Karen Chance Fans discussion
Series Discussions
>
Theories, Hypotheses and Conspiracies


It's hard to judge though, since we don't exactly see Dorina at her best. I think interesting times lie ahead!

So she might not care for the mind games that vamps seem to live for. So while she demands respect, she allows no room for vamps to weasel their way out. That should lead to some interesting problems, especially considering one of her family is Ray.



This protective instinct does seem at odds with a psycho vampire, which makes me think that Dorina's nowhere near as bad as Dory thinks she is. I'm not sure if Dorina just has a soft spot for the weak, or maybe it's some vampire instinct to create and protect a family. Any thoughts?


Fun times ahead!



It's possible, although I wonder if it was a pythia thing or a Cassie thing?


Rational as in she can converse, not rational as far as decision making or controlling her temper...

If, all my life, a group of people had slighted me (at best) or tried to kill me (at worst) I don't know if it'd be fair to judge me on my behaviour towards those people. And I think I'd be right to be angry with them or disdain them. In my opinion, anyway! :)

I think in the warehouse it was partially mixed in with Dory too... it was almost like the two personalities merged.

Dory is the one who doesn't like vamps---because they act like Dorina---and Mircea, Cleo, etc.

Must admit, I feel quite the opposite.
For sure Dory has her run-ins with vampires, but that's mostly because they're really nasty to her. But I think Dory almost secretly craves acceptance by vamps. If she hates them so much, why is she working with them? Why has she slept with some of them? Why is she dating one now? Why did she try to become vampire at one point?
I feel it's Dorina who really doesn't like vamps, and the root of it could be that same disparagement that Dory suffers. Dory shrugs it off, but first level master Dorina knows instinctively that she shouldn't be treated this way.
Some of Dorina's thoughts from early in Fury's Kiss ...
It was backing down. It was refusing challenge.
But vampires lied.
Note that LC is not a male, he's an 'it'. Also this ...
They always assumed that I did not speak. That I could not. So many had plotted my death, discussed it, laughed about it, while I was even in the room, because they assumed I was mindless. Like one of the failures of their kind, born mad.
But I was not a failure. I was what I was supposed to be. I was dhampir.
And they never lived to tell anyone they were wrong.
Mircea's thoughts on Dorina ...
"My contact with ... Dorina ... has been limited," Mircea said. "She does not trust me. I am what she preys upon."
It's possible 'hate' is too strong a word, but Dorina has no fondness or trust for vampires. I think this is something that'll come to the fore in the next book.

But I think this aspect of her personality could really affect Dory's relationship with LC. If a distinct distrust of all vampires starts to bleed into her conscious thoughts, it would make it harder to pursue the tenuous relationship she has going with LC. Then again, even Dorina was impressed by LC.

I got to thinking about the recently discussed theory that Caedmon might ally some of the Dark Fey, and here is this little Dark Fey who has become the companion, playmate and sometimes protector of Caedmon's heir.
So even if no one *was* looking for Stinky, he might soon be sought after for his royal connections. ?

From a narrative point of view, I feel the point of Stinky and Aidan's friendship is to show yet another bond between a dark and light fey. If the future king of the light fey grew up with a dark fey friend (and a dark fey mother), that's got to go some way toward removing the prejudice the light fey hold toward the dark. Caedmon says that in the end they're all fey and probably wants the prejudice gone, and Claire and Heidar wouldn't object either. I kinda see there being a big war between the fey (that's almost guaranteed) then afterwards many of the old divisions can start to be overcome. That's how it plays out in my head, at least!

The timeline of separating Dory’s 2 natures doesn’t fit.
1. It takes decades/centuries to reach master level (the narrative so far implies >100 years is the norm) longer still to be a senior master.
2. Only 1st level masters have special abilities/powers, some 2nd levels manifesting them early.
3. Mental abilities are rare and a special ability.
Mircea was a baby vampire throughout Dory’s childhood. This contradicts the above canon. 1st level Mircea has to travel back in time to fix Dory, to reconcile the discrepancies.




So, if that's correct, Mircea would be able to make his own vampires after being vamp for less than ten years. Allowing for a nine month pregnancy, Dory could easily have been only seven or eight years old when Drac was turned. I'm not sure there's any continuity issue here. Or maybe I'm not understanding it?
My impression was that the more powerful the vamp was destined to be, the more likely he/she was to develop early. I'm not certain about the special abilities that a first level master has. I was tending to assume those wouldn't show before second level, as I thought those were one of the pointers to being a first level master.
For reference, KC gives an outline of the vamp levels here (Question 2):
http://www.karenchance.com/news/qa-40-2/


Rereading RtW teaser chapters reminded me that Cassie seemed a bit confused interacting with Pritkin in 1793, as though she could not distinguish between him and 21st century Pritkin.
And when she got back, she was mad because he did not remember her (or did not let on if he did.
At the time I attributed her behavior to inexperience and ambivalence toward Pritkin.
But in RtW, as several people pointed out, he seemed oddly sophisticated about energy sharing and oddly trusting of the woman who robbed him before...
That got me thinking how easy it was for to take advantage of him the first time they met.
The easy answer is that he was attracted to her from the moment they first met.
Yet he had just come from hell, and he had just been ripped off on Earth. He should have been anything but trusting.
Especially the second time. He is very, very bright, so he must have caught on quickly in 1794 that she was trying to protect him, but still....
It's as though thereip is some sort of time leak between eras where those two are concerned, with maybe feelings leaking somehow between past and future....
I'm wondering about the significance of that, and what we'll see in the future, especially since there seems to be a similar anomaly with her mother. Same? Different? I'm not sure.
Anyone else thinking the same way?


I think if the Circle learned Pritkin was Merlin, this would raise his status quite significantly with them. The vamps may not be quite as enamoured, since they aren't magic users, but I guess they'd want a reasonable relationship with such an historic figure. I don't know if Pritkin finding acceptance and status on Earth would suit Rosier's agenda to have him as his heir/stud in the demon realm? I think he'd possibly much prefer Pritkin to be dismissed by everyone and maybe return with his tail between his legs (yeah, yeah, he'll be waiting a long time for that!)

Pritkin would **hate** it! Plus, all the dark mages and many of the Circle mages would be trying to kill him to get his magic.
He would hate the adulation almost more. So much, in fact, that he might "escape" back to Hell.
Besides, in one of his temper fits Rosier might do it without thinking.

I think it's funny on several instances when Rosier used Cassie and Pritkin's attaction to each other to try and get them to do the deed, either by saving Pritkins like or trying to get Pritkin to drain Cassie and go back to hell. There was the time Pritkin was dying because of the dragon blood working like acid on him, and he gave Cassie some sort of boost to make Pritkin have to feed. And then there was when Rosier did a spell that effected Pritkin and Cassie, the time she first noticed Pritkin had a twin and was checking his tattoo.
I want to know what will happen when Pritkin gets back, will he remember the difference in between what first happened and what happened after Cassie when back and affected his timeline? Or will he somehow lose a lot of his memory and that's part of why Adra and the demon council gave Cassie the counterspell, or if he didn't lost his memory and decides he wants to be with Cassie (a lot more than friends) what Rosier will do to try and break them up then? I think no matter what happens if Cassie gets a demon army and if her and Pritkin decide to take their relationship up a notch I think Rosier will continue to make trouble somehow.
Heck maybe Rosier will go to Mircea and plot with him that's it better for both of them if Pritkin and Cassie separate.


I think Rosier will soon be plotting again as soon as they get Pritkin back he'll probably try and undermind Cassie's already fragile relationship with the demons. I think Ming-de is a big bad and is planning something, not just for more power but there's something that happened or is on-going with Mircea. I think Jack's favor he asked Cassie since she told him she'd have to agree to it, might be him switching masters? Maybe he wants to be her personal guard because she's always in danger and getting a lot of action.
And maybe all that power Roger took for the black circle is because him and Artemis are planning something, not necessarily changing their history but something in the future? Maybe they have some allies somewhere we haven't see or heard of yet. It wouldn't be very smart of Artemis not to have allies with all the powerful enemies she has, and knowing she can't run or hide forever. I wonder if those two have an army stashed away.
Pritkin will be saved and in charge of the demon councils army, Cassie will find some other demigods and lead them, with her silver circle backers. Tony will spend a lot of time with Rasputin using the rogue initiates to mess things up trying to keep Cassie running around like a chicken with her head cut off trying to clean up or figure out what they're doing while they put their real end game into play and in enters Ares.

It didn't become obvious to me that Pritkin might really be the one till CtD. And it wasn't apparent that Cassie really was becoming aware until late in HtM.
HtM came out in June of 2011, so from our POV, we've known for over three years. But for Cassie that was just LAST WEEK!
The problem with KC being such a slow writer is that we have had all this time to become bored, blase, and apathetic in a way, while other readers have wandered away and forgotten about the whole series.
Still others would have to reread some or all of the novels to be able to catch up and keep up with the fast action in RtW...and they may not want to work that hard. Not all KC's readers are fangirls like us.
So I think the loooonnnnggg time between novels distorts our perception of time.

Kathleen wrote: "I thought the early relationship with Mircea *was* the feint to throw us off track."
You know, I can see both points of view here.
Kathleen, I agree that there was certainly misdirection at the start, where I think most would have said the love triangle would be between Mircea and Tomas, but by EtN it was obvious that Pritkin was being developed further (e.g. Cassie has a few lustful thoughts about him when they were back in Paris in 1793).
However, the thing that makes me wonder if Kristen's on the right track is the fact that (I believe) KC adores Mircea. I think he's her favourite character, and given that she's dropped a few hints about him (e.g. that we've barely scratched the surface of his story) convinces me that he's not going to quietly bow out the way Tomas has (for now, anyway). I know Mircea's in a slightly different position since he's an important crossover character in both the Dory and Cassie books, but I feel that there are big things in store for Mircea yet.
Another point we have to consider of course is the overall narrative of the story. KC's been quietly developing Pritkin's character and building tension between him and Cassie for several books, and that has to have some sort of pay-off or it all becomes pointless. So either Cassie and Pritkin have to get together, or there has to be some sort of dramatic development (like a death) to stop it. They can't just fizzle out and have Cassie decide to stay with Mircea. That makes no sense from a story-telling point of view.
To touch on some of Kristen's other comments:
About Jack, well he's on the Senate now, so he doesn't really have a master (beyond the Consul). He would have been emancipated by Augusta a while back, presumably.
On Ming-de, yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if she's got something up her sleeve. She has agreed to accept the war effort be governed by Cleo, but I can see her immediately plotting to turn this to her advantage somehow. And aren't new senate members Cheung and possibly ZZ her boys? She might use them to undermine the North American Senate in some way.
On Rosier, I can't see him and Mircea aligned somehow. Not that they won't have the same interests, but I don't think they could trust each other enough. Mircea expresses extreme distrust for demons in Hunt the Moon, and I'm sure he knows Rosier already tried to kill Cassie in EtN. I just can't see them co-operating to oust Pritkin from Cassie's life. Mircea would suspect a trap of some sort.
On Pritkin, whilst I agree he wouldn't enjoy or seek out the limelight, I don't think he'd run back to hell because of it. I think he'd simply disappear off on a mission for the Circle to some remote part of the world and lie low for a while. Or just yell at anyone who mentioned it!! I don't see it being any kind of dealbreaker for him.
With regard to Pritkin's memories and the timeline, I don't know if we can answer this yet. I'm hesitant to guess until we see what happens in RtW. It gets awfully complicated if Cassie's continually changing history, and in many ways it starts to undermine everything that's gone on before. How can we take Pritkin's first meeting with Cassie seriously if he's encountered her several times in the past already? Once is OK, but surely if there were a few meetings he'd remember? I think I want Pritkin to wake up on the Demon Council doorstep with all the memories he had from the moment he 'died' with nothing changed for him.
On Artemis, Roger and the Black Circle power, there's something fishy here. I'd thought at first that Roger was taking that power for Artemis, but now we know she can't use it, so it's not that. We've seen this type of power used by Jonathan the Mage. Was Roger using it to prolong his life? It states quite clearly in FK that using power in this manner is A Bad Thing, however given that Roger's dead, it feels like it should be a non-issue. I'm not so sure though. I think there's something else going on.

In RTW I know the demons will probably be an important part or at least make some kind of showing, but I wonder if Cassie will get to see/meet all the new senate members, maybe if she gets her demon army she'll have a meeting to tell them about it, rather than just having contact with the senate through Mircea. Marco's probably had to report how Cassie hasn't really been around much at the hotel, and that he saw her jump through a demon portal. Than there's the fact that no one has really questioned Pritkin's abscene and since he's her guard and always by her side even if they don't know that the two of them have a deeper relationship. Maybe Mircea has been too busy with Dory and the senate to deal with it, or maybe he's realizing Cassie is doing a pretty good job of taking care of herself and he's learning to trust her, and he might still have that tracking device on her so he know's she's still alive, and the senate is probably trusting Mircea to keep tabs on their allied pythia.
Also about the unwelcomed reception of Cassie going back in time when Roger and Artemis both knew she was their daughter, Cassie attributed it to be slightly because they can't miss a daughter they still had. But the fact that Cassie went back to them alone instead of asking their present selves should of let them know something was wrong, yet they didn't seem concerned they just wanted her gone. It's obvious their hiding something, neither one of them is who they appear to be and everything anyone knows about them are just the things they have heard, I'm wondering if they truly love Cassie as their daughter or if her existence will be used as something more to them. Artemis said something to Cassie her existence is born out of Chaos and fate not being controlled? And even though Artemis knows all about jumping around through time she was so surprised and started when she saw Cassie, almost instantly recognizing her as her daughter.
So in RTW will we find out more about Mircea and his motivation (things he's hiding) or do you think we'll see Cassie's parents again and get something on them?

I love your observations about Jack. I think that favour is going to be important too. Maybe Jack will ask Cassie to do something that seems fairly benign to her, only it ends up causing a lot of problems for Mircea ... as Jack knew it would! Mircea could be torn between wanting to blame Cassie (since vamps punish the one who caused the problem, regardless of where the true fault lies) and having to answer for her to the Senate.
Jack is an oddball. What's his agenda, if he even has one? We don't really know much about him, apart from his sicko pleasures. Although he's a senator, I don't get the feeling he's much liked or respected by the others. That could cause resentment. Is he truly loyal or could he be collaborating with the enemy like Lawrence? I'd like to know his real opinion of Mircea. Jack says all vamps are monsters, even the beautiful ones. Maybe there's some jealousy there, and Jack wishes he were as beautiful, powerful and successful as Mircea obviously is.
On Cassie and her trip to the demon realm, I wish we knew exactly how the timeline aligns with Fury's Kiss and when (or if) Mircea finds out about Cassie's little trip through a demon portal. If Marco & crew 'forget' to mention that, Mircea will go apeshit! It's possible that Mircea's wrestling with Lawrence in Dory's head right around this time, so there's no chance to tell him (and maybe when Cassie returns, all the vamps in her suite will be passed out from Mircea's power drain).
On Cassie's parents, I think we're going to see them again. I think we're only starting to get into what's going on with them. Every new book deepens the mystery around them, rather than enlightens. I think that comment about Cassie being a child of chaos is a statement about Artemis herself, not about Cassie. Artemis talks about how Cassie will change her fate if she goes to rescue Pritkin, but I think her initial comments (especially the bit about 'fate can be undone') is in reference to herself. It feels like this whole conversation between Cassie and her mother should have a neon arrow pointing at it with 'Clue' flashing in big letters LOL! We can really dig into this when we do the Tempt the Stars re-read in a couple of weeks. I'm hoping when our hive mind gets to work we might have some new theories!
Finally on RtW, KC did say there will be more Mircea in the book, and obviously the timeline will catch up with FK so we should see something of the scene in Cleo's house from Cassie's POV. It's not so much the retelling of that scene itself that I'm interested in (though it'll be fun to get Cassie's thoughts!) but it's the aftermath of the scene. And the 'beforemath' LOL! How does Cassie get there? How does she find out that Mircea nearly died? What will be the conclusion of the book (another cliffhanger?, a declaration of outright war?, the return of Ares? the rogue Myras doing something?) So many things could happen!!

I'm also wondering more about the bond Mircea told Cassie they have together, if it's only one way and what information can they get from it when their apart.
I'd like to get a scene between Cassie and Radu. They've met that once, but I don't know how much he remembers about it. And when he told Dory that Mircea went back and changed time so that Radu didn't end up insane and ended up turning LC he never mentioned Cassie at all. Perhaps this is deliberate on his part. Casanova knows about Dory and never mentioned her to Cassie and we know how much he likes to complain.
Artemis may have been extremely weak for a goddess living on Earth but she was a heck of a lot stronger than Cassie or Agnes. I wonder if she can travel to the future? Why did she stop going to the demon realm to feed and regain some strength? Maybe because of the spell she cast she can no longer open the door between realms.

Cassie must have arrived at the Consul's place and visited Mircea in his room (not sure whether she'd feed him, though it probably doesn't matter really) then she must have left for a bit, maybe to go for food, or a snooze, or even a quick trip back to Vegas? Then she returns to Mircea's room and sees Dory. She knows where his room is and she doesn't seem to be accompanied by anyone, so she's obviously been there before. After being dumped in the field and stealing a car to get back home, Dory reckoned she'd been out for the best part of 24 hours, so there was plenty of time for Cassie to have been hanging about. There must be some chat between Cassie and Cleo as well surely, because you don't just sneak in and out of the Consul's house without saying hi! Maybe Cassie sees Radu here and re-introduces herself? I'd like to see another scene between them too. I wonder if Radu will treat her in that offhand way of his, which can sometimes seem rude, but it's really more absent-minded. I kinda want to laugh if Cassie's dissed by Radu AND Dory!
I want to know what happens after this scene, specifically about the Senate induction. There seemed to be two ceremonies for the new Senators. The main one, where Cheung and ZZ are welcomed, then a second one for Dory alone. Unless she was hiding at the back somewhere, I'm fairly sure Cassie wasn't there at Dory's induction, but she might have been there for the main one (which Dory missed). Having a Pythia present might be something the Senate could brag about, so Cassie would be welcome to witness the event. However, if she were furious at Mircea, she might have taken off before then. Hopefully we'll find out in RtW.
On Artemis and power, it says somewhere that once she created the spell to lock out the other gods, it also served to lock her in, so she wasn't able to leave to travel to other realms to feed. I don't know if she can travel to the future, but I think it's quite possible. KC has been very cagey about this, so I'm taking that as a clue that it might happen. Maybe Cassie can't, but Artemis was able to, at one point at least. Maybe she travelled ahead in time but never saw a daughter, and that's why she was so surprised at seeing Cassie? That would also explain all the comments about fate being undone. Her fate was to remain childless, but she somehow thwarted it and had Cassie?

Cassie tends to put more focus on one specific thing, I think it's part of an excuse to put a lot of issues she needs to think/talk/work-through on the backburner and avoid them. Maybe when she found out Mircea was injured that put the talk her and Pritkin need to have about their feelings and relationship behind. Or maybe they already have the talk and the reason why Cassie seems shocked but not truly angry at finding the other woman (Dory) in that sitation with Mircea was because she already dumped him. Then they wouldn't have to talk about all the things they have been keeping from each other as a couple/trust issue, because they'd just be allies,his job as a senator and her's as a pythia, and we know those two titles are bound to keep loads of secrets from each other.
It makes sense if Artemis did travel to the future and saw herself childless and then Cassie shows up which is why she makes those statements and is all surprised. Though Cassie had helped Agnes capture Roger whom Agnes returned to her court where supposedly Artemis met him, therefore they became a couple and had Cassie, I wonder how it was suppose to happen if Cassie hadn't travel back in time to talk to another pythia?Does that mean Cassie wouldn't have been born? Also I think we went over the Cassie's mom and dad timeline of when we know they met and when Cassie's mom said they met and it didn't match up. Could they be lying for some reason? Like could Roger and Artemis have met before in the past? Even farther back and started making plans, maybe that's why he joined up with that cult group, they had found a way to travel back in time, than later he worked with the black circle? Why did he really join up with those two groups he didn't really seem like the type to believe either spiel. Roger's packing some power, he's smart, yet his outward appearance is anything but impressive along with how he acts. Maybe what Roger shows everyone but Cassie's mom is an act to hide something about himself. There has to be a reason he tricked and outsmarted those two groups he joined, and a reason Artemis ended up being with him specifically.

I love the idea that Cassie and Pritkin have already had 'the talk' and that she's committed to him now, so seeing Dory only serves to reaffirm that she made the right choice. I still feel Cassie's behaviour was less than admirable, even though it was an amusing scene, so I want to hear her POV and her justifications to herself.
There are just soooooo many questions about Roger and Artemis. The whole thing is screwy. I was thinking about that timeline inconsistency the other day, i.e. how Artemis supposedly met Roger after Agnes captured and imprisoned him for being a member of the Guild (the parliament scene), yet Agnes herself says, in the very same scene, that her heir had already run off by this point. This is such a glaring inconsistency! I can't believe this is an oversight by KC because it screws up everything, so I think there's something bigger going on. There's another inconsistency in Hunt the Moon, with how Roger recognises Cassie when she and Mircea travel back to the party in the 80s so Cassie could have a look at her mother. Artemis clearly hasn't run off yet, since she's there with Agnes, so the parliament scene hasn't happened. Yet Roger recognises Cassie and lets out a little scream, then all hell breaks loose. Could Cassie have accidentally made a big change to the timeline by going to this party? Maybe Artemis & Roger weren't planning to run off then, but Cassie's visit changed that, and this is where all the comments about Fate and Chaos come from?
Roger's association with the Guild and the Black Circle is confusing. He talks about ghost armies in Tempt the Stars, so maybe the Black Circle power was for them, but I don't get the Guild connection at all. However, all the time I'd read the books in the past, I was working off the basic assumption that Cassie's parents were Good People, and all my impressions were based on that conjecture. I'm honestly not sure if that opinion is correct any more, and I should probably revise my beliefs! I do think that, whatever they're up to, Roger and Artemis are in it together, so she would know (and presumably approve) of everything he's done. I definitely have the impression that they've known each other for longer than 25(ish) years, though the text doesn't entirely back that up. I think they've told Cassie a pack of lies about their 'meeting' and they may have good reasons for this (i.e. to protect the world or something like that) or they've lied because they have their own agenda. Artemis seemed far more caring and, well, motherly in Hunt the Moon than she did in Tempt the Stars. There's certainly more to come on these two.

It might not be important but Roger definitely didn't like Agnes though Cassie's mom mentioned she thought she was a good woman, yet she still ran away with Roger knowing somehow the bad guys were closing in. Okay so Cassie goes back in time and helps Agnes capture Roger, he goes back to her court where he meets Artemis. Artemis helps him escape and he comes for her at that party where they run away together. And since Roger recognized Cassie at that party and freaked he probably thought she was with Agnes's court in some way. And that's how Cassie's mom told her they met, so maybe the problem is with Agnes? Agnes had told Cassie when they captured Roger than gave her ward to Cassie's mom who took it and ran off with some loser, but she didn't mention the loser was the guy she brought in from the guild, obviously because she hadn't caught him yet. Maybe Cassie's mom saw that Cassie would somehow need the ward in the future to survive the ley line exploding among other things and that's why she had borrowed it from Agnes and ran, so she didn't have to give it back. Maybe she knew she'd one day have a child from a vision or visiting the future and the reason she was so surprised was that it meant she survived the sons of Ares coming after her, and hey she ended up having her future daughters help to do it! I wonder if the memory lapse Agnes had is the timeline correcting itself and maybe bleeding through a little? Or maybe we're dealing with two different Agnes's, the one Cassie met when she helped capture Rogers was from farther in the future then the one she saw with her mother at that party? To one Agnes her mom had already run off, and to the other at the party it didn't happen yet. My brains having troubles thinking this thing through, so I don't know if that makes sense.

On the timeline inconsistency, I hadn't really thought about the ward itself being important, but I like your ideas, and this is perhaps exactly the sort of thing that Artemis might have foreseen. And the ward arguably saved Cassie's life right at the very beginning of TtD, when those vamps attacked Cassie and Tomas at the nightclub. But I still don't know how we get round the basic sticking point of Agnes telling Cassie her heir has run off. How can she have already run away with the guy Agnes is about to introduce her to! I'm starting to think that maybe it's not Agnes, but perhaps there are two Rogers kicking around the timeline, but my head does not want to go there!!!
I wrote this out before, but I find it helps to get things straight so I'm doing it again. From Agnes's POV, the timeline is as follows:
In the 80s (based on the dresses), Agnes attends a party with her heir, Artemis. Cassie and Mircea gatecrash the party, and Artemis runs away with Roger that same night.This just doesn't make sense! I think Cassie's going to do something in a future book that changes time. Or, perhaps, her visit to that party with Mircea already changed time? Roger shouldn't have been able to recognise Cassie at the party, since the parliament scene hasn't happened yet, but since Cassie's now visited her parents once, she may well visit them again (or encounter Roger, at least) and maybe that's how he recognises her. But none of this gets round the basic problem of Agnes's statements directly contradicting Artemis's. One of them is either lying or time has changed. I don't see any real reason for Agnes lying to Cassie, especially as she seemed quite horrified at the hints Cassie was dropping about the future. Artemis, on the other hand, could easily be lying, or maybe misdirecting might be a better word.
Some time after this (maybe a year or two, or more?), Agnes travels back to the Houses of Parliament in the early 1600s. She meets Cassie and says that her heir has run off. This scene MUST take place after the party from Agnes's POV, because Artemis is gone and Agnes is now training Myra.
During this same scene, she captures Roger and takes him back to her present time. Then Roger and Artemis supposedly meet for the first time, fall in love and run away together.
On Roger disliking Agnes, that could simply be down to the fact that she imprisoned him and I think she has a sharp tongue. I sorta took his attitude to be more like a guy moaning about his mother-in-law. But, there could easily be more to it than we know.

Okay so maybe the time line issues are just due to so many people going back and confusing things and the timeline is doing its best to clean things up, I might think of something else later at some point, but right now I've looked at it from all the angels I could think of.
Also Cassie had a lot of people trying to kill her before when they thought she was just in the running for pythia, then she became pythia and I guess they stepped up their game,but now everyone knows she's Artemis's daughter the one who put up the spell the bad guys want to take down. Like they didn't need a reason to kill her enough before. Also I think it's sort of ironic before Jonas was back in charge how the majority of the circle was willing to bash Cassie not only because she was raised by vamps but also because of the rumors they had about Roger being a powerful leader of the black circle, only to come back around and see that she's the daughter of the reason their organization even exists and the one who "saved" in essence the humans. Instead of bribes Cassie should be getting a lot of appologies, though she hasn't received any yet. While going through the books again it's kind of upsetting how many people treat her so badly, even when she is pythia she is slightly discarded by a young human girl who doesn't know anything, and only her title is important, not the things she has done or the role she has played in fighting the good fight and bringing down the bad guys. She need's some R-E-S-P-E-C-T. Even in TTS Jonas keeping things from her was a slap in the face, she's still getting a lot of those. I'd love to see the scene where Cassie can tell the senate and consul she has demon allies (maybe she should see if the squid face demon lord would mind paying a courtesy call to Ming-de?)
If Cassie ever gets some time she should go back through time on the basis of collecting information she needs to know alone. It's time to play hard ball and dig up everything she can on Mircea, get some more information on her mom and dad, a few others? Ya know pull a Marlowe move just in case, it's worked out for him.
Myra was bad enough she constantly outsmarted Cassie, and even after all she has done Cassie couldn't bring herself to take care of the situation at the end Agnes did. Now there are 5 of these evil powerful girls running around, the kind who could murder the children they once helped take care of. I'm more worried about what they're going to do then Ares, I just don't see how Cassie's going to be able to keep up with them, or stop them.
Yeah, agree. I think Dorina is very prickly about getting the respect she deserves. Possibly that's a reason why she dislikes most vampires? They always slight her (well, slight Dory at least) and it infuriates her.
I think Dory/Dorina's merging is going to be a focus of the next book. I'm really curious to see how it comes about and to see how it changes Dory.