appendix

[David]

Do you regard an appendix at the end of a novel (and not a classic, but a new scifi) as a sign of weak writing? Meaning, if they need an appendix to explain their technology/governments/lineages than they weren't writing effectively. Thoughts?

[mark, personal space invader]

no, I usually appreciate such things. although it will often mean that I will appreciate the novel itself for its world-building and narrative rather than for its prose style or themes. not sure why that is or why I've found that connection, but there it is.

[[deleted user]]

I honestly never understood why someone would think that inclusion of an Appendix was a sign of weak writing. I’ve read some fantastic novels that include an Appendix or even a cast of characters (some of Peter F. Hamilton’s novels come to mind). Weak and lazy writing will be apparent when you read the book, not because it does or does not have an appendix.

[Kevis]

David wrote: "Do you regard an appendix at the end of a novel (and not a classic, but a new scifi) as a sign of weak writing?"

Absolutely not. The best writers create a universe so rich that it requires exploration beyond the pages of the books in order to get a proper glimpse at its scope. The appendices at the end of Herbert's Dune is among the first that comes to mind.

[Mickey]

Absolutely!

I have no wish to keep flipping to the back of the book to see what a special word means. If a made up word is used, put that word in the context of the sentence so it make sense. Or describe the newly made object in the world/ character build.

After all, someone has to be the antagonist :)

[Kevis]

Mickey wrote: "Absolutely!

I have no wish to keep flipping to the back of the book to see what a special word means...After all, someone has to be the antagonist :) ."

LOL. Touche'. :)