The Fault in Our Stars
discussion
Am I the only one who didn't cry that much?
message 51:
by
Oz
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Aug 21, 2013 03:33PM

reply
|
flag


me, too!! when I wasn't crying, i was always on the verge:_(


Same here. I knew either Hazel or Augustus was going to die, and since Hazel was the main character, I had a hunch it would be Augustus. It was sad, but slightly predictable.

yeah I felt really weird when all my friends who had read the book said they cried through the whole book


Agreed. I would have been pissed if Green had tried to spring his death on us at the very end, like a "surprise twist" or something. Even though it was predictable, I think it was almost SUPPOSED to be, in a way, and that Green handled that much more eloquently than he could have.
It was actually quite a weird read for me, the first time I read it I thought it was good, yes, but I wasn't sure why all the hype (and I didn't cry)...but it's kind of grown on me. I reread bits of it a couple of times, and now I think it's an excellent and really well-written book. (Still didn't cry, though.)






when she told me that, i felt "OMG! I know if she dont love books as I am but pleaseeee dont spoiled with meeee!" but in reality I just "oh thanks you told me before"
So when I finished this book, I felt nothing, just "oh, he died, oh same like my friend told me" haha


Personal oponion.Maybe I'm just weird,who knows...





I feel you! haha :) the characters of LFA were also sooo amazing. I mean Pudge, Alaska, The Colonel, Takumi. All individual, unique characters. & the dialogues were in so many ways better than the ones in TFIOS. The whole story, the characters, the plot twists & everything would've made such a great movie. I think LFA was in some way even more sad than TFIOS. the way that Pudge never really could reach Alaska was heartbreaking to me. But maybe one day there'll be a movie as well.

Yes you're right! Thought I was the only one ;)


I feel exactly the same way you do. I also think that this book really isn't as great as people keep saying it is. I didn't shed a tear even. It was sad and all, but people kind of exaggerate the sadness of the ending.

Was I a little down as a reader when Augustus died? Of course. As a human I can feel human emotions and having a 17 year old kid who was in remission die of cancer kind of sucks. But I did not cry.

You just wrote what I couldn't articulate - Thank you!


I didn't even cry.
A love story of two teenager cancer patients. Sounds like an instant bestseller recipe to me. Emotional blackmail stuff.

The book is good just not as good as media and people make it out to be. I think it might be because all the time I thought Hazel wasn't portrayed as a girl as much in depth as she should be?
Do you know what I mean? Like her feelings toward Gus weren't explicit enough from the feminine perspective. Would it be because the author in fact is male? I don't know.. It would, however, very interesting to read Gus' version of events.

Me too, I didn't cry, I felt like I already knew that someone was going to die and I'm not obsessed with it either. It was a good book though.

But TFIOS is really a heart warmer.




People die everyday and Mr.fictional Gus was not one of them..so ...ennhh...Plus I'm a grown ass man, what do you expect. It was sad enough that I chose to read a glittery love story about teens.



all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
De Profundis (other topics)
Paper Towns (other topics)
Flat-Out Love (other topics)
The Fault in Our Stars (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Nevermore (other topics)De Profundis (other topics)
Paper Towns (other topics)
Flat-Out Love (other topics)
The Fault in Our Stars (other topics)