Victorians! discussion
This topic is about
The Pickwick Papers
Archived Group Reads 2013
>
Pickwick - No. IV - chs. IX-XI
date
newest »
newest »
I just love the word eloped. I wonder why Mr. Pickwick was given the manuscript of the Madman. And I wonder about Mr. Pickwick: is he the great man the narrator keeps calling him? It appears his greatness is tinged with a layer of sarcasm. I have been having this idea from the beginning, but the final pages of the ninth chapter convinced me of it. It appears he mistook a simple stone (which is naturally ancient as all stones are) with an inscription made by a simple man, for an antiquity. His greatness appears to be derived from the support he gets from society, not from his having made a great discovery.
I think they're all a bit of a humbug. Although Pickwick is usually kind and benevolent, he also seems to have quite a temper, and not always rationally. Winkle is far from being the expert sportsman he pretends to be, Snodgrass never seems to write any poetry, and Tupman has bad luck with the ladies.
I also loved the story about the old stone! How all the experts wrote so many papers about it. I have to admit that I was mystified by the inscription myself, until Pickwick's rival pointed out what it really said. Of course, even though he must have been right, especially as the man who carved it told him, he was reviled and kicked out, for going against the great Pickwick!


In this section, we are introduced to Sam Weller, a servant at the White Hart, who will become a very important character in the story.