci-fi.
I'm babbling. Sorry. haha
Glad you like Cherie's work. It is great steampunk and now you will be hard pressed to find modern authors to match her.


Hi Charlie,
Perdido Street Station is one of my all time most favorite books ever. Hands down. I too consider it steampunk, even though it is a fantasy. Mieville is an astonishing author. I've read all of his stuff (except one published only in Spanish). His early works has a lot of his political philosophies of socialism in them, but I like them anyway. haha
"The Scar" and "Iron Council" are also amazing stories.

On the other hand, I love the Cherie Priest books. I think I liked Boneshaker a skosh more than Dreadnaught, and I'm really sorry I couldn't get my hands on a copy of Clementine. Thankfully, Ganymede comes out soon, and it's set in New Orleans! Yay for NOLA!

I could be wrong since I have not read them, but there are many other true steampunk novels to read for me to waste my time with posers.
hahahahaha
That sounds incredibly snide and mean. Sorry, that's not my intention to anyone - author included. Like I said, they could be great books, I'm just not giving them a chance.
I also agree about your assessment of Priest's novels. I have loved every single one of them and I think they epitomize steampunk right now. There is not a shred of magic or fantasy, the stories are science fiction, AND the characters are punk! That is a rare trait in steampunk these days.


Thanks!
Aaron

Thanks for the recommendation. I suspect there's a lot of unsung fiction out there that came out when steampunk wasn't yet a marketing category . . .
Books mentioned in this topic
The Janus Affair (other topics)The Parasol Protectorate: Soulless, Blameless, and Changeless (other topics)
Perdido Street Station (other topics)
Perdido Street Station (other topics)
The Strange Affair of Spring Heeled Jack (other topics)
More...
That's part of a series right? is it really good? I was gonna buy that, but I bought Airman and Leviathan instead. :D If it's really great, I'm gonna buy that next week.